Criminal Justice to Court Room Process Essay

Submitted By SoulRanger
Words: 1078
Pages: 5
Open Document
Ronnie Allen
April 1, 2013
Criminal Justice to Courtroom Process
Ms. Angela Bradrick
University of Phoenix

This paper is about the high profile case of a five year old child Shaniya Davis, murdered and raped.
With the high rise in crime all over the country there are cases that are high profile. Such is the case of five year old girl named Shaniya Davis in Fayetteville, North Carolina, cause of death asphyxiation and rape. In this paper a description of the crime will be noted from the reports of different media, the role of attrition, the criminal justice processes used in the case, How the participants in the criminal justice process influenced the case in terms of discretion, when was discretion used by a party or parties, and at other points, if any, might this case have been pursued. Also, would the defendants in the case benefit more from a bench trial or from a jury trial and to explain the advantages and disadvantages as they apply to the high profile case? My heart as well as the hearts of the world hurt as the story revealed itself about Shaniya Nicole Davis. The story begins with a five year old child being raised by her father, Bradley Lockhart, and his sister, Carey. In September of 2009, Shaniya’s mother, Antoinette Davis, contacted Shaniya’s father, to start having more contact with her daughter. Shaniya’s mother had struggled in the past, but it appeared that she had gotten her life back together. She had a job and a place to live (Crumpet, 2012). A neighbor of Antoinette Davis stated that at 3:00am in the morning in November of 2009, she heard banging outsider her home. A 6:11 the same day a surveillance camera at “Comfort Suites’ hotel caught a man carrying Shaniya through the hallway. The man checked into the hotel with Shaniya, and he stayed for an hour as reported by one media. At 6:53am, Antoinette reported Shaniya missing from her home. A blanket belonging to Shaniya was found in a trash can outside a neighbor’s home. The role of attrition in this case was the police, FBI and other organizations and the community all compiling evidence that could be used in the investigation to convict someone for kidnapping and any other crimes that might be charged against someone. Allegations that Shaniya was used to pay off unresolved drug debt. It was stated authorities was looking into those suspicions. The first charge in the case was Clarence D. Coe for first degree kidnapping. He swore that he wasn’t guilty. The police identified another man, Mario Andretti McNeill, on a video at the hotel carrying Shaniya in the hallway (Butler, 2009). Mario admits to the kidnapping and the charges against Clarence were dropped. Then her mother was charged with human trafficking. There was a delay in additional charges because of jurisdiction issues between Cumberland County and Lee County. Finally, it was decided the case would be prosecuted in Cumberland County. Soon after first charges Shaniya’s body was found raped and murdered by Mario McNeill. A Jeff Riccio of Tar Heel Canine Training Inc. after getting information that the body may be near some deer carcasses they had overlooked. They found her body on Monday, November 16, 2009, in a forested area off of Highway 87 in Sanford, North Carolina. Further charges were made on Antoinette Davis filing a false police report, human trafficking and felony child abuse, accused of selling her daughter into sexual slavery. Mario A. McNeill was charged with rape and first degree murder in addition to first degree kidnapping charges. Mother arrested November 14, 2009, and Mario McNeill November 13, 2009. The Criminal Justice process used in this case is called the Wedding Cake model. The smallest layer at the very top of cake represents famous cases that attract a lot of publicity and unfortunately, often contribute to public misinformation about the criminal justice process. This model points out two important phases
Show More

Related Documents: Criminal Justice to Court Room Process Essay

Consistency Of Trial Essays

Each alleged offender or defendant in the Criminal Justice Process should be considered on an individual basis because consistency of process is fairer than consistency of outcome. Do you agree? The purpose of the criminal justice process is to basis of the criminal justice process is the idea that individuals will receive a fair and unbiased trial The purpose of the criminal justice process is to stand as a reasoning organisation dedicated to keeping order and honour in society. ^^Law enforcement…

