Discuss Two Or More Theories Of The Breakdown Of Romantic Relationships Essay

Submitted By sam821999
Words: 689
Pages: 3
Open Document
Discuss two or more theories of the breakdown of romantic relationships. (8 marks + 16 marks)

Duck’s model of breakdown attempts to explain the process in six steps. It begins with dissatisfaction with how a relationship is conducted, which leads to an intra-psychic process that is characterised by brooding on the partner’s faults and the costs of the relationship. In the dyadic process, people confront their partners and discuss their feelings about the relationship. The relationships may be saved at this point due to a reassessment of goals, possibilities or commitment, or it may break down further.

If further breakdown occurs, social processes will take place, whereby friends and family will offer advice and support. After having left the relationship, grave-dressing processes will commence. Partners strive to construct a representation of the relationship that does not paint their own contribution to the relationship unfavourably. This process often involves emotional distress. In the final resurrection process, each partner prepares for new relationships by learning from the mistakes of the prior relationship.

This model has been largely supported by research evidence. Tashiro & Frazier surveyed students whose relationships had recently broken down. They reported to have experienced emotional distress as well as personal growth, stating that these breakdowns had given them a clearer idea about future relationships. This provides evidence for both the grave-dressing and resurrection processes.

This model had practical applications in counselling. Assessing which stage a couple is in can help to identify what steps should be taken to save the relationship. This model stresses the importance of communication in breakdown: paying attention to what people say and how they interact will help their stage to be identified. Appropriate interventions can then be used.

A study by Akert provided a criticism for this model. Akert found that the instigators of break-ups suffer fewer negative consequences than non-instigators. Duck used the same model for both instigators and non-instigators. This suggests that this model ignores individual differences such as this one.

This model is also perceived to be culturally biased, rooted in Western culture. Many collectivist, non-Western cultures have arranged marriages, which are generally regarded as permanent. Marital crises of these relationships are also seen as the concern of the entire family, not just the couple. Therefore, this model may not apply to non-Western relationships.

In another theory, Duck proposed three reasons as to why relationships break down. One of these is a lack of skills. A partner may lack the interpersonal skills to make the relationship mutually satisfying. They may be a poor conversationalist; poor at indicating their interest in their partner, or their interactions with other people may be generally
Show More

Related Documents: Discuss Two Or More Theories Of The Breakdown Of Romantic Relationships Essay

Discuss psychological theories for the maintenance and breakdown of romantic relationships Essay

Discuss psychological theories for the maintenance and breakdown of romantic relationships (8+16 marks) One psychological theory of relationship maintenance is the investment model. This theory suggests that commitment in a relationship is strengthened by the amount of satisfaction in a relationship which is weakened by presence of possible alternatives. This theory suggests that there should be satisfaction in a relationship in order for it to become long-term. The satisfaction in a product of…

Words 1049 - Pages 5

Understand theories of relationships and social networks Essay

1.1 Key principles of relationship theories - Stage theories in general describe how we go through distinct stages as we develop. Thus, rather than gradually changing, we typically make sudden shifts to different plateaus of perception and behaviour. Relationships go through a series of stages as they mature. Levinger's model has ABCDE stages. A = Acquaintance/attraction. We meet other people and feel an initial attraction, often based on physical beauty and similarity. B = Build-up. We become…

Words 1889 - Pages 8

Basal Ganglia Case Study

Basal ganglia disorders are a group of syndromes that all have a common source. In this case the common source is the basal ganglia. This is a part of the brain near the limbic system that is associated with many disorders, both psychological as well as physical. These disorders are very different and the only thing they have in common it the basal ganglia. The basal ganglia are a group of neurons that is also called the nuclei and is located deep within the cerebral hemispheres of the brain. The…

Words 2398 - Pages 10

Sociology Essay

Discuss how childhood is viewed and protected in contemporary society It is assumed that children, especially in Western societies, need a lengthy and protected period of time of nurturing in order to prepare them for adulthood. However, the length of time adults deem appropriate for this period differs across the world (James and James, 2004). As time has gone on, understandings and perceptions of childhood as adults has undertaken a series of changes and been heavily influenced by factors such…

Words 4273 - Pages 18

Professional Presence Essay

ulcers” (Koerner, 2011). Countless studies on heart disease, cancers, stroke, etc. with the studies concluding that these stressors contribute dramatically to the health and healing of individuals were also conducted during this era. Many nursing theories arose defining health and healing models during these eras. Virginia Henderson formulated one of the most well-known. One of her fundamental beliefs was that the mind and body are inseparable. Throughout her nursing career, Ms. Henderson “advocated…

Words 4454 - Pages 18

Essay on Frankenstein: Mother

RELATIONSHIPS and CHARACTERS in Romulus, My Father. CHARACTER NOTES: Romulus Man of suffering: Suffered greatly as predicted by the fortune teller The composer sees his suffering as some sort of rite of passage in which he was ennobled. (see above) “People argue about whether suffering ennobles”. There is another and different thought, which is that suffering makes one wise”…”Some kinds of wisdom, however – the kinds that show themselves not only in thoughts, but in the integrity…

Words 6318 - Pages 26

Essay Social Media Business Model Analysis - Case Tencent, Facebook, and Myspace

l Social Media Business Model Analysis - Case Tencent, Facebook, and Myspace Logistics Master's thesis Xiaoyan Hu 2011 Department of Information and Service Economy Aalto University School of Economics ABSTRACT The term of social media is becoming increasingly popular presently, the amount of social media users is growing dramatically, and the monetization of social media has been discussed in publications but not in details. Nowadays, the most frequently used approach to make money for…

Words 34791 - Pages 140