a spectrum of good and evil Essay

Submitted By twoboaters
Words: 1007
Pages: 5
Open Document
Lynch 1
Chloe Lynch
Mrs. Lind
English II
October 24 2014
A Spectrum of Good and Evil
Few people believe that mankind is black and white or in this instance brutal or beautiful. However it can be argued that mankind is both. A philosopher named Augustine States “there is no good or evil in the world, if there was Evil would be just necessary as good.” This quote shows us that this great philosopher, along with others, agree to the theory that there is not good without evil and that everyone has a small amount of both within them. Throughout history we have seen multiple situations that display both virtuous and vile behaviors once again proving both good and evil is present within this world. Experiments similar to the Stanford prison experiment show disposional and situational aspects of the good, evil none, or both debate. The world is not black and white it is made of many colors. Whether you believe that the world is benevolent or beastly you mustn’t ignore the fact that there is some good and some evil. Any situation has a measly amount of both in the particular situation There is always some good (the whistler blower) and evil (the person/people responsible for a villainous situation). According to a documentary by Heroic Imagination TV; In 1971 Philip Zimbardo a social psychologist conducted a experiment involving college students. These experiments made ordinary people do things they never could imagine doing. Zimbardo experiment was a physiological
Lynch 2 experiment to show how people respond to a cruel environment without clear rules. Over 70 men volunteered for this experiment and 24 normal men were chosen. After the men were randomly chosen as guards and prisoners. The Witnesses say that the experiment became more like a real life situation, not an experiment. The guards were given glasses and attire and the prisoner were given prison uniforms. On the first day the guards and prisoners were laughing at each other, but one guard would change that. Dave Eshelman started to become more violent and extreme towards prisoners. When the prisoners would protest he would respond by violence. The prisoners rebelled against this and barricaded themselves in their cell. The guards came up with plans involving fire extinguishers. Zimbardo says that he saw human nature transform for good to evil. At this point prisoners began to have emotional breakdowns. Dave says at the time he believed that this people were wimps and/or faking, but regrets what he did. They had prisoner clean out toilet bowls with their bare hands. After the forth day things became sexual. Later that day Zimbardo invited his girlfriend to visit the mock prison. She saw prisoners with bags over their heads as well as being beaten. She states that she couldn’t watch the dehumanizing of these people. She tells Zimbardo what he is doing is terrible and runs off. They argue over the ethics of the experiments and she convinced him to call off the experiments before anymore physiological damage was inflicted on these men. (Stanford prison Experiment; Heroic Imagination TV)
After six days of this experiment Zimbardo realized the evil of this experiment. The whistler blower in this experiment, Christina Maslach, was the good within this experiment, the guards were the evil. The prisoners were innocent bystanders who
Lynch 3 flipped the wrong side of the coin. In this situation you can see that there is clearly good and bad sides to this argument, although each individual displayed an array of characteristics.
In a different experiment known as the Hawaiian/Californian honor system experiment, ordinary people were given the opportunity to pay for their restaurant bills using solely the honor system. In Hawaii ninety eight percent of all participants paid using this system. In the state of California ninety six percent of the participants paid the full
Show More

Related Documents: a spectrum of good and evil Essay

Good Vs Evil Research Paper

A Take on Good and Evil Intro Though used in everyday communication, the topic of the morals of what defines good and evil in its bare form is vague and left to priori, or “common sense”, in determining this. Common sense, though contradicting the general way of its usage, is learned. General View on Good and Evil The line between good and evil is easily seen if it were viewed from a vague point; Good are actions that bring benefit/or benefit individuals or groups; the greater the benefit and more…

Words 1296 - Pages 6

Humans Nature - Good or Bad? Essay

Human Nature Good or Bad? Whether human beings are instinctually good or evil in an elementary natural state is a question that has been boggling the minds of even the greatest philosophers. There is a spectrum of theories that support both good and evil within the human race, each with valid points that explains the range of our interests, being either for ourselves or for others. However, my personal stance is the sensible theory of Altruism. Past experiences and observations allow me to…

Words 1154 - Pages 5

Plato And Augustine

two, whereas on certain subject matter, they differ. The three most important similarities and differences between Plato and Augustine are their views on reality beyond material, their ideals about the problem of evil, and their beliefs on what they say is necessary for our souls to be good and happy. In Plato’s Phaedo, reality versus material comes about when Plato discusses the visible and intelligible worlds. To describe this he uses two things: the simile of the Sun and the divided line. In short…

Words 2090 - Pages 9

Evil Is For Good Men To Do Nothing Analysis

individually and with the rest of civilization. With this, good and evil cannot be simplified into two innate elements of human nature. “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” A quote by Edmund Burke encapsulates the theory and basis of philosophy in the long debated conflict between good and evil. At it’s core, this quote provides the implication that humans can be classified as either strictly good or evil. Despite this, in correlation with this quote, it can…

Words 1680 - Pages 7

Good vs Evil Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Essay

happenings are good or evil can shape one’s mindset and outlook on the actions they take themselves. Both have distinct strengths and weaknesses; however, the real question one must ask is which side of the spectrum is more capable of influencing humanity. In Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde written by Robert Louis Stevenson, a wealthy and well-respected doctor by the name of Henry Jekyll, who believes that man is not one but two separate people, constructs a potion which unearths his inner evil (Mr. Edward…

Words 1835 - Pages 8

Evil, a Force Deserving of Punishment Essay

Evil, a Force Deserving of Punishment What are the best ways to justify a crime? What if that crime were murder? And what sort of punishment would be necessary if that crime wasn’t justified? In the novel Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoyevsky multiple characters do immoral or outright evil deeds, but often attempt to justify their actions. Three of the characters who do evil and seek to justify their actions are Rodion Raskolnikov, Sonia, and Svidrigailov. Raskolnikov is the first “criminal”…

Words 702 - Pages 3

Nature Vs. Nurture In The Scarlet Letter

Humanity has pondered its own inherent morality for centuries. Is man naturally good or evil? How much of either is the result of the nurturing man has received in their formative years. Philosophers such as John Locke tend to believe that the natural state of man is good while others, like Thomas Hobbes, see man as being naturally corrupt. Puritans take a Hobbes-like viewpoint on the state of man and thus believe that man must be purified at whatever cost. This disregard for human dignity creates…

Words 1270 - Pages 6

Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde Duality Analysis

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are set up as diametric opposites on the ‘spectrum of good and evil’ . This is seen before their names are even mentioned in chapter 1 where Mr Hyde is seen as “a really damnable man” compared to Dr Jekyll “who do what they call good”. Both men are the same person and therefore the beginning foreshadows the conflict this distinct contrast will cause in the future. The names themselves could…

Words 991 - Pages 4

Jitterbug Research Paper

Standing in front of the dimly lit fountain, late that night, I held a smooth rock with my own words written on it. I prayed while holding the rock tightly and watched the water from the fountain splash into the bed of rocks at its base. Teens wandered in and around me, as they engaged with multiple prayer stations around the camp for their annual Night of Silence. Tears began to form as I envisioned God reaching a hand out – come dance with Me, I heard. I answered, “yes!” internally, placed my rock…

Words 1674 - Pages 7

Can Tolsents To The Gas Woman

Once these working men begin their assigned task the wretched insanity of their circumstances is revealed. As these regular men corral and lie to the victims of Nazi madness the true depth of the bottomless well of evil to which humanity is capable is shown in vivid imagery. The full spectrum of hatred, sorrow, and the destruction of hope is burned into the eternal…

Words 654 - Pages 3