Essay on Distributive Justice

Submitted By ysargeon

Words: 333

Pages: 2

Open Document

Distributive Justice
According to Wikipedia, Distributive justice concerns the nature of a socially just allocation of goods in a society. A society in which incidental inequalities in outcome do not arise would considered a society guided by the principles of distributive justice. The concept includes the available quantities of goods, the process by which goods are to be distributed, and the resulting allocation of the goods to the members of society.
“It is often thought that ethical validity and ethical universality stand and fall together, that a moral norm can be binding only if it is binding everywhere and at all times” (Borgman, 2006, pg. 40).
John Rawls (1976), stated, “Justice is the first virtue of social institutions.” Thus it is widely regarded as an important concept and influential force in philosophy and the social sciences”.
In the United States, as elsewhere, issues of distributive justice are connected to concerns about systematic poverty and racism, and questions about the fairness of affirmative action; policies that grant preferential treatment to particular racial or gender group. While it is clear to most people that skin color or religion should not be valid criteria of distribution, real-life experiences suggest that such factors often turn out to be quite significant.
In his Theory of Justice, John Rawls states that one’s place of birth, social status and family influences are matters of luck that should not unduly influence the amount of

Utilitarianism: Distributive Justice

felicity and benefit the people. However, it is not as encouraging in terms of distributive justice. While the employment of utilitarianism as a tool to analyze the State’s decisions can provide justice to many people, ultimately it disregards the benefit of individual people and can lead to distribution that is both unjust and imbalanced. Based on its core philosophy, utilitarianism seems promising in its ability to ensure justice is administered to the most people. The State’s role, according to the ideology…

Words 589 - Pages 3

Nozick on Distributive Justice Essay

Justice Paper 2 -Ankur Shah Nozick says that "liberty upsets patterns." Critically assess this claim. Be sure to: I. Explain what the quoted phrase means (what Nozick means by “liberty” and by “patterns”); II. Discuss how Rawls would respond to Nozick’s thesis; III. Explain whether Nozick is right that liberty upsets patterns; IV. If Nozick is right, then discuss whether such "upsetting" of patterns provides a sound reason for rejecting patterns, or for regulating liberty.…

Words 3145 - Pages 13

History of Distributive Justice in Prisons Essay

History of Distributive Justice in Prisons Nicole Galarza Student DeVry University Abstract The fundamental value of a harmonious society is justice. Justice is basically the common sense of the common good or public goods of a certain community. A prison is a place where offenders are removed and detached from society because they have committed a petty or serious crime. Prisons have taken part in a huge role in our history. While at times we might not think about it, prisons are a huge reason…

Words 1251 - Pages 6

Essay business ethics

accordance with the principle of justice in acquisition is entitled to that holding. If someone gains something legally and it doesn’t affect someone else, then they have the right to what they gain. If someone was to plant a vegetable garden in their back yard that did not affect anyone else, then they are entitled to what comes out of that garden. #2- The second of Nozicks principles is, A person who acquires a holding in accordance with the principle of justice in transfer, from someone…

Words 953 - Pages 4

Essay on Should equality be a political ideal

and distributive equality are, moving onto looking at which of the two is more necessary and appropriate. The benefits and disadvantages of the two shall then be assessed. Finally, this essay shall establish that the argument that equality should be a political ideal is unnecessary, as equality is implied in other political ideas such as justice and democracy. In his book, ‘Political Philosophy’, Adam Swift implies the identification of two kinds of equality- formal equality and distributive equality…

Words 2045 - Pages 9

Essay on defining justice

People commit it to fulfill their needs, to fit in and etc. Law: The law is a skeleton or framework for justice. It is only one institution in the study of justice. Justice study is interdisciplinary including: the study of law, philosophy, social studies (e.g. psychology, sociology, history), political science, criminology. 2 common rules apply to considering the issues and topics of justice : 1. Putting our own ethnocentrism aside 2. We must recognize the perspectives of the marginalized, poor…

Words 755 - Pages 4

Retributive Justice Model

The retributive model and the utilitarian model of justice are similar in many ways. Both models require the criminal justice system to adhere to the written laws in place when responding to an offense, in addition to pandering to the unspoken rules of society as well. When the distributive justice theory is applied, however, the difference between these two models of justice becomes clearer. The utilitarian model is considered forward-looking in nature, whereas the retributive model is considered…

Words 530 - Pages 3

Aristotle Economic Inequality

Aristotle identifies justice as the “complete virtue in the fullest sense” because justice is, in itself, an “active exercise of complete virtue,” that one must “exercise it in relation to another person” (Aristotle 69). However, when examined from a broader perspective, justice takes the form of fair distribution of honors and wealth, and also provides the pattern of all transactions, whether voluntary…

Words 1520 - Pages 7

Are inequalities ever just? Essay

Are inequalities ever just ? Considering this issue requires considering two essentially contrasted concepts which are equality and justice. In a great part of the world, it is taken for granted that all individuals are of equal moral worth, no matter their gender or ethnicity. All individuals therefore are treated equally by the law and should be granted equal fundamental rights, such as liberty of expression or the right to vote. However, there are great (and increasing) inequalities in terms…

Words 2320 - Pages 10

Procedural Justice Summary

positive expectations about the authority’s actions and intentions. Types of trust include; affect-based trust, cognitive-based trust, and disposition-based trust. Justice, ethics, trust, and stress are all interrelated, one way or another. For instance, justice related actions can function as behavioral evidence of trustworthiness. Justice can be used to measure trust, and ethics can also be used to measure trust. Many times, trust, and the greatest bonds are created in the most challenging circumstances…

Words 741 - Pages 3