Ethical Arguments Against Eugenics

Words: 735
Pages: 3
Open Document
EUGENICS
A question raised by biochemistry student Grace Farley proposed the idea that the idea of Eugenics might not be as negative as it’s name brings to the minds of many people. Farley wrote ‘if germ line editing is helping people alleviate the risks of passing along harmful alleles in their gametes, then is it eugenics?’ The idea of the eugenics slippery slope is one of the most significant arguments against gene editing of somatic cells. People who argue against gene editing suggest that a slippery slope could form where by designer babies would be made from genetically manipulated in order for them to have what parents, and society, consider to be ‘genetically ideal.’

The oxford dictionary defines eugenics as ‘the science …show more content…
Whilst everyone has an idea of what they consider to be ideal, sometimes based on societal norms, what could be considered as ideal now could change quite dramatically over the next decades and centuries. Therefore, Caplan and Magnus were prescient in their thinking that ‘There is nothing terrible about subjectivity in a decision to indulge preferences about the traits of one's child as long as those preferences do nothing to hurt or impair the …show more content…
- TRIED TO CREATE THE PERFECT AYRAN RACE!
SAYING THAT PEOPLE WHO HAVE THIS GROUP OF CONDITIONS ARE NOT WORTH IT!
Adolf Hitler represented the extreme end of the negative eugenics argument that he applied to the ideology that non-Aryan people were inferior. His beliefs lead to the holocaust and the catastrophic loss of more than six million people. Many people who argue against the idea of gene editing suggest that should gene editing begin then it could potentially develop to become something akin to the holocaust. Through the manipulation of genes in order to be considered ‘genetically ideal,’ anti editors argue that society would begin to shun those who would not be perfect, and thus leading to an unequal
Show More

Related Documents: Ethical Arguments Against Eugenics

Eugenics Movement Essay

Proposal Eugenics Not many know that eugenics was prevalent in America during the 1900's or know how and why it was done. In the early 1900's America sought out to create a healthier and genetically fitter society; by forcibly sterilizing "unfit" citizens, even without consent. Not known by the public this idea was then adopted by the late Hitler himself for the purpose of creating a "perfect" race. Since the start of the eugenics movement it has had many backlashes and is not outlawed in the United…

Words 3556 - Pages 15

Genetic: Eugenics Movement Essay

Eugenics Eugenics gained popularity throughout the late 19th and early 20th centuries, as some scientists incorrectly believed that many human behaviors, like alcoholism or social dependency, were solely the product of genes, independent of environmental influences.(1/4 Hix, Laura, (2009). Modern Eugenics. 2/7 Lewis, Ricki “concepts and applications” 10th edition 5 Pickens, L. Donald, (1968). Eugenics 6 O’keefe, John, (1995). Eugenics. 8 www.Publiceye.org, 1995. 9 www.facing…

Words 2085 - Pages 9

Gender Stereotypes

Argument One: Sex Discrimination and Gender Stereotypes Sex selection and PGD for non-medical purposes should be discouraged as it may contribute to sex discrimination that would result in a distorted sex ratio. According to consequentialists, by allowing reproductive techniques for such purposes, sex stereotyping and discrimination might be enhanced rather than reduced. The consequentialist perspective is that the right act in any circumstance is one that produces preeminent results by good reason…

Words 1870 - Pages 8

Genetic Manipulation Of Humans

would have no say is unrealistic because what child would argue against being born with a stronger heart or being cured of a chronic disease? To counter the argument of parents only viewing their children as genetic perfection and no longer feeling parental feeling critics may take a look at the parents of children born with disabilities in modern day. They have fierce love for their children despite their born flaws (Green 3). The argument of a divided society is a more real threat than any other worry…

Words 1269 - Pages 6

Pros And Cons Of Sex Selection Of Embryos

‘designer babies’ through non-medical sex selection of embryos, i.e. the selection of embryos for a reason other than medical purposes. A ‘designer baby’ is an embryo that has been genetically modified to produce certain desired traits. There are ethical concerns that non-medical sex selection of embryos can represent a withdrawal from the universal aim of medicine to cure and/or alleviate pain. The notion also questions established concepts about a parent’s acceptance of their child, the unconditional…

Words 1780 - Pages 8

Genetic Engineering of DNA Informative Essay

create small organisms that eat our wastes. This means that future generations could be void of some widespread disorders that we have today as well as many other benefits. As you can imagine, there is a lot of controversy about whether or not GE is ethical. My opinion about genetic engineering is that it can be beneficial if it is used wisely. For thousands of years, people have bread the strongest male bull with the biggest female cow. They did this because the outcome of two strong and big parents…

Words 1025 - Pages 5

Essay about DSST1summer2 7

Karyn Valerius Office: 301 Mason Hall Phone: (516) 463-6817 Email: Karyn.M.Valerius@hofstra.edu 1. Course Description: This course offers an introduction to the field of disability studies. Disability studies approaches disability not as an individual tragedy or a medical problem but as a cultural construct--akin to gender and race--that undergirds social practices and cultural representations in various media. This course draws on various disciplinary perspectives to understand the broad and complex…

Words 2524 - Pages 11

Effects of Social Darwinism Essay

Introduction The Effects of Social Darwinism on the social trends of the 19th century. “As a world view, Darwinism cannot of course be refuted, since Faith is, always has been, and always will be, stronger than facts. “ - Francis P. Yockey Social Darwinism is a theory that competition among all individuals, groups, nations or ideas drives social evolution in human societies. The term draws upon Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection, where competition between individual organisms drives…

Words 2904 - Pages 12

Essay on The Positive and Negative Effects of Dna Profiling

area of which all people should be somewhat knowledgeable. DNA profiling has many uses, both positive and negative, in our society. Aside from its usefulness in many legal investigations, DNA profiling can be used in the workplace to discriminate against employees whose profiles could pose a financial risk. For example, genetic technology can and has been used to determine the capacity of a person to contract certain diseases, such as…

Words 2642 - Pages 11

Cloning As Source Of Organs Essay

1999;25:87-95 we Should a source of human tissue The Murdoch Savulescu Julian clone for Institute, at all, is to provide or tissues for medical use, Some have argued transplantation. especially this raises 4. cells no new issues ethical those above or fetuses to produce raised cloning the sake embryos for cells, tissues or even organs for therapy, or fetus. by abortion of the embryo followed ofMedical (Journal Keywords: onic stem Ethics Cloning; cells; fetal It uses…

Words 7788 - Pages 32