Words 885 - Pages 4

Essay on Criminal Justice Trends

Criminal Justice Trends of the Courts Terry M. Busse CJA/484 May 13, 2013 Wayne Scott Patch Criminal Justice Trends of the Courts The primary function of any court system is to keep the domestic peace. If there were not a court system that was accepted by the citizens of the society that it serves, vigilante groups would exact their own justice. The court serves as the impartial judge that…

Words 1505 - Pages 7

Essay on Intro to Criminal Justice - My Cousin Vinny

Cousin Vinny and compare this to the actual Criminal Justice System. I want to start off by saying the portrayal of the Criminal Justice System was much different than what we see it in real life. I really enjoyed the comedy that was displayed around it. The movie was based around two teenagers who were suspected of murdering a gas station attendant. This movie takes place in Alabama. The first similarity I noticed is that the movie depicted the due process model. In which they were allowed a complete…

Words 1466 - Pages 6

Personal Narrative: Bail Hearing

The court case I chose to attend was a bail hearing also known as a “judicial interim release” for the defendant who was assaulting another individual outside a bar while intoxicated. A Judge/Justice of peace is very likely to give bail easily to individuals with less serious offences due to the current overcrowding problem in most jails (Williams, M.R (2016)). I walked into the court house on Wednesday February the 15th around 12 o-clock and was surprised at how little people there were in the main…

Words 1202 - Pages 5

Sentencing Essay 2

Sentencing law and punishment is undoubtedly one of the most important areas of law and criminal justice. The historical background of protective sentencing is particularly important since, as Pratt (1995,1996 cited Henman 2003, p.3) has argued convincingly, “It is closely linked to the postmodern emphasis on individual self-government and the related expectation that state intervention is necessary to protect citizen’s rights to life, security and self-determination”. Seemingly, the theories and…

Words 1813 - Pages 8

Wainwright V. Gideon Case

In June of 1961, a burglary occurred at the Bay Harbor Pool Room in Panama City, Florida. A witness claimed to have seen Clarence Earl Gideon in the poolroom early that morning. Based on this accusation alone, the police arrested him and charged him with breaking and entering with intent to commit petty larceny. Too poor to afford a lawyer, Gideon appeared at the Florida Circuit Court alone and requested that the judge appoint a lawyer to him as entitled by his Sixth Amendment right to counsel (Oyez)…

Words 594 - Pages 3

Law Juries Essay

Jurors are an important part of the English legal system and these are ordinary people who deal with serious criminal system. As it is a civic duty they do not have a choice than to do it. Jurors are ordinary citizen’s men and women of the district who are randomly introduced into the trial procedure to be the arbiter of the facts of the case, strengthen the authority of the legal system. Slapper and Kelly (2010). However, Martin (2010) mentions that jurors are partly middle class and younger than…

Words 1313 - Pages 6

Jury Trial Essay

Jury Trial Analysis Jaynice Harden March 16, 2015 CJA/364 Criminal Procedure Shane Krauser Jury Trial Analysis In today’s society, there are many people who know what a jury trial is and what is expected in the process of a jury trial. They may also know why the process is important and very necessary as it protects the citizens of the United States. The part that some people may not know about is the process that is taken during the pre-trial phase. Any and every individual that has been…

Words 1563 - Pages 7

What Is The Foundation Of Criminal Justice

Individual Project CRJS101 – Foundation of Criminal Justice 05/05/2013 Abstract The process of the criminal justice system is very complex, and sometimes it can be confusing to person that does not understand how it works. The function of the criminal justice system from investigation, to arrest, to defendant’s right, and on to trial procedures can be very complex. Overview of the Criminal Justice System. Introduction The foundation of the criminal justice system plays an important part in keeping…

Words 983 - Pages 4

Role of Magistrates & Jury in England & Wales Essay

decision-making process. It will assess both the advantages and disadvantages of both mechanisms and give an opinion on the contribution they make in the process. The role of a lay magistrate is one that is at the core of the legal system in England & Wales. They help maintain the foundation of the criminal justice system and deal with approximately 98% of all criminal matters. The sheer volume of cases that they deal with has helped earned them the title of the workhorses of the criminal justice system…

Words 1956 - Pages 8