Comparing Juvenile Cases

Words: 862
Pages: 4
Open Document
Compare and contrast juvenile cases
Introduction
The trial of child offenders who have committed extreme crimes as adults is still in contest as the laws that were voted and passed in areas such as California completely differ from the view of many scientific reports which state that children and adolescents have either undeveloped or developing brains thus cannot be tried as adults in any criminal justice firm.
Major characters
Children in contrast to adults in crime punishment
Young children under 18 years of age (juveniles) are given life sentences for serious crimes but there, the juvenile is not forever locked up and forgotten as it is supposed, opposite to what the adult get in life sentence meaning. Life sentence means that ones’ whole …show more content…
Besides, in 2005 a court ruling determined that it is was unconstitutional to execute a person under the age of eighteen years. Dissimilar to the Proposition 21, the court considered that children lack careful and similar evaluation as well as judgments as well as theability control sudden and spontaneous inclination in mind development (L. Grigorenko, L. Grigorenko and University, …show more content…
Proposition 21 in contrast to 707(b)
People in California voted and passed Proposition 21 allowing juveniles as young as fourteen years, as long as they are accused of serious crimes are to be tried at law courts as adults, and only at the discretion of the District Attorney this makes the law be different from 707(b) hearing where juveniles accused of committing serious crimes were to be heard before a judge to determine if the case met the criteria to be tried as an adult (L. Grigorenko, L. Grigorenko and University, n.d.).
Extreme violence in contrast to petty crimes
Unlike, before the introduction of the Proposition 21 and 707(b) laws, juveniles were only tried as adults on extreme cases of violence (HOGG HAUGHT, n.d.).
L.A. Times newspaper article in comparison with University of San Francisco’s Center for Law and Global Justice
There are 2,387 juvenile offenders that have been given life sentences here in the United States. This is according to University of San Francisco’s Center for Law and Global Justice. similarly, to a L.A. Times newspaper article which also quantifies the same numbers (G. Savage,
Show More

Related Documents: Comparing Juvenile Cases

Definition Of Delinquency And State Offenses

country acknowledge that a juvenile both male and or female is a person between the ages of 10 and 18. In addition, some states have the authority to establish the maximal juvenile age as 16. Anyone over a state's given age limit is tried as an adult. All Criminal law proceedings set by a juvenile person is termed under the definition of delinquency. And once the Criminal law matters are considered a delinquency the term crime is no longer used. Instead, the Juvenile court system uses the word…

Words 820 - Pages 4

Female Offender Crimes Essay

lead to a criminal behavior in women. (2012 Muraskin, Roslyn) During the early 1990s, the number of girls in the juvenile justice system has been increasing because to regulation changes. The quantity of girls has increased in the juvenile justice system can be recognized by the dysfunctional family conflicts such as vicious crimes, domestic violence in the home, misdemeanor cases that is gender-based that may be a misunderstanding of girls’ developmental issues, according to reports status. (2012…

Words 415 - Pages 2

Malefaction In Prisons

Juvenile offenders who commit solemn malefactions shouldn’t be trialed as an adult because studies have shown that simply giving more astringent sentences doesn’t “scare straighten” the offenders. Putting younger generations in locked up facilities with malefactors older has the potential for more damage than good on inverting their life of malefaction. Prisons have gang ravishes, more rigorous murderers, and child molesters just aching for a thirteen year who purloined or attempted murder to walk…

Words 1239 - Pages 5

Essay On Recidivism

inconclusive. Inconsistencies in the way summaries have been compiled reflect the limitations of the desk review and the data available in the original source material. For example, some studies do not measure results against a control group and in some cases the evaluation methodology is not very detailed. Those wishing to gain a more in-depth view of this topic should refer back to the original sources for more detail. A. Studies which show significantly reduced recidivism Source Author, country…

Words 8788 - Pages 36

Welfare-Based Model

It ensures that such rights and responsibilities apply specifically to children under the age of eighteen by taking into account their needs and situations, (UNCRC, 1989). Comparing the Convention compliance between Canada and Scotland, I will describe some of the rights children have pertaining to Articles 3, 37 & 40 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC, 1989). These will be the Articles that…

Words 1233 - Pages 5

Racial Disparity In The Criminal Justice System Essay

Cole shows that racial disparities in the criminal justice system can result from deliberate racialized laws and actions. For drug offenses, Blacks and Hispanics are convicted, arrested, and imprisoned many times more than Whites; the case is similar for juveniles. Research indicates that although crack users are majority White, a huge percentage (96% as of 1988) of Blacks are charged with violation. In contrast, 80% of Whites were convicted for using powder cocaine. What percentage of powder cocaine…

Words 548 - Pages 3

Essay on U.S. V.S. China

U.S. V.S. CHINA The two criminal justice systems that will be discussed in this paper are the United States and the People’s Republic of China. When comparing and contrasting these two systems one should start with the premises that both are instituted in their reciprocal countries in the attempt to curb the proliferation of crime, offenders and deter potential offenders. Both the U.S.’ and China’s criminal justice systems make use of a court system, police enforcement organizations and detention…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Emic Approach Analysis

would often have issues trying to attain his ambitions due to his undocumented immigrant status. Due to the disparities he faced the client would often feel emotions of frustration, depression, and anger. The client also became involved with the juvenile justice system due to behaviors that he later said was everyday life for him in the…

Words 801 - Pages 4

Essay on Capital Punishment and Death Penalty Sentence

the U.S., Americans yearn for a successful way to reduce the homicide rate. However, most Americans do not approve the use of the death penalty when other options, such as life in prison without parole plus restitution, are presented (Dieter). By comparing the empirical and moral claims of the arguments in favor and against the use of the death penalty, we suggest that the presidential candidate take a cautiously anti-death penalty stance. The key issues include whether the U.S. should sustain the…

Words 4332 - Pages 18

Forensic Anthropology Research Paper

human they then can identify the sex, gender, ethnicity, and so on. Then the forensic anthropologist assists the law enforcement in the investigation. Forensic anthropologists are very important and helpful in helping the law enforcement solve their cases. Some people don’t even know what forensic anthropologists are or what they do. The first step is to determine sex. This is important to start with for forensic anthropologists. Sex is determined by genes, and expressed through…

Words 987 - Pages 4