Ethics Of Torture

Words: 1046
Pages: 5
Open Document
The United States government should never use torture in its counter-terrorism efforts as it is unethical and inconsistent with American values. Torture is defined as the intentional infliction of pain and suffering on a non-consenting victim for the purpose of breaking the victim’s will (Moser and McDonald 2015). Torture tactics include waterboarding, sleep deprivation, and solitary confinement. Torture is unethical in all situations and its supporters use irrational scenarios to defend its use in counter-terrorism efforts. Torture violates the individual rights ethical approach by subjecting non-consenting victims to extreme harm and suffering. The rights approach views “human beings as having the ability to choose freely what they want …show more content…
The virtue ethical approach states that there are certain ideals toward which we should strive (Velasquez et al 2014). These virtuous ideals include compassion, self-control, and integrity among many others. Under this approach, ethical actions enhance and cultivate virtuous ideals. The image of the United States comprises virtues such as freedom, equality, and human rights. Torture does not cultivate the virtuous ideals of society as a whole or the virtuous ideals of the United States. If any level of torture is allowed to occur, society may become desensitized to the idea of using torture and more torture will occur (Mayerfeld 2008). Desensitization may lead the United States to allow even more unethical acts that contradict society’s virtues. Each act of torture in the present makes it easier to accept the use of torture in the future. Torture does not cultivate virtues in the United States and damages its integrity. John McCain has argued that if the United States sinks to the level of its enemies we will “lose the moral standing that has made America unique in the world” (Evans 2007). Torture becomes counterproductive because it alienates target populations, such as Muslims, and may perpetuate the problem of terrorism (Mayerfeld 2008). Torture also damages the individual virtues of the people committing the torture. Under the …show more content…
The utilitarian ethical approach strives to maximize benefits and minimize harms for the greatest number of people (Moser and McDonald 2015). In the utilitarian approach, an action is ethical if it benefits many people. Defenders of torture use the ticking time bomb scenario to illustrate that torture is ethical under the utilitarian approach. In the ticking time bomb scenario a known terrorist is captured, a terrorist attack is imminent, and the captured terrorist has vital information that can prevent an attack (lecture). Krauthammer, and other defenders of torture argue that if you have a chance to save a great number of people by torturing a terrorist, it is your moral duty to do so (Krauthammer 2005). Under this approach, torture is considered ethical even in a slow fuse scenario where an attack is not imminent. Torture is considered ethical under the utilitarian approach because the harm of only one person benefits a large group of
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics Of Torture

War On Terrorism And The Ethics Of Torture

War on Terrorism and the Ethics of Torture For many years terrorism has played a major part in American history, dating back as far as the late 20th century. They're many parts to understand when exploring and understanding terrorism, such as ethical boundaries of counterterrorism operations, morality target killings, and the use of torture while dealing with a terrorist. When discussing terrorism, understand that they are two different types, domestic and international. Although domestic…

Words 1773 - Pages 8

Is Devine's Is Torture Ever Justified?

Assignment 8 — Rough Drafts It is universally acknowledged that torture, regarded as a kind of crime, is prohibited in any circumstances according to the human rights law. However, the fact is that it is still widely used around the world especially in third world nations’ military regimes. Therefore, the question “Is Torture Ever Justified?” has been put forward which evoked a heated debate. As professor Bagaric and Clarke claims, torture need to be regulated in some circumstances instead of totally…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

Essay about John Stuart Mill

Armando Reif Kaplan University Unit 2 Assignment: A Major Contributor To Ethical Theory Ethics and the Legal Environment Professor Mighdoll May 17, 2015 John Stuart Mill was born in 1806 to James Mill in Pentonville, London. As a child, he was subjected to a rigorous education by his father, in which he mastered English and classical languages. He also studied the law, logic and philosophy. At 17 he began a career with the British East India Company and suffered depression before turning 21. In…

Words 932 - Pages 4

Essay on morals of agreement

February 12, 2010 Morals By Argreement? APOLOGIA By Hendrik van der Breggen (The Carillon, February 11, 2010) Morals by agreement? A contemporary view of ethics (popular in theory and practice if not in name) is contractarianism, a.k.a. morals by agreement. Let’s get clear on this theory of ethics, and then let’s assess it from the point of view of critical/ careful thinking. Contractarianism can be traced back to the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679). Hobbes believed…

Words 997 - Pages 4

Evil Data Essay

the nature of Scientific Data is to help us explain natural phenomena, advance diagnosis/treatment in Medical Sciences, and help us to better understand and explain our environment. There have been times that collecting certain data has caused the torture of innocent humans, so would this data be considered evil or is the people collecting the data? Data cannot be evil, the people collecting the data are the ones that are evil. Following World War II Nazi physicians performed brutal medical experiments…

Words 374 - Pages 2

Water Boarding Vs Genetic Engineering

Ethics Ethics, What is it? Merriam-Websters dictionary defines it as “The discipline dealing with what is good and bad with moral duty and obligations.” Yet, if we look at many of the things we take for granted today, they remain available to us because of certain unethical and immoral activities that occur. Lets look at two very controversial issues that have come up today; water boarding and genetic engineering. Is water boarding a form of torture or not? Both sides bring a valid argument…

Words 1269 - Pages 6

Joseph Gonzalez Ethics Essay example

Joseph Gonzalez Philosophy 108 June 11, 2014 Living alongside with Torture An Ethical and Moral dilemma that has developed in modern day society is the idea behind the interrogation tactics used by our armed forces which is also known as torture. To many individuals, this idea is thought to have many different perspectives, both negative and positive according to ones moral capacity. In my opinion, this idea behind torture is acceptable only in the sense of using this idea to protect and positively…

Words 450 - Pages 2

Torture In The Military

Basically torture can be broken down into two sub categories: punitive and interrogational. Santucci (2008) defines interrogational torture as having the intent of extracting information that is considered pertinent to a higher cause from the detainee. This is the type of torture that would describe the purpose of its use by the U. S. in the War on Terror. Punitive torture is used to discipline or persuade the opinions of someone or a group of people (Santucci, 2008). This type of torture is most…

Words 707 - Pages 3

Aristotle's View Of Torture

of torture is deeply rooted in justice as it can serve as an either a means or an end, so in order us to draw a conclusion by both philosopher thoughts on the matter. We must first focus our attention to the concept of justice. Once we have determined each philosopher outlook justice we can then properly assess whether torture is just or unjust and if is condemned or accepted by either philosopher. We can begin by looking at Aristotle views which as describe in Book II of Nicomachean Ethics, are…

Words 1493 - Pages 6

Argumentative Essay On Torture

ON TORTURE This paper will systematically investigate different positions taken on the moral permissibility of torture, to reveal that torture is not to be accepted or justified under any circumstance. In order to effectively address the matter, we ought to come to definitional terms with “torture”, despite the lack of unanimity and the spread of contextual usage of the term. For the scope of this paper, the term “torture” will be adopted to refer to any act by which mental or physical pain…

Words 1031 - Pages 5