determination of employment Essay

Submitted By ermo
Words: 822
Pages: 4
Open Document
In order to determine whose vicarious liability it is, the relationship of being an employee or an independent contractor must be clarified first. Which including various forms of employment legislation, the assessment of income and business taxes, whether a dismissal is reasonably handled and if the contractual rights are properly applied.
According the “master’s tort theory”, the acts of employees are the acts of the employer in law as what the employees do is considered under the authority of the employer. So the employer is totally responsible for whatever his employees do. Another theory named “servant’s tort theory” also indicates that the employer should be liable for the acts of his employees since the employer is the superior and in charge. But it does not make any sense for an employer to take responsibilities for acts of an independent contractor, who is in business on his own.
So the central question is that whether the person who performed the services is doing so as a person in business on his own account or under the relationship of an employment. To determine, we need to consider at least 3 major factors: direction and control, the extent of integration and mutual dependency and the operation process of business (such as ownership of tools, whether hire his own helpers, the degree of financial risk taken by the worker, the worker’s opportunity for profit, the degree of responsibility for investment and management held by the worker).
1. Direction and control.
A significant question is that how much control Sagaz had over AIM? In the case related to Canadian Tire, the information given indicates that Sagaz and AIM are two different separated legal entities. AIM paid for its own expenses incurred in business, like commissions and travel expenses. The head office of AIM is located in New York, and Sagaz’s is located in Florida, which is the evidence that they are not together. Sagaz just had a contract with AIM, stating that AIM would provide services to maintain the goodwill of Canadian Tire, and some terms relates to price and conditions as well. But how to provide the service is on AIM’s decision. Sagaz is not controlling AIM ‘s activities, AIM could serve other companies at the same time.
2. Integration
Another important question need to be answered to make a determination of the relationship is that if the worker or the services he performed integral to the employer’s business. In the case of Dynamic industries, during the period of appeal, Mr. Martindale provided construction service for SIIL and which made him a part of the business, like an employee, while when we look at the monopolization of Mr. Martindale during that period, he did not only provided services to SIIL, he also served many other enterprises apart from SIIL. So Mr. Martindale does business with various entities as an independent contractor, not an employee of anyone.
3. The operation process of business.
This category includes a lot.
In terms of responsibility for investment and management, in the case relates to Sagaz, after signing the contract, it was AIM and Landow
Show More

Related Documents: determination of employment Essay

Effective People Skills: Process Of Recruitment

the case of the expansion of the company's activity, the company has sometimes go to an employment agency that registers the names of those who have lost their jobs and are recorded as well as the competencies and skills. Stages of the recruitment process include: job analysis and the…

Words 1301 - Pages 6

Organizational Climate In Mental Health

development, but developmentally-appropriate counsel will assist the clients in overcoming barriers to employment. Casper, E. S. (2003). A self-rating scale for supported employment participants and practitioners. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 27(2), 151-158. Researchers utilized the Need for Change scale (NFC) for persons in supported employment settings; the workers rated their satisfaction with employment. The results indicated an urgent need for change among the majority of subject. The use of…

Words 1028 - Pages 5

You Decide 1 Essays

one were to look at her employment status, they would see that Karen has additional clients outside of the local utility as well as the fact that she has not received benefits or proper tax documentation for this period time. For these reasons, Karen should be classified as an independent contractor for the local utility. 2. What factors do you feel help contribute to Karen being an employee? If I was being the devil’s advocate based on 20-factors analysis and determination of form SS-8, here are…

Words 966 - Pages 4

Essay on What They Didn t Teach Us in Sales Class

and determination in order to successfully develop the skills necessary to successfully overcome these challenges which will enable him to become a better provider for his family and a better salesperson to Nabisco. 2. How should Mr. Brown handle this situation? What should he say to Rick? As the Division Sales Manager, one would surmise that this was not Mr. Brown’s first case of a new recruit “quitting before testing the waters.” There must have been valid reasons for making an employment offer…

Words 523 - Pages 3

Essay on Employee Status

• Is Mary an independent contractor or an employee? Describe the factors that led to her determination. Several factors must be examined to determine if Mary was an independent contractor or an employee. In the beginning Mary seemed to be hired as an independent contractor. As the relationship continued for two years Mary seemed to move more toward an “at will” employee. The following factors were taken into consideration to determine Mary was an “at will” employee of the company.…

Words 730 - Pages 3

Nafta Pros And Cons

approximately 700,000 employments as generation moved to Mexico. The majority of these misfortunes came in California, Texas, Michigan, and different states where assembling is concentrated. Undoubtedly, there were some employment picks up along the fringe in administration and retail segments coming about because of expanded trucking action, however these increases are little in connection to the loses, and are in lower paying occupations. Most by far of specialists who lost employments from NAFTA…

Words 682 - Pages 3

Summary: The US Employment Tax Case

creating an S corporation to avoid self-employment tax. Most S corporation employment tax cases often involve a similar situation of an individual trying to shift income to the corporation, creating an opportunity for a tax advantage. In the tax court, the taxpayer often takes the position that the shifting of income is a distribution rather than compensation. However, a more recent federal tax development questioned the jurisdiciton over certain S corporation employment tax cases. This would put taxpayers…

Words 657 - Pages 3

Nisa Mission Statement Analysis

NISA helps their members recognize their ability to gain meaningful employment, so that the individual can feel a sense of purpose and value within their community. NISA believes in a system where members need to redefine themselves as untrained or unqualified versus being identified as a person who has a mental health disability…

Words 1493 - Pages 6

Examples Of Disability Determination Process

Assessment of Disability Determination Processes in Sudan: Needs, Challenges, and Recommendations I. Disability Determination Processes at a Glance Although statutory definitions of ‘disability’ are objectively specific, the definition of a ‘disability determination process’ is not so precise, and requires close examination. In general, the disability determination process includes 1) the examination of medical records, 2) the allegations of the claimant, 3) medical opinion of treating doctor…

Words 1576 - Pages 7

Essay on Lily CV

of gaining employment with Focus International. I believe that with my out going personality and my hunger to learn that I will be a perfect candidate for a position. I have been an active member of the workforce for the last 5 years mainly working in retail, hospitality and sale jobs. I am extremely customer focused and know that the both the customers needs and that as a business as a whole comes before my own. Within the last 5 years I have learnt that hard work and determination to succeed…

Words 306 - Pages 2