Ethics and Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

Words: 2176
Pages: 9
Open Document
Ethics and the Stanford Prison Experiment

In 1971 Philipp Zimbardo carried out one of the most ethically controversial psychological experiment the ‘Stanford Prison Experiment’. Originally he aimed to study how much our behavior is structured by the social role we occupy. Describing the study briefly 24 undergraduates with no criminal and psychological record were chosen for the research to play the roles of prisoners and guards in a mock prison situated in the basement of Stanford University Psychology Building, equipped by hidden cameras and microphones. As the lead researcher, Zimbardo was observing the events from a different room, giving instructions to the guards. The research was supposed to last about two weeks. However, …show more content…
Guards were instructing other prisoners to continually keep punching the door of the closet where prisoner 436 was put in. Eventually they tried to persuade the other prisoners that the only way the closet would open and their peer will be free if they give up their blankets and slept on their mattresses. Only one of the prisoners refused to do that. (Bradey, Longsdon.p706) From this sense it shall be quickly concluded that prisoners were also under physical harassments, once guards did adopt the negative attitude towards them, their aggression increased. The other main concern is why the researchers did not end the experiment when they saw what was happening in this stimulated prison? After all these ethical and moral violation the experiment continued for six days. As Zimbardo admitted, he also became immersed with his role of his role of being the instructor, providing orders to the guards. He could no longer objectively fulfill his role of lead researcher, (Harney et al. p.18) still he carried on with the process, knowing that the participants did not realize that they could leave the mock-prison whenever they wanted. When they were asked whether they wish to be released without receiving the amount on the contract, they said yes, but still returned to their cell when they were ordered following this discussion. By then they lost their real identity and voluntarily continued to be carry on the with the prisoner role. On the other
Show More

Related Documents: Ethics and Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

Ethics in the Name of Science Essay

Ethics in the Name of Science: A detailed Comparison Between Milgram and Zimbardo’s Internationally Renowned Attempts at Ethics in Social Science Experiments David Baxter Park University SO220 Ethical Issues in Social Science Kris Reichart-Anderson 2 October 2011 Abstract For years many experiments have been scrutinized for their ineffective use or lack of establishment of ethical principles within their research. Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison Experiment and Milgram’s Obedience experiment…

Words 1343 - Pages 6

Essay On The Stanford Prison Experiment

Stanford Prison Experiment The Stanford Prison experiment consisted of a study between twenty-one college students where the kids were able to choose their role as either a guard or prisoner. Ten prisoners and eleven guards were divided and all were brought to the psychology department building in Stanford University that was decorated by Zimbardo, the lead psychologist, to look like a prison. The guards and prisoners were uncertain how to act at first but quickly began to play their roles where…

Words 560 - Pages 3

Stanford Prison Experiment and Social Psychology Essay

Stanford Prison Experiment and Social Psychology Erica Mariscal Vigil PSYCH 620 Diana Wheatley 04/07/2014 Stanford Prison Experiment and Social Psychology Dr. Philip Zimbardo, a faculty member at Stanford University, conducted the Stanford Prison Experiment in 1971. The experiment was conducted in the basement of the psychology department at Stanford. According to Zimbardo, they study was “an attempt to see what happens when you put really good people in a bad place” (Classic…

Words 1118 - Pages 5

The Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

The Stanford Prison Experiment The Stanford prison experiment is the one of the most controversial psychological studies in the 20th century. This theory has its critics and supporters, but the results of the experiment became an interesting look on the human psyche in the form of role behavior and their expressions. In the year of 1971, a professor and psychologist named Dr. Philip Zimbardo has a theory that one’s nature didn’t impress their roles in what they do, but rather one’s role had an impact…

Words 916 - Pages 4

Zimbardo Research Paper

The Stanford Prison Experiment was a study conducted in 1971 by Dr. Phillip Zimbardo. According to Dr. Steve Taylor (2007), “It’s probably the best known psychological study of all time.” (Classic Studies in Psychology, 2007). Zimbardo stated that the point was to see what would happen if he put “really good people in a bad place” (Dr. Zimbardo, 2007). He did this during a time were most college students were protesting for peace and were against anything authoritarian. The experiment contained…

Words 1024 - Pages 5

Lucifer Effect Paper

psychologist and a professor emeritus of Stanford University. He was also known for the famous Stanford prison experiment that happened in 1971, where he randomly selected a dozen college students to be part of the experiment of a prison situation. This book details the significance of human nature and our ability to be perpetrators of evil. Through the discussions about the horrific abuse from Abu Ghraib, other real life examples, and the famous Stanford experiment from Zimbardo himself, we find the challenges…

Words 5548 - Pages 23

Critique the Power of Organizations from Weberian and Goffmanesque Perspective in the Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

Q 1. Critique the power of organizations from Weberian and Goffmanesque perspectives in the Stanford Prison This document briefly reviews and critiques the ideas of Weber and Goffman in applying them to the Standard Prison Experiment. Weber identified the significance of bureaucracy within organizations. Within the bureaucratic organization there is a stratification of hierarchy where the legal legitimate authority is invested in individuals who exercise command on the basis of rules and…

Words 1778 - Pages 8

Zimbardo Paper

Zimbardo Experiment The value of the Zimbardo study to social psychology The Zimbardo experiment was a milestone study of how individual people can respond to confinement. This experiment was examined and conducted in 1971 by a Stanford University student named Philip Zimbardo. The study also known as the Stanford Prison Experiment which is a classic proof of how the position of power can affect a person's behavior, morals and character. So severe, sudden and unforeseen change of disposition…

Words 503 - Pages 3

a spectrum of good and evil Essay

and that everyone has a small amount of both within them. Throughout history we have seen multiple situations that display both virtuous and vile behaviors once again proving both good and evil is present within this world. Experiments similar to the Stanford prison experiment show disposional and situational aspects of the good, evil none, or both debate. The world is not black and white it is made of many colors. Whether you believe that the world is benevolent or beastly you mustn’t ignore the…

Words 1007 - Pages 5

Philip Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

The Zimbardo prison experiment was a study of human responses to captivity, dehumanization and its effects on the behavior on authority figures and inmates in prison situations. Conducted in 1971 the experiment was led by Phlilip Zimbardo. Volunteer College students played the roles of both guards and prisoners living in a simulated prison setting in the basement of the Stanford psychology building. Philip Zimbardo and his team aimed to demonstrate the situational rather than the dispositional causes…

Words 1631 - Pages 7