Cambodia: Vietnam War and Indochinese War Essay

Submitted By austinso
Words: 2071
Pages: 9
Open Document
Conflict in Indochina Assessment

Assess the strategies and tactics used during the second Indochinese war.

To focus solely on the military strategies of the second Indochinese war is to limit one’s understanding of the complicated and unconventional nature of a war not open to purely military solutions. As discussed below, it seems apparent that it was the ability of the Communists, under consistent and unified leadership, to effectively combine their strategic and tactical efforts in the political, military, and diplomatic dimensions of the war which lead to their eventual victory.

Leaders from all sides of the second Indochinese war have emphasized the importance of the different strategic and tactical dimensions in a ‘comprehensive system’ of warfare. Truong Chinh (a leading member of the North Vietnamese government) wrote that resistance “must be carried out in every field: military, economic, political and cultural”1. Vo Nguyen Giap (a general of the Vietminh) observed that “the fight against the enemy on all fronts – military, political, cultural, diplomatic, and so forth – is waged at the same time”2 and even Lyndon Johnson (the American President) argued that the second Indochinese war was “not just a jungle war, but a struggle for freedom on every front of human activity.”3

The strategies and tactics of the political dimension of the second Indochinese war varied between both sides. The Americans looked to destroy their “opponent’s military capability to wage war” as, to them, the enemies’ “will to continue the struggle is irrelevant … [when] the means to that end are no longer available.”4 To achieve this, and in keeping with the American Containment policy, Johnson pledged “military and economic assistance [to] South Vietnam and Laos” for the “purpose of helping these countries to repel aggression and strengthen their independence”5 in his 1964 Speech to Congress. However, he largely disregarded “the crux of the problem [which] lay in the Saigon government’s inability to mobilize the people and pacify the country…[and] the absence of a [united] political community in South Vietnam”6 because, as Hoffman argues, “one’s success in reaching one’s end depends almost decisively on the solidity of the political base on which one operates.”7

America’s lack of political strategy and aid to South Vietnam meant that it continued to be a politically fragile state and “this fragility gave Hanoi the ability to continue rupturing the South.”8 It has, in fact, been argued by Gertner that it was this unstable “political terrain of Vietnam [which was the] characteristic that doomed United States efforts”9 as it allowed for the spread of Communist and nationalist sympathizing and opportunities for infiltration by Communist and nationalist agents. Thus the impact of the lack of American political strategy in dealing with South Vietnam and the significance of the political dimension of the second Indochinese war to its eventual outcome is highly apparent.

Indeed, for the Vietnamese Communists and the NLF, “the political dimension of people’s war was particularly significant”10 because they were “lacking the technological capability or the basic resources” to destroy the enemy’s military capability and therefore “must of necessity aim to destroy his political capability.” Because, as Mack argues, “if the external power’s will to continue the struggle is destroyed, then its military capability – no matter how powerful – is totally irrelevant.” 11

Truong Chinh maintained that “military action can only succeed when politics are correct”12 and for the Vietnamese Communists and Nationalists political strategy was certainly important to success. The NLF was the political organization which provided the power base of both Communists and non-Communist nationalists in South Vietnam; “it was a political force that fought… for the minds of the people.”13 Because of its power base in the ‘ordinary people’ of South
Show More

Related Documents: Cambodia: Vietnam War and Indochinese War Essay

Policy Brief （Cambodia） Essay

Policy Brief （Cambodia） Part One: Strategic Objectives (in order of importance) A. vita interests: ①.Post-colonial focus on preserving independence. ②.Preserve neutrality so as not to “import” the war B. peripheral interests: ①.Limit Communist influence in Cambodia. ②. Prevent Communist guerrillas inside Cambodia from coming to power③.Seek a peaceful settlement to the Indochinese wars. Part Two: Your Team’s Actions and Reactions As a result of growing war in neighboring South Vietnam, we declare…

Words 345 - Pages 2

Summary: The First Indochinese War

2008)The first Indochinese war, was a Nine year war, against the Vietnamese and the French. At the beginning of the twentieth century areas of the world were under control of foreign powers. The world’s foreign powers had the benefits of imperialism. In the second half of the twentieth century, many people fought political, military and social battles to gain independence from colonial rule of the country. In Indochina, the peoples of the the areas of Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam fought to gain independence…

Words 939 - Pages 4

Hamlet: Cold War and ho Chi Minh Essay examples

TERMS CHAPTER 27 “CHILLS AND FEVER DURING THE COLD WAR” Harry Truman/Dwight Eisenhower – personal styles, views 875, 876 Joseph Stalin/Nikita Khrushchev --‐ styles, views 876, 877 Potsdam Conference 877, 878 Stalin Speech/Churchill’s Iron Curtain Speech response, 1946 878 George Kennan 878 Containment Policy – Alarmed by the expansion of Soviet power into Central Europe and Asia, the US acted to keep the Soviets from gaining control…

Words 832 - Pages 4

Vietnam War Research Paper

The Vietnam War causes started at the end of World War II. Vietnam is a strip of land on the eastern part of the Indochinese Peninsula in Southeast Asia. Before the war Bao Dai was the emperor of Vietnam from 1926 to 1945. A French colony called Indochina which includes Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia had been controlled by the Japanese during World War II because in 1940 the French surrendered their control to Japan. Ho Chi Minh then created the League for the Independence of Vietnam, also called Viet…

Words 1058 - Pages 5

Vietnam War Essay

Introduction……………………………………………………………………………… 2 Causes of the war…………………...…………………………………………………… 3 United States Involvement in the war………………………………………………….. 4 The Vietcong……………………………………………………………………………. 5 Australia Involvement in war…………………………………………………………… 7 The Vietnam War Timeline……………………………………………………………. 9 The War Aftermath…………………………………………………………………….. 10 Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………. 11 Works Cited…………………………………………………………………………….. 13 Vietnam War Introduction The Vietnam War took place between 1955…

Words 3352 - Pages 14

Essay Unit 12 Cornell Notes Chapters 29 and 30 MARGARET TEBBE

Unit 12: Civil Rights and Vietnam Chapter 29.1: Taking on Segregation KEY TERMS Brown v. Board of Education NOTE TAKING AREA ● In this case, the father of eight­year­old Linda Brown had charged the board of education of Topeka, Kansas, with violating Linda’s rights by denying her admission to an all­white elementary school four blocks from her house. The nearest all­black elementary school was 21 blocks away. ● In a landmark verdict the Supreme Court struck down school segregation as a slam on the 14th…

Words 3242 - Pages 13