Essay about Good and Evil: High Noon

Words: 1258
Pages: 6
Open Document
GOOD AND EVIL

The movie "High Noon" has interesting comparisons to the philosophies and views of Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill. It would be easy to analyze the lead character Kane as mirroring the philosophical views of Kant. This paper will analyze the somewhat contradictory actions of other characters which, to me, represent a quintessential truth about personal beliefs – that they are changed according to situation. I will be commenting on two characters in the movie which show a change in the views of the characters in relation to situational factors. We will be looking at Amy Kane and Mayor Jonas Henderson.
Amy is Kane's new wife. She is a religious woman, a pacifist Quaker, who chose this lifestyle in response to having …show more content…
Jonas felt a duty to protect his friend and an obligation to provide the greatest happiness to Kane and his new wife. Kane says “I think I should stay”. Jonas replies, “Are you crazy? Think of Amy”. Kane reluctantly leaves, but leaves quickly. As Kane rides off with his horses at a gallop, Jonas is shown with a proud look on his face, his duty accomplished.
As I said in the introduction, Kane’s belief system mirrors the philosophical views of Kant. Running was never an option. Not too far down the road, Kane’s sense of duty turns him around and heads him back into town and back into danger. In Kane’s attempt to recruit deputies he is forced to interrupt Sunday church services asking for help. Jonas is in attendance. After much debate, Jonas takes the floor and begins to speak. Jonas’ speech is totally void of any partiality, it is a very rational explanation of what he feels needs to be done. He states that what the town owes Kane, it could never pay back and that Kane is the best Marshall they ever had and maybe will ever have but the town is growing and cannot afford for there to be killing in the streets if they are to enjoy any prosperity. Jonas states that Kane did not have to return and that he wishes he had not. It is possible that with Kane gone, Miller will do nothing. Jonas then asks a second time for Kane to leave town but this time Jonas’ decision was not a mixture but pure Mill’s philosophy of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism asks us to maximize
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Good and Evil: High Noon

Essay on TheLotteryDecember5th

Prof. Robinson English 102-02 5 December 2014 Sticks and Stones Most people believe in superstitions. Some superstitions are positive as in sports when athletes say the same prayer before each game. Other times superstitions are believed to ward off evil, like throwing salt over the shoulder or not walking under a ladder. Oftentimes people follow superstitions so much that they become rituals. This idea is seen in “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson. Ms. Jackson develops her short story using symbols…

Words 2280 - Pages 10

Summary Of Ani Difranco's Poem

symbolism to describe a sinful act of lust between a man and a woman. There are indications of comparisons and contradictions to another poem, “Adam and Eve,” written by Marjorie Pickthall. Even though the two poems have the same title and symbolize good and evil, they are written in two different ways. In other words, both poems display a different point of view, which in turn gives different meaning. The poem written by Pickthall, expresses sin that was committed, but was followed through righteousness…

Words 791 - Pages 4

Shirley Jackson Bibliography

decided to move to Rochester and this is where she felt like an outsider and felt rejected. Some say that because of what happened to her in high school of being rejected by the sorority is what made her write “The Lottery”. Shirley Jackson was one of the most notorious American cryptic writers of the twentieth century. Jackson could weave a story using themes of evil, violence, and victimization and make it all seem somehow normal. It was with these themes that Jackson wrote such shocking tales as The…

Words 1716 - Pages 7

Motivation: Reward System and Casino Essay

competition. The turnover rate is a problem at the staffing level. The full time employees are being over worked to cover shifts and customer service is not being satisfied. Among the housekeeping staff, there has been an above normal rate of absenteeism and high turnover of rooms. Many of the managers who work in accounting, payroll, and other departments have had to ask their full-time employees to help cover for housekeeping by cleaning rooms periodically. Because of this problem, the hotel has had to adjust…

Words 1230 - Pages 5

Adolf Hitler's Resistance To The Warsaw Ghetto

Unarmed Resistance of the Warsaw Ghetto The Holocaust exterminated over six million Jews in a only span of around three years, leaving many historians to ponder why such an act had not been defied sooner. Adolf Hitler was a Germanic dictator with multiple countries under his power up until various countries, such as America, came into the picture. It may seem that none had acted against the Nazis within the Polish, German and other ghettos, but there had actually been a multitude of under acknowledged…

Words 1421 - Pages 6

The lottery STUDY GUIDE Essay

complaint. Many readers cancelled their subscription to the magazine. After the hubbub subsided, critics realized what an outstanding short story it was. Today, the story appears in numerous anthologies for high school and college students. Setting The action takes place between 10 a.m. and noon on June 27, a sunny day, in a New England village. Characters Bobby Martin: Boy who loads his pockets with stones that he will use after townspeople draw lottery numbers. He also helps build a pile of stones…

Words 3132 - Pages 13

Essay on Samuel: God and Saul

relationship. 1 Samuel 11:2 (NKJV) And Nahash the Ammonite answered them, On this condition I will make a covenant with you, that I may put out all your right eyes, and bring reproach on all Israel. Like many abusers the demands are exceedingly high. The cruel condition included gouging out the right eye of every citizen. The purpose of the condition was to disgrace not only the citizens of the city, but to disgrace all Israel as weak and cowardly. The king also knew that blindness in one eye…

Words 3586 - Pages 15

American ELectronic media Essay

Benny and regular cast and guest stars who sang or played instruments on the show -soap operas: named after the sponsors of soap products; The Shadow, Betty and Bob -appealed largely to females and dominated day-time airwaves TV programs in high demand and were desperately needed to fill airtime; Producers convinced to move radio programs onto TV easiest way to full airtime is with music -innovations that helped the transition 1. music recordable on vinyl, live bands not necessary 2. small…

Words 3016 - Pages 13

Introduction Gabriel Garcia Marquez Writing 2 Essay

grandparents, Colonel Nicolás Márquez Iguarán idol-his entire life-and Tranquilina Iguarán Cortés. In 1936, when his grandfather died, he was sent to study in Barranquilla. In 1940, he traveled to Zipaquirá, where he received a scholarship to study high school, which ends in 1946. The following year he enrolled at the Faculty of Political Science at the National University and published in the newspaper "El Espectador" his story, "The first designation ". In 1950, he wrote a column in the newspaper…

Words 4169 - Pages 17

Essay about Absolute Essentials Of Islam Shaykh Faraz Rabbani

Islam according to the Hanafi school, the largest school of Islamic law. And its purpose is to make one's worship valid, sound, and proper And Allah alone in a short amount of time. gives success. Fennz RlsneNr Amman, zoo4 Belief Allah Most High says in the Qur'an: "The Messenger believes in what was sent down to him from his Lord, and the believers all believe in Allah and His angels and His books and His messengers. \7e make no distinction between any of His messengers. They say, '\7e…

Words 9865 - Pages 40