Don Marquis Abortion

Words: 1204
Pages: 5
Open Document
When it comes to the ethics of killing, Don Marquis presents a unique position that differs from the typical arguments centered around personhood or the qualities that determine moral status. Marquis believes that killing is wrong not because of its effects on the killer or the effects on those in the victim’s life, but rather its impact on the victim’s future (Marquis 1989, 189). This paper aims to evaluate his argument based on the deprivation of potential future experiences, particularly in the context of abortion, where the ethics of abortion are weighed against the fetus’s potential future deprivation. To frame his argument as to why killing is wrong, Marquis first addresses possible counterarguments. He states that some might believe …show more content…
His argument against abortion does not rely on the specific characteristics of a person, such as their level of consciousness, their social roles/status, or their capacity for relationships. One of the main strengths lies in its uniqueness, which appeals to the future possibilities prohibited by abortion, rather than getting tangled up in the complexities of determining when life begins or what a “person” is. This allows his view to be applied broadly, encompassing not just humans, but all members of the species Homo sapiens, emphasizing a shared potential for a valued future. (Marquis 1989, 190-192) Additionally, this view can explain why humans think killing is such a terrible thing, which is because they are deprived of the rest of their lives. It resonates with a universally recognized sense of loss, particularly in the premature end of young lives often described with sentiments like “they had so much left ahead of them” or “they had so much potential,” indicating that we think killing is so terrible due to the fact the victim failed to live out their …show more content…
This line of reasoning provides a defense against claims that this argument fails to consider the competing futures of the mother and fetus. However, no matter which way you look at it, this aspect of his argument is circular and continues to go back to the application of what is considered “valuable.” In this sense, we would be stuck in a position of weighing futures, a task tainted with personal bias, signifying an immense weakness in his argument. Furthermore, since the concern is that the immorality of abortion is grounded in the deprivation of a valuable future, then a similar argument could be made about contraception since it prevents the existence of a potential future. Thus, if preventing a valuable future is wrong, then contraception could be deemed wrong for the same reason. This extension brings about another quandary in which there is fogginess in where and how we make a distinction between actions that prevent life and those that end life. Overall, Don Marquis’s argument against abortion, grounded in the wrongness of depriving an individual of a valuable future, exhibits a compelling argument regarding the ethics of
Show More

Related Documents: Don Marquis Abortion

Don Marquis Abortion Summary

Don Marquis is the author of the second essay, opposed to abortion. Marquis’ main goal throughout the essay is to argue that most abortions are extremely immoral except in rare cases. He believes that murder is murder and disregards any defense or abortion because he sees abortion as denying the fetus from the right to live or having a future (Ethics in Practice: An Anthology, 143). Marquis basically tries to get his point across of how it is completely wrong and unacceptable to kill a human being…

Words 104 - Pages 1

Don Marquis Abortion Analysis

Within this essay by Don Marquis, Marquis explains his opinion that abortion is definitely more on the pro-life side of the spectrum. He also believes that abortion is the act of killing a being with a right to life and killing a being with a right to life is seriously morally wrong because it robs such a being of its future. Marquis means to convey that the act of killing an unborn child should be seen just as cruel as the murder of an innocent adult man. Before beginnings to discuss his own view…

Words 489 - Pages 2

Essay about Response to Don Marquis' "Why Abortion Is Immoral"

Don Marquis' "Why Abortion is Immoral" In his essay "Why Abortion is Immoral," Don Marquis argues against the morality of abortion on the premise that the value of a fetus' future is so great that it is immoral to take that potential future away from it. Essentially, he contends, abortion is tantamount to murder: killing an individual is prima facie wrong because the loss of the goods of one's future is the worst loss a human can suffer. He calls this potential future a "future-like-ours,"…

Words 1918 - Pages 8

Abortion Debate Essay

In this paper I will discuss the great moral dilemma of committing an abortion. This issue of whether having an abortion is morally justified has been very controversial to many people for a long time, and still continues to be one today. As a context to this argument we are given a story of Mrs. Adams and her husband who decided to have an abortion after a contraceptive method went wrong. After forgetting to take her contraceptive pill one night Mrs. Adams ends up getting pregnant, and because…

Words 1498 - Pages 6

Abortion: A Woman's Prerogative Essays

should be enough to silence those pro-lifers who believe that this should be overturned and stating that it is immorally wrong to have an abortion. Abortion can also be argued to be seen as criminal because the unborn child is not able to defend itself at all. As explained by author Caitlin E. Borgmann in The meaning of "life": belief and reason in the abortion debate A person is allowed to defend herself against an unlawful force, but her own force must be proportional to the force used against…

Words 1331 - Pages 6

Don Marquis Argument Analysis

Abortion is defined as the deliberate termination of the human pregnancy, typically performed before the first 28 weeks. In this paper, I will discuss the moral permissibility of performing any type of abortion, and I will refute Don Marquis argument against abortion as it fails to consider the mother’s autonomy and rights. Marquis has demonstrated the impermissibility of abortion in his paper Why abortion is immoral. After analyzing the standard pro-choice, and pro-life arguments, he concluded…

Words 972 - Pages 4

Analysis Of Don Marquis's Argument That Abortion Is Wrong

Abortion has generated considerable debate with supporters and opponents widely labeled as “pro-choice” and “pro-life” respectively. Despite both sides feverously arguing that their view is better, abortion is a topic that is widely misunderstood and mischaracterized considering how both sides employ similar arguments and thus causes great confusion. In this essay, I set out to support the claim that abortion, except perhaps in rare circumstances, is seriously wrong. In the first section, I will…

Words 1839 - Pages 8

Abortion: The Ethical Battle Essay

Abortion: The Ethical Battle Background Abortion has been around since the beginning of recorded history, but only now in the 21st century has it become something that is frowned upon. In many cultures such as the Assyrian, Jewish, and Greek, it was very normal to have abortions and was not at all frowned on. In fact, the Romans would use abortion to limit family sizes. Even in these situations though the father of the family would always take the decision as to whether or not it was ethical…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

Who Is Don Marquis

1 Don Marquis, in his essay “Why Abortion is Immoral,” argues that abortion is morally impermissible. 2 Marquis is challenging the potential of personhood. This view asserts that abortion is wrong because it prevents a potential person (the fetus) from developing into an actual person. According to this view, the moral status of the fetus depends on its potential to become a person with a valuable future. Marquis argues that if we accept the potential personhood view, we must also consider other…

Words 650 - Pages 3

An Argument That Abortion Is Wrong

ethics that come into play regarding a morally controversial decision such as abortion has been debated and challenged many times over with no right answer. There are rare exceptions as to when abortion may be considered, but it is ultimately wrong to intentionally act in bringing about the death of a fetus for the sake of the woman who carries it. In the article, “An Argument that Abortion is Wrong” by Don Marquis, abortion is wrong for the same sake that killing and murdering a human being is wrong;…

Words 958 - Pages 4