Essay On Descartes Meditations

Submitted By PeterNolan
Words: 974
Pages: 4
Open Document
Peter Nolan
Professor Daniel Shannon
Introduction to Philosophy
November 24, 2014
God & the Necessity of Evil In Rene Descartes Meditation IV, he explores the problem of error (evil) and why he is “subject to an infinitude of errors”(20) when it is inconsistent to believe that God, the most perfect being, would be directly responsible for evil through the creation of defective creatures. By analyzing Descartes premises in Meditation IV, I will demonstrate how he has truly solved the problem of evil in a world created by the most perfect being, with the conclusion that evil is necessary for God’s existence and is a result of free will.
He begins by establishing the impossibility that God would deceive him because imperfection is found in the qualities of “fraud and deception”(19) and it would be a contradiction for the most perfect being to have qualities of imperfection. Next he reasons that he has experienced in himself a “certain capacity for judging” and that God would not give him a faculty that would lead him “to err if [he] use(s) it aright”(19). However, he is aware that although in his mind he finds no cause of error, he has still experienced error. Descartes concludes that the mind is split into two distinct parts: the perfect but limited wit (intellect) and the imperfect but very powerful free will. It is inconsistent to think the perfect part of the mind would be the cause of error; therefore, the cause of error must lie in his freewill. When considering why God would give freewill to his creations, Descartes suggests that without freewill, he would cease to be more than a machine and that by having the power to affirm the false and deny the truth; he is actually a more perfect being than a machine. Furthermore, he realizes that as an imperfect being, he is finite. Otherwise, he would be an infinite, perfect being; making him the most perfect being. Since God is the most perfect being, He cannot create another perfect being or God would be creating God. God cannot create God because of God’s unitary nature. As a result, Descartes must be finite and his ability to distinguish between truth and error is also finite. This is why his freewill is more powerful than his intellect; his intellect is limited by his understanding but his freewill is unrestrained (shown by his ability to affirm the false and deny the truth). Descartes explains the problem of evil-understood as the creation of defective creatures-as necessary for God’s unitary existence and for the existence of free will which ultimately allows imperfect beings to seek their own perfect nature.
I believe it is impossible for us to be perfect when we are made up of two opposing parts: the perfect intellect and the imperfect will. According to Descartes, God is the most supremely good being (20). Furthermore, God is the most perfect being; therefore perfection includes all good qualities. On the other hand, imperfection lacks some good qualities and in their place are some bad qualities. Thus we are the source of error; which is synonymous with evil according to Descartes. Despite God being the most perfect being, He indirectly created evil through the creation of defective creatures. Although it seems illogical for a perfect being to create imperfect creatures, it is necessary for God to exist. Every quality must have an opposite in order to exist. The essence of this duality forming a whole is captured by the Chinese philosophy of Yin-Yang. Whether life and death, light and dark, or good and evil; there are two opposing sides that maintain the balance. This translates to God and the necessity of evil because they oppose one another; yet need each other to exist. Without one,
Show More

Related Documents: Essay On Descartes Meditations

Essay on Descartes Meditation Four

Dalene Fulk Cypress Philo 100 Descartes Meditation Four 3-13-14 The Meditator reasons in his Meditation Four that it is impossible for God to ever deceive him since deception and trickery are indicators of some level of imperfection and that the ability to betray, defraud, cheat or victimize is also an indication of cleverness and power and further the will to deceive must surely show a weakness. The Meditator further says "deception…

Words 414 - Pages 2

Essay about The Meditations of René Descartes: Never Believe What You See – I Don’t Mind If I Do

Within Meditations on First Philosophy (1641), René Descartes undertakes the project of developing a new belief system regarding his existence. Descartes begins this project by demolishing his former belief system. Having his trust in the senses eliminated through a process of methodical doubt, Descartes attempts to establish a sound platform, upon which he will build an indubitable foundation for all knowledge. Upon evaluation of the first two meditations, three conditions for establishing this…

