Same-sex Marriage and Sex Couples Essay

Submitted By jennh1982
Words: 1609
Pages: 7
Open Document
In defense of traditional marriage
Jennifer Hopes
Ashford University: PHI 103
Informal Logic
Ed Teall
09/14/2014

In recent years, there has been a considerable shift in the belief system of many Americans in regards to marriage equality. It appears that people are coming around to the understanding that all Americans deserve the same rights regardless of their sexual orientation. It is my belief that homosexuals should be allowed to marry because it is their constitutional right as American citizens to pursue happiness.
In “In defense of tradition marriage” Anderson states that “Americans respect marriage, not only as a crucial institution of civil society but as the fundamental building block of all human civilization”. It is true that in American culture the concepts of marriage have changed. However, not all of the changes have been positive, and our experiences to the changes have been enlightening. Developing the definition of what marriage is to include relationships of a same sex would surely change people's ideas of what marriage is. Such changes in the perception of marriage would change people's behavior and thoughts of marriage. The arguments made against same sex marriage in the article “In Defense of Traditional Marriage” by R. Anderson asks the question, “Should the government recognize same-sex relationships as legal marriages?” Anderson offers many premises on the matter, which help to support the conclusion that marriage laws need to stay the same in order for the good of society.
The first premise offered by Anderson is that same sex marriage is actually not illegal. Nowhere within the United States are same sex couples actually banned from living together or raising a family together. For spiritual purposes same sex couples have some of the same privileges as traditional couples. In many workplace environments, “same sex couples are allowed to name their significant other as beneficiary for benefits” (Anderson, 2013).
The second premise is that “Marriage exists to bring a man and a woman together as husband and wife to be father and mother to any children their union produces” (Anderson, 2013). There is not a reason for same sex couple to marry, since they cannot naturally have any children together. The article states that “it has been proven beneficial for children to be raised by a man and woman”. And that this type of environment is healthier and is more beneficial, as it “ensures the well-being of future citizens” (Anderson, 2013).
The third premise given is that the foundation of marriage has already been damaged by the adult’s desires above the requirements of their children. With the changing definition of marriage people start to decide that their marriage can be anything they want it to be, whether it is between multiple people or same sex couples. If same sex marriage were to become legal, what is stopping polygamy and adultery from being readily accepted and made legal? Changing the definition of marriage only works to deteriorate the central reason for people to get married in the first place, “which is first and foremost to create offspring, and to commit yourself to another person for the remainder of your lives” (Anderson, 2013).
The conclusion for these arguments is that there is no need to redefine marriage; we need to remember what tradition is and stay with that rather than change it. “The government isn’t in the business of affirming our loves. Rather it leaves consenting adults free to live and love as they choose” (Anderson, 2013). This has been a nice way of saying that the government does not really care who you love, they just do not want to recognize who you marry or want to marry legally.
My counter argument will provide that the initial statements made, that same sex marriages should not be legalized is an unsound and weak argument, which leaves a fair amount up for debate. While the premises support the conclusion, they do not undoubtedly convince me to share the
Show More

Related Documents: Same-sex Marriage and Sex Couples Essay

Essay Marriage: Same-sex Marriage and Opposite Sex Couple

Same Sex Marriage The controversy over the decision to make same sex marriage legalized has been going on for many years now. The decision that is made to be united as one is to be made between two people. Whether is it between a man and women, a man and another man, or women and another woman. As long as there are two people that care about each other and have a loving relationship should be allowed to be united. Only one state allows “gay marriage”, which is Massachusetts. New Jersey, Connecticut…

Words 1221 - Pages 5

Same-sex Marriage and Gay Couples Essay

Times Related Microsystems: Macrosystems SUMMARY OF THE ARTICLE It is now legal in every state in the United States for people with the same sex to get a marriage license. There are still many states in the U.S who wish this law did not pass. The real question is since the law passed can anyone get their marriage license when the couple is of the same sex? The answer is yes. Unfortunately, there is much delay. The reason is because many states are refusing this law and try to avoid this law to…

Words 1143 - Pages 5

Essay on Same Sex Marriage

Same Sex Marriage Same-sex marriage is a union between two individuals of the same gender that permits these two individuals to enter into a legally recognized marriage. In the US today, there is a big debate about whether gay couples have the right to marry. There are many reasons that people believe homosexuals should or shouldn’t have the right to marry. The United States was set up on an account of church and state being separated. For this reason Same-sex marriage should be recognized and…

Words 732 - Pages 3

Same Sex Marriage Essay

Biological Sex-Marriage: “An Alteration to Humanity” Submitted by: Ellicia Jiona Candelaria Submitted to: Mrs. Joan Bataclan ABSTRACT Biological Sex-Marriage: “An Alteration to Humanity” This study describes the advantages and also the disadvantages of couples of the same sex being married. It aims to explore how it affects the society and most importantly the church. Same-sex marriage, popularly known as gay marriage, is a socially or legally reorganized wedlock between two persons of similar…

Words 1148 - Pages 5

Law Reform Essay

------------------------------------------------- Evaluate the role of law reform in achieving just outcomes for family members and society ------------------------------------------------- -Recognition of same-sex relationships ------------------------------------------------- Olivia Jane To achieve just outcomes, justice needs to be done and seen to be done. To do this the law must adapt to accommodate society’s changing needs and attitudes. This means that, over time, new laws must be…

Words 1997 - Pages 8

Essay Same Sex Marriage

Same Sex Marriage Kelsey Smith Baker College April 15, 2013 Composition 102 T Same Sex Marriage Darity defines marriage as, “the exclusive commitment of two individuals to each other nurtures love and mutual support” (2008, p 1). There are many definitions of marriage including ones that say between a man and a women, but this definition explains not only what marriage is but what marriage should be like. The definitions with the words man and women in it is a religious belief not one that…

Words 1436 - Pages 6

Advantages Of Same Sex Marriage In Hong Kong

issue that concern and discuss by people ardently, that is should same-sex marriage be legal in Hong Kong? Different people have their own points of view, some people for the same-sex marriage should be legal in Hong Kong and some against it. In the below, I will talk about some history about same-sex marriage, why people support or against same-sex marriage and my points of view. Same-sex marriage means that two people of the same-sex get marry to each other. Netherlands was the first country…

Words 2012 - Pages 9

SSM Policy Paper 2

Policy Paper #1: Same Sex Marriage The rights of same-sex couples, particularly the legalization of same-sex marriage, have been closely reviewed on many different levels of government. Those who are Pro same-sex marriage feel that it is mainly due to the following reasons: Banning same sex-marriage creates a negative stigma for those involved, same-sex couples have the right to celebrate their union, they should be granted the same benefits as heterosexual couples via marriage, marriage is now seen…

Words 685 - Pages 3

Same-Sex Marriage Essay

Same-Sex Marriage: The Problems with DOMA and the Pursuit for Equality Believe it or not, same-sex marriage has been around since ancient times. At least two Roman Emperors, Nero and Elagabalus, were in gay unions. It wasn’t until the advent of Christianity that the practice of same sex marriage was out-lawed by the emperors Constantius II and Constans in 342 AD and has continued to be through-out most of the world until the twenty-first century (Boswell 83). With the advent of gay rights movement…

Words 1456 - Pages 6

Gay Marriage Persuasive Essay

Gay Marriage According to the Declaration of Independence, “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” This is not the case for all people, for example, same-sex couples. Homosexual couples are not given the same rights as their heterosexual counterparts in all 50 states. Currently, only 37 states have legalized gay marriage, which leaves us with 13 states who are still…

Words 827 - Pages 4