Ethics and Loving Thing Essay

Submitted By praabb
Words: 1558
Pages: 7
Open Document
I. Examine the strengths and weaknesses of Situation Ethics. (21)
May 2013

Situation Ethics is a teleological theory which takes a relativist approach by doing the most loving thing according to the situation and the predicted consequence regardless of laws and rules. The theory also focuses on which action will be most loving for the most people. Joseph Fletcher introduced this theory in 1966 when he released his book “Situation Ethics: The New Morality.” He expresses that he wanted to create a middle ground between legalism and antinomianism as he felt people were becoming secular. He wanted to bring Christians back to the Church.

Situation Ethics (SE) has many strengths, firstly it’s very flexible it allows you to consider the different aspects to the situation unlike many other deontological theories that have a much more legalistic approach. For example, Christians believe that murder is wrong in any context or situation however a SE approach would accept the choice of abortion if the person who is pregnant had been raped as it could be considered as the lesser of two evils as the mother didn’t want a child and may not want to be constantly reminded of the traumatic event.

Another strength is it follows the teaching of Jesus in the sense that it’s main focus is agape love which is a core belief in Christianity. It’s important that SE was influenced by Jesus as Fletcher introduced it with intentions to bring Christians back to the Church because people were becoming secular. Jesus demonstrated SE on many occasions, one being when he healed one of his followers a man on the Sabbath day as he knew that would be the most loving thing to do. Knowing Jesus had followed the same Ethic is an important aspect for Christians who follow SE as it is reassuring for them that the Ethic has a religious root.

A further strength is the fact that it gave people a sense of freedom. Due to the introduction of contraception and the civil rights movement, people were warming to the fact of thinking for themselves especially considering that the Church’s rigid rules were becoming an issue to those who wanted to move forward with the social changes despite the Church refusing to change for society. SE allows a modern take on religion in the sense that it has Christian morals but isn’t so legalistic as Robinson stated it was for “man come of age” meaning it was for those moving ahead with the times. For example, if a criminal asked you if you were aware of his next victims whereabouts, a Christian would be honest as lying is a sin however someone using a SE approach would lie to protect that person as it would be the most loving thing for that person and would have the most positive result.

Adding on to the point of freedom, people were beginning to drift away from the Church due the introduction of the contraceptive pill giving more women freedom and power over their decisions. Also, the Vietnam war forced women to take on the roles of the men and become more independant. All these things lead to a lack of faith in Christianity as people were beginning to realise they don’t need set rules in order to make the right decisions as they have become familiar with relying on themselves which meant Situation Ethics was very convenient and accepted at the time. However there are many weaknesses to SE. One being that it focuses on the end result, it assumes a sense omniscience in predicting what the end result would be which of course is impossible as a consequentialist theory isn’t very effective as humans can’t predict the future. You can never be sure your action will have the intended result and could turn out to have a negative impact which may suggest that human do need structure and rules in order to make decisions. For example if someone is having trouble with school work and you insist on helping them but they end up getting in trouble as it was an independent task although you had good intentions, the result that you had
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics and Loving Thing Essay

Pet Situation Ethics Essay

situation ethics Situation ethics is based on the idea that you do the most loving thing in a situation, even if it leads to breaking the law. It is known as a relativistic theory. It has no absolute rules that have to be followed in every circumstance. It is also a consequentialist theory, where the end result is held to be of great importance. Finally it is a teleological theory, claiming the morale truth can be found through nature and purpose. Joseph Fletcher, who focused on situation ethics, came…

Words 635 - Pages 3

Essay Ms Hirani

AS Religious Studies Revision: Situation Ethics AO1 Material: i.e. ‘what goes in part a)?’ What type of ethical theory is it? Teleological: it aims to bring about a greater good. It looks at what your ethical action is aimed at bringing about, rather than deontological ethics which focuses on the intrinsic rightness or wrongness of actions. Consequentialist: it looks at the consequences of actions, not the actions themselves. An action is deemed ‘good’ if it brings about good consequences…

