Evaluation Obedience Essay

Submitted By deputydave

Words: 464

Pages: 2

Open Document

Evaluation points: Explanations of Obedience

Agentic state

Milgram’s participants knew it was wrong but put the responsibility on the experimenter
At the Nuremberg Trials many Nazis said they were just following orders
It explains why some people do not obey – they have stayed in the autonomous state
A weakness is that there is no evidence that this shift takes place and it cannot be measured.
The theory is vague and does not explain fully why or how the shift takes place.
One way in which the shift can be reversed is through empathy – in Milgram’s study a woman who had lived in Nazi Germany was woken from her agentic state by painful memories, and empathising with the learner.
For the agentic shift to take place, the participant also has to trust in the authority of the experimenter. If this were to be removed, it would awaken them from their agentic state, as seen in Gamson’s study.
Gradual Commitment
Maybe Nazi soldiers gradually committed to their actions against the Jews – starting with name calling.
The foot in the door technique can also be used by salesmen – “you have already bought the TV so why not buy the surround sound to go with it?”
Milgram’s experiment, as the main support for this idea, lacked ecological validity – so the findings should be treated with caution when generalising to real life explanations for obedience.
Milgram’s experiment has been criticised for sample bias as it used all male Americans.
Milgram’s experiment, had high realism, as shown in the distress of the participants, who actually believed they were giving electric shocks.
Legitimate authority
Milgram moved his experiment to a seedy office block and obedience dropped.
Respect for authority is different from country to country and so this idea cannot be generalised too widely.
Further supporting evidence for this idea comes from Bickman’s study on the

Jimmy Carcamo-Campos

experiment 7 of Milgram’s Obedience study, the subjects were initially given instructions by the experimenter. After a short period of time, the experimenter eventually left the lab and proceeded to give instructions to the subject via telephone. This was different from the other experiments before, as the experimenter was always just a few feet away from the subject giving instructions. However, in experiment 7, the experimenter wasn’t physically there at all, which tested the obedience due to proximity…

Words 1102 - Pages 5

Stanley Milgram's Experiment

Psychologist Stanley Milgram, examined how justification from doing horrible things was often used by good Germans during the Holocaust, claiming that they were just following orders from their superior. Therefore, Milgram conducted an experiment in 1996, measuring how far individuals would go in harming/killing another person when obeying authority figures, and how easy they could be influenced. So, Milgram advertise a learning lab experimental study were 40 males volunteer and were introduced to…

Words 347 - Pages 2

The Board Of Directors: A Theory-Based Approach

The Board of Directors play a key role in the success or failure of any organization. Although boards differ tremendously, even in how they select their member (i.e. elected, self-perpetuating, appointed, or hybrid), there are two details that remain consistent: the board is “both held responsible and called to account for the organization” (Howe, 2002, p. 30). This essay will discuss the functional responsibilities of the Board of Directors and conclude with a brief description of the three theories…

Words 777 - Pages 4

Board Governance: An Important Part Of A Nonprofit Organization

that advance the nonprofit’s effectiveness and sustainability” (www.councilofnonprofits.org). However, in an effort to exercise the Duty of Care, boards may encounter opposition from the community. In which case, the board should maintain a Duty of Obedience. It is very difficult for a board to maintain both legal duties when they conflict with each other. A nonprofit organization board must recognize the impact their decisions would have on the community. It is also important for the community to recognize…

Words 895 - Pages 4

Heloise And Abelard Love Bodies Analysis

great love story because a great love experience is more important than a marriage ending. The process of loving the person matters more than the result of getting married. The marriage commitment is just one form of loving and being loved. If the evaluation…

Words 509 - Pages 3

Essay on Conformity and Obedience

Conformity and Obedience Task: outline and evaluate findings from conformity and obedience research and consider explanations for conformity (and non-conformity), as well as evaluating Milgram’s studies of obedience (including ethical issues). The following essay will be about understanding what is meant by and distinguishing the differences between the terms conformity and obedience. It will show the evaluation of two key psychological studies which seek to explain why people do and do not conform…

Words 3311 - Pages 14

Social approach psychology unit 1 Essay

and relate to one another in varied situations. Social psychological topics include: prejudice, discrimination, obedience, gender, culture, aggression and more. 1. The effect of interaction between individuals In some situations, we may give up a degree of our free will and do things that we don't necessarily want to do and act obedient. 'Agency Theory' which is a theory of obedience proposes that people are agents within society and behave in such a way as they think will benefit their society…

Words 1718 - Pages 7

Ethics and Moral Dilemmas Essay

Lawrence Kohlberg. He theorized that people progress through three levels as they develop abilities of moral reasoning. I. Preconventional Level II. Conventional Level III. Postconventional Level Rules are set down by others. Stage 1: Punishment and Obedience Orientation. Physical consequences of action determine its goodness or badness. Stage 2: Instrumental Relativist Orientation. What is right is whatever satisfies one’s own needs and occasionally the needs of others. Elements of fairness and reciprocity…

Words 398 - Pages 2

Euthyphro's Response To Socrates

First, Socrates challenges Euthyphro that inherent within divine obedience comes an inherent lack of respect for parents, something of which Douglas Linder, author of The Trial of Socrates, calls “The ultimate command of divine law is unconditional respect for parents.” (Linder, 2002, p. 2) Socrates also maintains that…

Words 849 - Pages 4

Book Review- Share Jesus Without Fear Essay

ponders on the question of what makes a "good" Christian. He contends that a person cannot be a "good Christian" without sharing his or her faith in Jesus? He is literally saying a good Christian cannot be silent because evangelism is an act of obedience driven by faithfulness to God. It is as if he is confronting the reader and saying that if the reader isn't sharing his or her faith then he or she isn't a good Christian. This could be offensive but it indeed drives home the point that the “sin…

Words 1911 - Pages 8