China The Rule Of Law And The Economy 2 Essay

Submitted By Chenzhe-Chang
Words: 2574
Pages: 11
Open Document
The Relationship between Economics and Law in China

China’s economic, political, and legal systems have drawn much attention in recent decades. The country’s unique circumstances and qualities make it a rich subject of study. China’s most remarkable characteristic is its unique ability to achieve unparalleled economic growth with its developing property and contract laws.
Economics and law affect each other. The relationship between a country’s economic progress and its legal system is widely researched. Although the relationship remains a complex subject, there is a strong basic argument that economic stability and progress rely on an effective legal system. The fields intersect in the areas of contract and property rights. The enforcement of contract law and property law is particularly essential to the transactions necessary to a sophisticated economy:

“[L]aw is necessary to create and maintain a sophisticated market. Without enforceable contract rights, exchange will not be possible beyond the most basic kinds of barter. Without property rights, investment will not occur because investors will not be able to protect their assets from private theft and state expropriation. In both instances, the instrument of rights enforcement is an independent, honest, and competent judiciary. Restated, the thesis is that property rights determine who has control over assets; contract law enables market participants to exchange those assets in complicated transactions; and the courts enable market actors to plan by resolving disputes predictably, efficiently, and in accordance with the legal rules. According to this conception, while legally unenforceable exchange can occur in networks and communities with high levels of trust, complicated transactions among strangers, upon which large-scale growth depends, cannot take place without these elements.”1

The terms of this relationship are no different as applied to the economic and legal system in the People’s Republic of China (“China”). China’s circumstances, however, are unique. Since 1949, the Communist Party of China (“CPC”) has enjoyed the monopolistic control of the nation’s legal system. Consequently, the legal system reflected and continues to reflect the CPC’s ideology. The CPC’s ideology has historically relied heavily on the Marxist notion of economic determinism.
Economic determinism attributes primacy to the economic structure over politics in the development of human history.2 “The sum total of [the] relations of production constitutes the economic structure of society, the real basis on which rises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite form of social consciousness.”3 The CPC has, until recently, employed the theory of economic determinism as a means of subverting the rule of law to its own needs in a quest for ideological advancement and purity.
Following the CPC’s successful takeover of power in 1949, it collectivized much of the country’s property. As a result, the CPC, the vanguard of the Chinese proletariat, took title to the property. It did not afford individuals substantial private property rights; private property and private business were anathema to the CPC’s ideology. Moreover, the CPC did not recognize the right to contract, particularly where such contracts were contrary to the regime’s goals. The free market was seen as an instrument of exploitation that frustrated the purpose of the revolution.
The CPC has, however, backed away from its adherence to the economic determinism model since Deng Xiaoping’s market reforms in 1978.4 These market reforms continue into the present. Changes in property and contract law have been central to reform and to the country’s economic progress.
One of the earliest and most fundamental changes to Chinese property law was the 1982 Constitutional guarantee to protect private home ownership.5 The Constitutional provision nevertheless dictates that the state owns
Show More

Related Documents: China The Rule Of Law And The Economy 2 Essay

Rare Earths Essay

such as missile guidance systems”[1]. China currently produces more than 95% of all rare earth metals in existence, and they control the ability to process them. This means that China has nearly total control on exporting the metals and attracting manufacturers to operate within China. With their control on exports, they can basically ration the metals to maximize profits and promote the labor force in China because manufacturers are forced to come to China. The United States, Japan, and the European…

Words 736 - Pages 3

Essay on Shanzai in China

the extent to which institutional drawbacks, for example, news/Internet censorship and lack of the rule of law, may inhibit Beijing’s attempts to enhance the innovativeness and global competitiveness of Chinese industry.” Abstract This paper discusses the current innovative environment in China and in what ways institutional drawbacks inhibit progress in this area. China’s rapidly expanding economy and recent transition to quasi-capitalism along with its long-standing cultural aversion to globalization…

Words 2520 - Pages 11

Ferguson term paper

uses these four sealed black boxes to “demonstrate that Western institutions have indeed degenerated” (Ferguson page 11). The first of these “long-sealed” boxes is “ labelled ‘democracy’. The second is labelled ‘capitalism’. The third is ‘the rule of law’. And the fourth box labelled ‘civil society’” (Ferguson). Each one of these boxes are an important part of how our civilization works. The purpose for revealing these black boxes, Ferguson states, is “that inside these political, economic, legal…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

Independent Study Essay

2000, the number of this group of people is over 100 million. China’s economic system Qin et.al (2007) say that China has gone through enormous change and high growth during the last twenty years since the economic reform started from 1978. “The reforms progressed gradually from farming to commerce, to state-owned enterprises, and to government finance and banking” (815) Then China established a “socialist market economic system” (21) in 1990s according to GY. Yu (2003) However, Guthrie (2009)…

Words 6448 - Pages 26

Global Financial Crisis Essay

Chinese eConomy The Chinese economy, vol. 45, no. 3, May–June 2012, pp. 8–23. © 2012 M.E. Sharpe, Inc. All rights reserved. ISSN 1097–1475/2012 $9.50 + 0.00. DOI 10.2753/CES1097-1475450301 Mary Ip The Global Financial Crisis Role of Law in China Abstract: in general, China’s response to the global financial crisis was not very different from that of other countries: a stimulus package worth trillions of renminbi, aimed at encouraging domestic consumption. At the same time, China realized…

Words 5961 - Pages 24

Characteristics Of Chinese Emperors

behavior of this particular emperor and others that the kings of China really had a large dynastic sense, with the large tombs and huge terracotta army that he was buried with really shows how these people believed they were G-ds, and they lived ruled and died like G-ds too. Another example of how ruthless and power hungry these Emperors were, is seen by The Youngzheng Emperor, who killed all of his brother bar one to ‘assure his own rule’, one could say they exhibit animalistic qualities. These war…

Words 965 - Pages 4

ECON 401 Assignment 1 Essay

where the production was made for their product to china to save on costs of labour to create a higher profit margin. By doing this they were able to increase their revenues and also the labour laws in those countries are not the same as North America, therefore they are able to create more product in a less amount of time because breaks might not be required in a country, like China. Whereas, they would be in North America. 1. The Venezuelan economy teaches us that when a dictator is in control,…

Words 1031 - Pages 5

golbal economy Essay

Kai Ding Question1: Huntington fractured world based on different civilizations each with culture (not ideology), each with value system and ideology aligned with the local hegemon that has ability to enforce a set of rules which governs behavior. People identify themselves first according to religion and culture, but for Fukayama, people identify themselves by location first. Huntington thinks that civilizations differentiated by history, language, culture, tradition, religion, and each has a…

Words 847 - Pages 4

How Did Emperor Shi Huangdi Rule

unified Ancient China by organizing the economy and establishing a system of protection. Although he was a young emperor the people worshiped him for controlling the empire and unifying the people. Shi Huangdi which literally means “First Emperor”…

Words 1091 - Pages 5

International Accounting Standards Board Essay

University of Science and Technology, Changchun 130022, China E-mail: Zhanghm1995@163.com Xianfeng Liu No. 65043 Section of PLA E-mail: lxfz@vipsina.com Abstract With the international convergence of accounting standards becoming an irresistible trend, China’s new business accounting standards have reached substantive convergence with International Financial Report Standards (IFRS). However, due to some factors including economy, law and culture, there is still a narrow gap between china’s…

Words 2330 - Pages 10