Children of Lesbian Mothers Article Review Essay

Submitted By yat225
Words: 1205
Pages: 5
Open Document
Children of Lesbian Mothers: How They Perceive Their Donors
Y. A. Taylor
University of Missouri-Kansas City

In the article I reviewed, an exploratory study was done on eleven young adults, ages 19-29 years of age, who have been raised by lesbian parents to gain a better understanding of how they perceive their donor, negotiate a relationship with him, and what ideas they may have about him in the familial form. The study was initiated to young adults, age 14-29, with Lesbian, Gay or Bisexual (LGB) parents primarily via listserv announcements and Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender or Queer (LGBTQ) Centers on college campuses throughout the United States. According to Author Abbie Goldberg (2013), participants were informed that the study was to gain a better ‘understanding of their perspectives on marriage (in)equality, as well as their experiences growing up in LGB parent-families in general.’ The focus of the analysis was centered around the following interview questions: “What type of family situation where you born/adopted into? Who do you consider your parents? What is the sexual orientation of each of your parents? Of your donor? Tell me about your relationship with each parent, and with the donor?” (Goldberg, 2013, p. 342).
In the past, little research has explored the relationships children have and the views they may have of their donors. What has been examined included a small study of children ages 4-11, conceived via a known donor, and their lesbian mothers. In total, eleven subjects participated in this particular study. The participants were interviewed about what role the donor played in the child’s life. Of the eleven participants, two of them indicated that the donor played no role in the child’s life. Of the nine whose donors were involved, four indicated the donor’s role was that of “acting like a father.” There was less agreement in the other five cases between the mother and child due to a variety of reasons surrounding donor’s involvement.
It appears that lesbian parents tend to be more open with their children regarding their conception and the use of a donor in that process, compared to straight parents (Goldberg, 2013).
Method
Eleven participants, ages 19-29 participated in the study. All participants were born in and resided in the United States at the time of the study. All participants were born to lesbian mothers via known sperm donors. Ten of the eleven participants were born to 2 lesbian mothers in committed relationships, one was born to a single lesbian mother who intentionally co-parented the child with a former girlfriend. Ten of the eleven participants stated their mothers chose their donors based on an existing relationship. In seven of those ten cases, the donor was specified as a male friend. In the other three of those ten cases, the donor was specified as being the husband or male partner of a female friend. Nine of the eleven participants identified their donor’s sexual orientation. In seven of the nine cases, he was identified as being heterosexual, in the other two cases he was identified as being gay. In regards to gender, eight participants identified as female, two as male and one as queer. In regards to race, ten participants identified as White, one as multiracial. The only data obtained on the participants’ parents was their education levels. One mother had a high school diploma, two completed some college, ten had a bachelor’s degree, five had a master’s degree and four had a doctoral degree.
After a semi-structured in-depth telephone interview, the focus of the analysis was how the participants perceived their donors or the relationships they had with them. Each interview was analyzed and coded. Terms like “donor’s role” was replaced with three more specific codes: (a) donor only; (b) extended family member; (c) father/parent” (Goldberg, 2013). The coding was revised seven times.

Results
Nine of the eleven participants
Show More

Related Documents: Children of Lesbian Mothers Article Review Essay

The Importance Of Equality In The United States

and allow discrimination. Such as bans on allowing same sex couples to jointly adopt. Some people don’t accepted same sex couples therefore they definitely don’t want them raising children. Some people are opposed to same-sex adoption because they fear that children raised by homosexuals…

Words 817 - Pages 4

Shelby Inquiry and Research Essay

surrounding gay and lesbian parenting and also showcase numerous cases where same sex parents raise successful and well-rounded children. “For the most part, we’re just like any other couple; we have the same ups and downs, we have the same hope to build a future and family together,” says Gary Stein sitting along side his long time partner Jeff Lutes. (Lee) The Lutes-Stein family is one of the many headed by a same-sex couple in Texas. Married in the presence of their three adopted children on the first…

Words 2610 - Pages 11

Gay Adoption Essay

Maria Gomes November 04, 2014 Adoption There are thousands of children in America who are waiting to be adopted. Right now there is a shortage of families and couples who are willing to adopt. However there are gay couples, who want to help reduce that shortage, but face many red flags. Most conservatives believe that gay couples should not be giving the rights to adopt. Some states even have laws that prevent them from adopting. Same sex- couples are just like regular couples; yet it is not easy…

Words 993 - Pages 4

Cervical Cancer: Annotated Bibliography

prevention. This article will be used to access attitudes and knowledge on cervical cancer for women as it relates to vaccination (prevention), as well as look at common barriers to accessing prevention interventions and treatment for different female minorities.…

Words 952 - Pages 4

The Struggles Of Being Gay In America

ignored. Failure to take action was a blatant violation of Jamie’s civil rights and this assault on individual rights is repeated throughout the world. Fear, discrimination, and inadequate legal protection are some of the challenges faced by the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) community, placing them at an increased risk of becoming victims of anti-gay crimes (gay-bashing). Fear is a significant aspect of society, particularly towards those with alternative sexual lifestyles. Members…

Words 1512 - Pages 7

Essay about Parenting Styles

about a more silent issue? This issue is not an issue we hear about often, because it has to do with whether or not a parent forms an attachment with their children, how that can adversely, favorable or has no effect on their progenies. In different classes of society parental styles are viewed substantially different. Some expert articles reveal and professionals believe that controlling and being overly active in a child’s life can actually do more harm than good, especially with your students…

Words 3076 - Pages 13

Same-sex Marriage and Sex Couples Essay

to include relationships of a same sex would surely change people's ideas of what marriage is. Such changes in the perception of marriage would change people's behavior and thoughts of marriage. The arguments made against same sex marriage in the article “In Defense of Traditional Marriage” by R. Anderson asks the question, “Should the government recognize same-sex relationships as legal marriages?” Anderson offers many premises on the matter, which help to support the conclusion that marriage laws…

Words 1609 - Pages 7

Success And Failure In Being Mary Jane And Scandal

The Single Black Female: A look at success and failure in the television shows Being Mary Jane and Scandal. The role of the single black female is society is one that may not be as simple as black and white: instead it has many grey areas. Society has pinned the black female to be a very independent, nose in the air, conquering everything in her way, no need for a man type of woman. These stereotypes affect her home life, relationships in the workplace, her friendships, and her day to day interactions…

Words 3178 - Pages 13

Judges Report Essay

enacted. The annual number of children adopted outside their families fell from a high of 2617 in 1968 to 92 in 2001. Last year there was a total of 486 applications3, 0.5% of the total number of applications of all types filed in the Family Court. However, that includes so called step parent adoptions; the percentage of “stranger” adoptions has dropped dramatically over the years (from 69% in 1968 to 24% in 2001), reflecting society’s greater acceptance of the “solo mother”. It may surprise you to…

Words 6036 - Pages 25

Eng Lit Cw 1st Draft Essay

York times book review by Mary McCarthy describes Gilead’s class system as the basis of society: ‘The Handmaid's Tale'' is a woman's world, even though governed, seemingly, and policed by men. Its ethos is entirely domestic, its female population is divided into classes based on household functions, each class clad in a separate colour that instantly identifies the wearer” . (Mary McCarthy, February 9, 1986) Offred’s only purpose in contributing to Gilead is to reproduce children for the Commander…

Words 2601 - Pages 11