Essay on debate about Natives

Submitted By wenjing1223
Words: 800
Pages: 4
Open Document
Topic: Native peoples have been adequately compensated for loss of land/ culture by the Canadian government. (Affirmative)
The Native peoples have been adequately compensated for their loss of land and culture by the Canadian government. This can be shown through
1. The treaties between the Canadian government and the Aboriginal peoples
2. The status card
3. Laws that assist the Natives in today’s society
The first point states, “The treaties between the Canadian government and the Aboriginal peoples.” 1) It was the Aboriginal peoples’ decision to sign the treaties with the British Crown which were recognized and affirmed by Canada’s Constitution. 2) It should also be noted that in the Historic treaties after Confederation: the First Nations who occupied these territories gave up large areas of land to the Crown. In exchange, the treaties provided for such things as reserve lands and other benefits like farm equipment and animals, annual payments, ammunition, clothing and certain rights to hunt and fish. The Crown also made some promises such as maintaining schools on reserves or providing teachers or educational help to the First Nation named in the treaties. Treaty No. 6 included the promise of a medicine chest. 3) Also there has been many Modern treaties—comprehensive claims, and the first of which was the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreement signed in 1975. To date, the federal government has settled 24 self-government and comprehensive land claim areas with Aboriginal people in Canada, two of which are stand-alone self-government. 4) As well, the Canadian government has granted the Aboriginals with self-government agreements which are one means of building sound governance and institutional capacity that allow Aboriginal communities to contribute to, and participate in the decisions that affect their lives and carry out effective relationships with other governments. They also provide greater certainty over rights to natural resources, contributing to a more positive investment climate and creating greater potential for economic development, jobs and growth. The second point, the status card gives Aboriginals access to benefits, programs and services administered by federal agencies and provincial governments. Such benefits include exemption from taxes, as well as money for ammunition and annuities, and hunting and fishing rights on unoccupied land. As stated previously the act states that "personal property of an Indian or a band situated on a reserve" is tax exempt. Also Status Indian working on a reserve is exempt from income taxes which could add up to thousands of dollars. As well Status Indians do not generally pay the federal goods and services tax or provincial sales tax if they buy something on a reserve or if it is destined for a reserve. Free post-secondary education is also one of the benefits of a Status Indian. The cost of which could add up to more than $10,000. The participation rates in this program has been growing, this results in more Natives being able to achieve a higher level of education. The Canadian government has also set forth many laws and acts which assists the Aboriginals. Some of which are the
The Constitution Act, 1982 (section 35 recognizes and affirms existing Aboriginal rights)
In 1992 the Aboriginal Justice Initiative was established and has been working with Native communities to improve justice institutions for Aboriginals and help
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on debate about Natives

Crawford Bilingual Able to Understand Essay

United States. Included in this first chapter, “Anatomy of the English-Only Movement,” are historical sketches that Crawford uses to examine the influence of English-Only campaigns on Pennsylvanian Germans, Louisianans, Californios, Native Americans, Puerto Ricans, Native Hawaiians, and European immigrants. These examples from U.S. history, Crawford argues, illustrate how language restrictionism has never occurred “independently of the material forces that govern U.S. history” (p. 10). Crawford further…

Words 1118 - Pages 5

Columbus Day Research Paper

Since 1892 when the first Columbus Day was celebrated, controversies behind the national holiday have been recurring through conversions and debates. When President Benjamin Harris proclaimed Columbus Day as a national holiday, many things in the previous years made the formation of this national holiday come to be. Although Columbus was able to start the first recorded history in the Americas, Columbus bought many cultural, spiritual, and economic differences from Europe. These differences affected…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Essay On Native American Stereotypes

For decades we’ve known the Native Americans to be a race that has lost a lot especially their home land being taken over by force from the white settlers. From that, Native Americans are rarely ever seen around in modern day life, only traditions exist among certain states across the US. And so, we see many of these traditions especially in sports ranging from football mascots to school names. For example, one of the most well-known NFL football teams are named the Washington Reskins which in past…

Words 1010 - Pages 5

Summary Of Manifest Destiny And American Territorial Expansion

into the southwest became the justification to kill or displace thousands of Native Americans. (Greenberg 12) Similarly, slavery in the South continued to thrive unchecked as white Americans placed their own economic interests above those of slaves and Native Americans. However, the national debate over slavery began to slow the race west. President Andrew Jackson resisted adding Texas as a state due to concerns about sectional tensions over a new slave state (Brinkley 291). Likewise, many saw…

Words 1164 - Pages 5

Gun Violence Introduction

Introduction to gun violence There are tons of statistics in gun violence or related to the topic due to the debate on gun control has been going around since decades ago in the country. Therefore, it is easy to believe that in the developed world, the United States leads the charts in gun related violence. However, the overall most violent countries in the world are countries in development that have had inside conflicts shaped in many forms historically, it is worthless to compare the United States’…

Words 775 - Pages 4

Some Homework Lol Essay

12/6/2012 5th Period AP Human Geography 1) Based on the article, describe the linguistic complexity of Ghana (what are the major languages/minor languages) While about a fifth of Ghana speaks English, the native language of Akan is spoken by roughly a third of the country as a first language, and millions more as a second language. Twi, or the dialects of Akan that are non-Fante, is the trade language of the densely populated southern half of the country. 2) Identify the main argument…

Words 404 - Pages 2

Maritime Fur Trade System

The maritime fur trade on the northwest coast, the whalers in the Artic-Inuit Native and the labourers, all played a large role in international trading and globalization. The maritime fur trade mostly occurred between the Natives, and the Hudson Bay company and the French after 1820. Nonetheless, Russia is said to be the pioneers, as they perfected the trading business in Kamchatka prior to UK and US entering in the late 1780s (E. E. Rich, 1960). The maritime fur trade was a ship-based fur trade…

Words 393 - Pages 2

How Did Andrew Jackson Changed America

jackson should be replaced on the 20 dollar bill. From getting rid of the Native americans,slave trader, and killing many people Some people could say one of things Jackson is most famous for is the Trail Of Tears. The Trail Of Tears was the forced marched of many Native Americans. In 1831, with the US Army threatening an invasion the native american would have to go, the Trail Of Tears would take as many as 4,000 lives. The Native Americans even brought…

Words 389 - Pages 2

I Am Bartolom De Las Casas Speech Final Essay

the Americas, and the natives of its land. My work in the natives’ freedom gave me the name “Defender of the Indians,” and, by some, was called the “father of anti-imperialism and anti-racism.” I was born in 1474, in Seville and my family was closely tied to the family of Christopher Columbus. Because of this, I went to the New World when I was rather young, and I did so dozens of times throughout my life. As a young boy, I first-hand saw the terrible conditions that the Native Americans were being…

Words 404 - Pages 2

Objectivity and Fieldwork Essay example

foreign culture. He believed that in order to understand the culture of the natives he needed to feel the native way of life. Throughout his work, Malinowski demonstrates to be more interested in the scientific scope of doing fieldwork, as he describes the methods and theories he used when trying to understand the Kula’s culture. “What is then this ethnographer’s magic, by which he is able to evoke the real spirit of the natives, the true picture of the tribal life? As usual, success can only be obtained…

Words 1117 - Pages 5