Essay on Certainty

Words: 3325
Pages: 14
Open Document
F3:2.1: CERTAINTY OF OBJECTS & DISCRETIONARY TRUSTS 1. Introduction: The Purpose of the Certainty of Objects Requirement

- For a Trust to exist, A must: (i) hold a specific claim-right or power; and (ii) be under a duty to B not to use that claim-right or power for A’s own benefit (unless and to the extent that A is also a beneficiary of the Trust). In other words, for a Trust to exist, A must be under the core Trust duty. The certainty requirements for a Trust simply reflect the fact that A must be under a duty to B in relation to a specific right. The certainty of objects requirement ensures that: (i) A owes a duty to a specific person; and (ii) A’s duty is certain enough to be enforced. The certainty of objects requirement can …show more content…
Sachs and Megaw LJJ both dealt with that point by saying that the onus is on X to prove that claim; until X does so, it must be assumed that X does not share an ancestor with A0.6 The approach of Sachs and Megaw LJJ (assuming X is out of the permitted class, unless and until X can show otherwise) seems to make the “any given person” test redundant. For example, if A0 tries to set up a discretionary Trust in which A has a power to distribute the benefit of a right to anyone who is a “good person”, we might expect A0’s attempt to fail: there is no way for a court to tell if X is or is not a “good person”. However, on the approach of Sachs and Megaw LJJ, we could instead say that the discretionary Trust is valid – it is just that, if X cannot prove he is a “good person”, it will be assumed that he is not such a person. It seems that neither Sachs LJ nor Megaw LJ wanted to leave the law in such a way as to permit there to be a discretionary Trust in favour of anyone who is a “good person”. So each judge added a further certainty requirement. Sachs LJ stated that the class of those to whom A can distribute the benefit of A’s right must be “conceptually certain”: that is, it must be possible to come up with a definition of the class.7 Practical, evidential problems as to whether X is or is not within that
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Certainty

Danger Of Certainty

causes society to loses its creativity; and with that, the ability to grow and improve. The dangers of certainty have presented themselves on multiple occasions throughout history. Several instances where civilians dogmatically followed the ideologies of someone with higher authority and were severely burdened by the consequences they resulted in can be seen through numerous past events. While certainty has its place in some settings, doubt is of greater importance for the progress of humanity and scientific…

Words 701 - Pages 3

Descartes Certainty

Ultimately, certainty refers to having the purest form of truth. To have certainty is to have reached a conclusion of truth about the world as we perceive it. However the ways to interpret certainty differ completely, for example the views of certainty between Descartes and Spinoza are not at all similar. In Meditations and Other Metaphysical Writings Quotes, Descartes does not at all support the notion of certainty. Descartes has a rather cold approach to the idea of certainty, for he treats it…

Words 223 - Pages 1

Certainty And Doubt Research Paper

The relationship between certainty and doubt are associated with one another. Typically with certainty there is an inevitable sense of doubt; it is a balance. This is the opinion of British author, mathematician, and philosopher Bertrand Russell. In the society of today doubt is looked upon in a negative light. American citizens do not want the leaders of this nation to doubt their decisions. Certainty is imperative in establishing credibility and doubt generates results. If scientists' did not doubt…

Words 758 - Pages 4

Certainty and Flexibility in Judicial Precedent Essay

It is often believed that the relationship between certainty and flexibility in judicial precedent has struck a fine line between being necessary and being precarious. The problem is that these two concepts of judicial precedent are seen as working against each other and not in tandem. There is proof, however, that as contrasting as they are on the surface they are actually working together to achieve one common goal. Judicial precedent in its broad definition is the process by which judges follow…

Words 1396 - Pages 6

PHL550 - First Essay

whether certainty is necessary for knowledge (beginning, page 11) and end up discussing a lottery with long odds. Briefly summarize the lottery argument and critically evaluate whether it has the implication argued for by Skip. If Skip is right, what implications might there be, and are they acceptable? In this essay, I will be discussing a debate that begins in “The First Conversation” from Jay Rosenberg's Three Conversations About Knowing, on the issue of whether knowledge requires certainty. This…

Words 1176 - Pages 5

Humans...who are they? Essay

The two virtues, certainty and doubt are very controversial. The doubt somebody has can cloud their judgment but it can also guide them in making a better decision. On the other hand, certainty can blind someone from seeing their true colors of something. In our modern society, doubt is looked down upon; or viewed as a negative idea. Doubt doesnt always contradict certainty, but instead somewhere in between. We have been and always will be afraid of certainty. Generations upon generations…

Words 383 - Pages 2

The Great Influenza Rhetorical Analysis

times through his passage to enlighten readers on scientific research. Barry opens his entire passage with the use of an anaphora. He reveals the importance of certainty regarding scientists and their research by stating, “Certainty creates strength. Certainty gives one something upon which to lean.” The repeat of the word “certainty” accentuates to the reader of Barry’s book that a scientist needs to be certain of himself to exceed. Barry proceeds using…

Words 577 - Pages 3

The Stranger Essay

acceptance of his fate that causes Meursault’s friends, the lawyers, and the chaplain to think of him as detached from society and even amoral. But is it this same acceptance of fate that allows Meursault to be truly happy once he reflects on the certainties in his life while isolated inside prison. From the beginning of The Stranger, Meursault displays emotional detachment from those around him. He does not cry at his mother’s funeral, has sex and is willing to marry Marie without displaying or mentioning…

Words 1222 - Pages 5

Vti Limited: The Need For Change In VTI Limited

BUS 744 Organizational Change Assessment 1 Individual Case study : VTI Limited The need for change in VTI Ltd. Change is everywhere. In fact change is one of the constant thing there is to ex,kist. For some cases change will be inevitable yet human beings are not always in the same part of a coin. We are different from each other, even twins have their own unique skills…

Words 1699 - Pages 7

Cesare Beccaria Deterrence Theory

Deterrence theory believes that people choose to obey or violate the law after calculating the gains and consequences of their action (Beccaria, Page15). Deterrence theory has three main elements. Those three elements are certainty, severity, and celerity. Certainty, the most important of the three, refers to the punishment being unavoidable and takes place right after the act is committed. Beccaria believed that if people know that their criminal acts will be punished, they will avoid criminal…

Words 547 - Pages 3