Duty to Warn Essay

Words: 1506
Pages: 7
Open Document
Duty to Warn
Jessica Hall
PSYCH/545
09/4/2011
Dr. P.

Duty to Warn
The ethical dilemma I wish to explore is The Duty to Warn. This refers to the duty of a counselor, therapist to breach one of the most important bonds between a client and a therapist; the law of confidentiality. The therapist has the right to break confidentiality without the fear of being brought up for legal action. If the therapist believes that the client poses a danger, or is a threat to himself, someone else, or society as a whole, the therapist must decide how serious of a threat the client may be, then if he decides it’s a serious issue, he must notify the person in danger, which would e the third party, or the police, or other people who may be in the …show more content…
The only unethical standard would be to know that the client will pose a threat to someone, and do nothing, or do not report it, and someone ends up hurt, or worse, dead. 6. Review relevant legal standards.
As I stated in the beginning, Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 1976. The therapist has a right to inform a 3rd part if their client proves to be a threat to them. Another case, in which the court included going over clients past records or files to see if any patterns or history of violence is present, is the case of Jablonski by Pahls v. United States in 1983. Mr. Jablonski was dating Ms. Kimball, and he threatened to kill her and her mother. After he continued to threaten her mother, Ms. Kimball took him to the Loma Linda VA Hospital, the doctor did a risk assessment, but he failed to look at his past records, which would have let him know that Mr. Jablonski had a violent past. The doctor determined he was not a threat, but told Ms. Kimball to be careful, when he was released, he killed her. 7. Review the relevant research and theory.
Research does not have to be done to know that a person’s safety comes first. Any client, that a therapist feels may be in harm’s way, or may present harm to someone else, must
Show More

Related Documents: Duty to Warn Essay

Fleck Duty To Warn Summary

Traditionally, the duty to protect innocent 3rd parties far outweighs the duty of confidentiality with that being said, confidentiality should almost always be broken to protect the 3rd parties’ life and/or well-being. Fleck and Angell both believe that there is a duty to warn and that confidentiality is not absolute. However, Fleck believes in certain conditions that must be met in order for that “duty to warn” is met. In the “Please don’t tell” article Fleck believes that the duty to warn is not met…

Words 694 - Pages 3

Ethical Dilemmas

This is decidedly because Moore had knowledge of danger and had not acted further to warn of his client’s hazard. I believe this ruling pressures psychologists to legally safe proof their judgement call. In overhearing a child shouting “you’re dead meat” to a sibling that they are chasing --or when someone flippantly says “they’re dead to me” in reference to an ex-lover, would you fear an oncoming passion-murder? Can this be a probable cause for danger? I would not anticipate any harm to come of…

Words 1341 - Pages 6

Case Study: Redmond V. Washington

1. The parties of this case include the administrator of Mr. Allen’s estate who petitioned this case against Mary Lu Redmond and her former employer. The suit was filed in the Federal district court. The Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reviewed the case and called for a retrial. This suit was brought to the U.S. Supreme Court. This case was argued on February 26, 1996 and was decided on June 13, 1996. 2. On June 27, 1991, Redmond responded to a call at an apartment complex reporting a…

Words 1006 - Pages 5

Kelly V. Movie Theatre: Negligence

against unreasonable risk of harm and is proven by the following elements: a duty of care was owed by a defendant, that duty was breached, and that breach was the actual and proximate cause of the damages to the plaintiff. Special Duty-Land occupier, Business Invitee The movie theater is the land occupier, one in possession of the property. Kelly is a customer of the movie theatre, a business invitee. The land occupier owes a duty of reasonable care to the business invitee to inspect and discover dangerous…

Words 1505 - Pages 7

Why Is Confidentiality Important In Counseling

Counselors have a duty to protect and warn potential victims. There are three conditions that must be met before breaking confidentiality. First, the client communicates to the counselor a threat of physical violence. Next, the threat must be serious. Finally, the victims must…

Words 322 - Pages 2

Essay on Commercial law case study

Issue: Had the defendant the Arctic Ice Skating Rink’s actions been ‘negligent’? Had Charles’s injury been reasonably foreseeable? Did the Arctic Ice Skating Rink owe Charles a duty of care? Whether any defenses might be raised by the defendant? Did the surgeon have the responsibility for the unsuccessful operation which leads to Charles spending longer in hospital? Relevant law: Negligence involves the failure to exercise reasonable care and skill, which includes both advertent and…

Words 1360 - Pages 6

New Jersey Fall-Down Accidents

can be arduous and expensive, with hospital bills, rehabilitation facility bills, loss of income, and permanent injury. Under New Jersey’s premises liability law, a property owner owes certain duties to members of…

Words 491 - Pages 2

Brown-Forman Corp. V. Brune Case

approved because it would have implied that there was a safe "dosage" of alcohol intake. If such label could hypothetically be made, there is no proof that Marie would have looked at or regarded the warning label, therefore Brown-Forman has no legal duty to place instructions or warning labels on its alcoholic beverages. Evidence shows that Marie had knowledge regarding the abuse of alcohol. A text book that was used by Marie shows that high amounts of cocktails can result in fatal consequences. Friends…

Words 602 - Pages 3

Democracy: Complaint and Dr. Moore Essay

2d 334 NO. 23042 Argued: July 1, 1976 Facts: Tatiana’s parent’s (Plaintiff’s and Appellants) represented by counsel (George Alexander McKray) filed actions of failure to detain a dangerous patient, to warn on a dangerous patient, abandonment of a dangerous patient and breach of primary duty to patient and public to (Defendants and Respondents) Dr. Lawrence Moore (psychologist), Dr. Harvey Powelson (Dr. Moore’s Superior) the police force, and The Regents of the University of California seeking…

Words 610 - Pages 3

Ethical Dilemmas In The Context Of Health And Human Services

values, making it difficult to determine the right course of action. These dilemmas often arise when there are competing interests, obligations, or duties, and no clear solution that satisfies all moral considerations. In the context of health and human services, ethical dilemmas can manifest in various ways, such as confidentiality vs. duty to warn. A counselor learns that their client is planning to harm someone else. They are torn between respecting the confidentiality of the therapeutic relationship…

Words 195 - Pages 1