Words 696 - Pages 3

The problem of evil Essay

believe that we just live one life and there is only one God so therefore the problem is why would God want to punish us and spread evil when we are just living our only life. There are also further problems for believers if God is omnibenevolent (all loving), omnipotent (all powerful), omniscient (all knowing) and Ex-Nihila which is God created the world out of nothing. So if God is omnibelevolent then why does he allow evil to exist is the question non-believers ask and if he loved everyone and everything…

Words 4461 - Pages 18

Ethical Teachings and How They Guide Adherents in Their Daily Lives Essays

Religion essay Ethical teachings and how they guide adherents in their daily lives Ethics can be defined as ‘Human moral conduct according to principles of what is good or right to do’. In Christianity there are certain ethical teachings, mainly The Ten Commandments, Beatitudes, and Jesus’ commandments of love. The Ten Commandments are derived from the Old Testament which defines what people must do in order to serve God faithfully and gives direction on how to live a life according to the covenant…

Words 1029 - Pages 5

Buddhism Vs Confucianism

As I read about Confucius in the description of him by Warren Matthews in World Religions can be seen as a teacher more of a teacher of ethics than religion as I understood the reading. To begin, I say that Confucius is more of a teacher of ethics than religion because Confucius focuses on getting people to be good in society as having a social reasonability in helping each other. For example, “the husband has responsibility for li toward his wife as she has an obligation for li toward him” shows…

Words 511 - Pages 3

Personal Code of Ethics Essay examples

Personal Code of Ethics Having a personal code of ethics is very important to me since it defines who I am and what my beliefs are. My ethical code symbolizes who I am as an individual as a result of my moral, religious, intellectual and cultural upbringing. One of my greatest wishes is for my personality and actions to clearly define my code of ethics, without me verbalizing or someone else reading it on a document. Some questions that I would like others to ask and come up with their…

Words 1518 - Pages 7

Shafer-Landau Argument

Let us set a few things straight. This is an argument to address the claims that God exists in order to create the moral standards, or laws. According to Shafer-Landau, most people believe that if the moral laws are to be considered objective, they must not have arisen from a human being. Because these moral laws are applicable to humans, they would not be objective if they were created by a person. For in the definition of objective, in order for the moral laws to be considered objective they must…

Words 1383 - Pages 6

Ethical Systems: Nonabsolutsm And Absolutism

Accounting Ethics Ethical systems are divided into two categories: nonabsolutism and absolutism (Geisler, 2010). The second category is in line with the Christian worldview, while the first one is not. The three main classes of values that are incompatible with the Christian worldview include antinomianism, situationism and generalism. On the other hand, those that are compatible include conflicting absolutism, unqualified absolutism and graded absolutism. According to Geisler (2010), Christian…

Words 879 - Pages 4

Essay on Religious tradition Depth study - Christianity

– CHRISTIANITY Outline and explain the beliefs and Ethics of Christianity Christianity can be defined as the religion that is based on the person Jesus of Nazareth and His beliefs and Ethics. Beliefs of Christianity include The Nature of God, The Revelation, Salvation, The Life, Death, Resurrection and Ascension of Christ, and, the Divinity and Humanity of Christ. Christian ethical teachings include the Ten Commandments, New Testament ethics, the Beatitudes, and Jesus’ commandment of love. Throughout…

Words 971 - Pages 4

Ethics, Goodness, Virtues and Wisdom Essay

Ethics, Goodness, Virtues and Wisdom Our most enjoyable experiences of personal refreshment have been surrounded with a setting of beauty. Beauty has the capacity to revigorate and refreshes our spirit. When we are celebrating great moments or conducting importing ceremonies/events we always select beautiful settings and play beautiful music. Beauty is able to bring not just a magnificent experience but also a positive self-assuring image. Beauty makes the aesthetic dimension of our lives. Unfortunately…

Words 2338 - Pages 10