God exist? Essay

Submitted By Romez
Words: 1899
Pages: 8
Open Document
October 27th 2014
Does God exist?
Descartes’ fifth Meditation argument for God's existence relies on an untenable notion that existence is a perfection and that it can be predicated of God. I shall first explain what Descartes’ argument for God's existence is, and then present his argument in propositional form. I will then attempt to support the argument that existence is neither a perfection nor a predicate of God. In our thoughts we apprehend ideas of things. These ideas may reside entirely within our thoughts or they may exist independent of our considerations of them. Descartes argues that the idea of God is that He is infinite substance "eternal, immutable, independent, all-knowing, all-powerful" to which nothing more perfect can be imagined. Descartes defines the more perfect as "that which contains in itself more reality" so that there are gradations of perfection beginning with the subjective phantasms, such as a chimera, and culminating with the most perfect being in God Himself. Thus, because our idea of God is one of absolute perfection, and existence contains more reality than nonexistent thoughts alone, God exists. Descartes’ argument can be represented logically as: (1) in our thoughts we experience an idea of the most perfect being. (2) Existence in reality is more perfect than existence in our thoughts alone. Therefore, (3) the most perfect being exists in reality.
The ontological argument is the only a priori justification for God’s existence: that is, it does not depend upon our experience of the world to be verified, but instead relies upon purely logical inferences from the concept of God. It was adapted by Descartes in Meditation 5 and has been reformulated in recent times. The classical version comes from Anselm who addresses it to the fool in Psalm 14 who says in his heart, there is no God: ... “this very fool, when he hears of this being of which I speak – a being than which nothing greater can be conceived – understands what he hears, and what he understands is in his understanding; although he does not understand it to exist. For, it is one thing for an object to be in the understanding, and another to understand that the object exists... Hence, even the fool is convinced that something exists in the understanding, at least, than which nothing greater can be conceived... And assuredly that, than which nothing greater can be conceived, cannot exist in the understanding alone. For, suppose it exists in the understanding alone: then it can be conceived to exist in reality; which is greater. Therefore, if that, than which nothing greater can be conceived, exists in the understanding alone, the very being, than which nothing greater can be conceived, is one, than which a greater can be conceived. But obviously this is impossible. Hence, there is no doubt that there exists a being, than which nothing greater can be conceived, and it exists both in the understanding and in reality.”
The argument starts from the definition of God as ‘a being than which nothing greater can be conceived’. The fool understands this concept but believes that such a being does not exist. If it did exist, however, it would be greater than the concept alone: an existing being is greater than a mere idea. Therefore the fool is contradicting himself as he can conceive of a being greater than ‘a being than which nothing greater can be conceived’, one that actually exists. Anselm’s argument assumes the premise that God does not exist leads to a contradiction. Therefore, God must exist. Another way of putting this is to say that God necessarily exists. If God is ‘a being than which nothing greater can be conceived’, then he must exist by necessity as such a being is greater than a merely contingent one. Since the concept ‘God’ contains the notion of necessary existence, then the proposition ‘God exists’ must be analytic, in the same way that ‘bachelors are unmarried’ is analytic: the predicate (exists, unmarried) is already
Show More

Related Documents: God exist? Essay

Essay on Does God Exist?

whether or not God exists. This is the very question that has grasped the imagination of humanity since the birth of reason, and the same question that has plagued scientists and philosophers without coming close to an accepted conclusion. God is a word that means different things to different people. The definition for God, according to most monotheistic religions is the creator and ruler…

Words 1981 - Pages 8

God Exists Essay examples

Argument Essay God Exists The existence of God has been debated by mankind all over the world for centuries. Belief, or non-belief, in God has destroyed families, and brought them together. Many people say they have experienced His presence in different ways, such as tragic or traumatic events. For me, God’s presence is the peace that He gives beyond my understanding, which is the absence of fear, anxiety, and worry that controls everyday life and situations. There are many different…

Words 624 - Pages 3

Essay about Does God Exist?

isn't a 'God' at all. There is no authenticated evidence to suggest that 'God' does exist. Whereas, there is more than enough evidence to support Darwin's theory. For example: human embryos, very early on in development, are almost identical to that of a fish. Embryos are clear signs of evolution as there are many similarities between human embryos and fish embryos, these are also almost identical to embryos of birds and reptiles, not just fish. The human eye is imperfect, if there was a 'God', surely…

Words 871 - Pages 4

Does God Exist Research Paper

Many people argue about whether God exists or not. Many people try to use science to prove Christians wrong. But what they haven't done, is use science to see if God is real. In this paper I will prove why God does exist, by showing scientific proof of an Almighty Creator. Many atheists, believe that the world was created with the Big Bang Theory, but with this, everything occurred by chance. But the earth is very perfect, which makes it seem like it was created by God. For example, lets look at some…

Words 1527 - Pages 7

The Ontological And Teleological Arguments For The Existence Of God

The Existence of God The Ontological and Teleological arguments have multiple similarities and differences in the sense that they both are proving the existence of God, and how God is all powerful; but the major differences are the idea of the proving the existence solely through thought and the proven existence through the physical world and intricate order of nature. The Teleological argument goes more in-depth with its argument of the existence of God by providing more physical proof for people…

Words 1008 - Pages 5

Essay on Existance of God Proofs

Proofs Anselm’s Ontological Argument for the Existence of God 1. Even someone who denies God exists must have a concept of what God is. 2. The term God means a being greater than which none greater exists 3. There are 2 ways something can exist: a. Only in the mind. b. Both in the mind and in the reality outside the mind. 4. It is greater to exist both in the mind and in reality than to exist only in the mind. 5. Therefore, God must exist both in the mind and in reality or he would not be the…

Words 476 - Pages 2

Anselm, Guanilo And Thomas Of Aquinas: The Existence Of God

The existence of God has been the subject of debate by philosophers, scientists, and for centuries. Three of these philosophers Anselm, Guanilo and Thomas of Aquinas explore some ideas on the topic of the existence of God. Anselm refers to Psalm 8 that says we need to seek God with our whole heart but he points out the fact we cannot see God so how can we seek God with our whole heart? Subsequently, Guanilo disagrees with Anselm’s comparison of God existence that leads them to go back and fourth…

Words 2113 - Pages 9

B Gods Existence Through Definition Alone Essay examples

with the quote and believes existence is not a predicate. You cannot talk about something and then state that it exists because we could do this with anything He gave the example of unicorns. Humans have an idea of what a unicorn is but this does not mean to say it exists just because we can picture what it could be like. Therefore in this example, we see through definition alone, God cannot be proved to be real because we could demand anything into existence but this does not mean it will happen…

Words 560 - Pages 3

Compare And Contrast Anslem Vs. Anselm

1225-1274 (Palmer 2013). He argued over the existence of God, but he had five philosophical arguments called the cosmological arguments. Anslem and Aquinas have two different philosophies, but some comparisons and contrasts exist between the two arguments. While Anselm’s argument comes from a theory of being, Thomas was concerned with observing the natural world. If beings can conceive an incredible, necessary being then a greater being exists, according to Saint Anselm. If humans do not have an idea…

Words 371 - Pages 2

Anslem's Ontological Argument

through understanding, then that being should be able to exist in reality. His argument is not sound due to the possibility of other things such as perfect islands [1] could also exist if one were to think about the subject being perfect in every way. Some philosophers such as Gaunilo do not refute that god does not exist but that Anslems argument is unsound and that a better argument can be created. Anselm's definition of God starts by saying that God is the greatest being we can possibly think of and…

Words 1137 - Pages 5