Words 2052 - Pages 9

Rene Descartes Meditation 2

Shortlidge March 12, 2013 Essay #2 Prof. Kraft Descartes’ Meditation II René Descartes wrote the Meditation II, along with the other five, during the 1640s. The Meditation II talks about the nature of the human body and functions of the brain but begins with the explanation of how strong doubts exist in Meditation I (Descartes 1). The difference of what actually appears and what is perceived to be there are the two main topics examined. (Descartes 1-16). The Meditation II is very tricky, but…

Words 725 - Pages 3

Descartes Second Meditation By John Cottingham

central theme which forms a common thread through all six of Descartes’ Meditations as ‘’doubt, stretched to its limits, as an instrument which self –destructs, impelling him forwards on the journey towards certainty and truth.’’1. This is particularly prevalent for the Cogito (ego sum, ego existo – I am, I exist) and what is reveals about existence, which will be my main emphasis for this essay. The Second Meditation begins with Descartes using the example of Archimedes who ‘’used to demand one firm…

Words 304 - Pages 2

John Locke Innate Ideas

critique of innate ideas with explicit reference to Descartes The debate surrounding innate ideas is not a recent controversy in philosophy as opinions have been known to differ on whether the mind is born with innate knowledge, or whether knowledge is learned. Seventeenth century philosophers John Locke and Rene Descartes held conflicting views on the topic of innatism, with Locke arguing against the idea and Descartes supporting it. This essay will explore Locke’s main criticisms which include…

Words 2030 - Pages 9

The Concept of Power in International Politics Essay

from clear and distinct perceptions, and from simplicity, Descartes attempts to prove in “The Meditations” that the mind is distinct and separate from the body. This view is now known as Cartesian Dualism. In this essay I will outline Descartes’ main arguments, some of the criticisms of dualism, and my opinion as to which argument I perceive as the most convincing. The first argument in Cartesian Dualism is the Argument from doubt. Descartes starts by concluding that although he can conceive the possibility…

Words 1587 - Pages 7

Meditation on First Philosophy Essay

First Essay Assignment Question: Meditation on First Philosophy It can be seen that Descartes Meditations on first philosophy raised a lot of questions regarding the existence and nature of the self, the existence of God, the nature of truth and the possibility of error, and finally also the essence and existence of bodies along other things. Descartes did all this through the medium of his six meditations. Descartes from his very first Meditation, that of concerning things that can be called…

Words 2560 - Pages 11

Essay on Descartes' Epistemology

Epistemology ------------------------------------------------- Carefully explain Descartes’ cogito and his attempt to build his knowledge structure from the ground up. (Be as succinct as possible.) Does Descartes succeed or fail in that attempt? Justify your answer in full. Descartes’ Epistemology This essay attempts to explain Descartes’ epistemology of his knowledge, his “Cogito, Ergo Sum” concept (found in the Meditations), and why he used it [the cogito concept] as a foundation when building his…

Words 1720 - Pages 7

Mind and Descartes Essay

Discussion Analyses January 21, 2015 Rene Descartes: Meditation 1 an d2 1. Identify the author’s essay thesis, i.e. the position the author supports on the topic. Descartes begins to question and place doubt on all the beliefs that come to us from senses. He basically questions is it knowledge and if so what makes it different from opinion. 2. Identify the position against which the essay’s author argues. Descartes uses three very similar arguments to open all our knowledge…

Words 635 - Pages 3

Rene Descartes Research Paper

Adopt A Philosopher: Rene Descartes Rene Descartes was a philosopher, scientist, and mathematician. Not only did he contribute to the philosophical world, but he also contributed to the mathematics world as well. Due to Rene Descartes, students taking geometry can now find the distance between two points on a graph and philosophers have more insight on some of the many theoretical thoughts that he had. Rene was born on March 31, 1596 in La Haye, Touraine, France and died at the age of 53 on February…

Words 464 - Pages 2