The Patient Protection And Affordable Health Care Act

Submitted By arendja
Words: 1602
Pages: 7
Open Document
The debate over health care reform has raged in America ever since the days of the Progressive Era, when European countries during the same period were adopting some kind of health insurance as a way to gain political allegiance, while the US federal government let the states decide. Insurance was largely left to businesses under the influence of unions and attracting experience workers, along with Medicare and Medicaid . 46.3 million Americans were uninsured according to the 2008 Census Bureau . The Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act is a landmark piece of legislation that was created in the spirit of health care as a right and will support a healthier American public and in the process reduce future health care costs.
In the history of health care reform, both proponents and opponents have cited important documents like the US Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution as reasoning for and against health care being a right for all Americans. Generally, left-wing pundits believe access to at least affordable health care is a human right, siting the Declaration of Independence’s right to “Life,” interpreting it as health care preserving Americans’ lives. In the Preamble to the Constitution, it states that it is the purpose of government to “…promote the general welfare” of the people, and just as education is filed under this, health care should be as well. The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that “…everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of oneself and one's family, including... medical care.” All of these documents have been used as philosophical and moral backing in the health care debate .
Right-wing opponents hold a more strict interpretation of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. They will site the right to “pursue” happiness in the Declaration of Independence as not a right to happiness or free medical services. It is also just the government’s job to promote the general welfare of the American people, not provide it. In the 2012 Republican Party Platform, Republicans believe the Patient Protection Affordable Care Act is an “…attack on our Constitution…”, describing it as never really about healthcare, just another grab of power by the government for one sixth of the economy, and requiring Americans to buy insurance is an assault on individual freedom .
It is under the “threat” of socialism that the conservative half of the American political spectrum has largely stopped any reform of universal health care system in the United States for more than a century, and it is important to understand because this pressure largely shaped the way the Affordable Care Act was organized and implemented. Starting in the late 1800’s, many western European countries were developing some sort of “social insurance” that later evolved into more complex national insurance plans. Starting with Germany in 1883, countries like Britain developed their own plans by 1912. Ironically, the social insurance policies in Germany and Britain were developed by conservative governments as a political counter-action to take power away from socialist parties and labor unions. Meanwhile, in the U.S., the federal government left the social insurance choice to the states that in turn left it up to private industry, and with labor unions and socialist parties fragmented on the issue, the movement never really gained any momentum even under Theodore Roosevelt .
Following the First World War, the U.S. experienced anti-communism rhetoric that associated compulsory health care to the “…growing threat of communism” so the topic was largely dropped through the twenties and early thirties. The Great Depression made the American people hungry for social reform with millions thrown into poverty. One would think that the Great Depression would be the uniting force that would allow universal health care to be passed; however, it was pushed to the
Show More

Related Documents: The Patient Protection And Affordable Health Care Act

Health Care Reform Analysis

American Struggle over Healthcare Reform, Starr poses the notion of whether health insurance should be given or be earned. It is an undeniable fact that healthcare coverage can be considered a necessity. Therefore, as a necessity, it should be provided without penalty to those who are unable to afford it. This change must start from the forerunners of reform, the policy makers. With…

Words 1244 - Pages 5

Health Care Reform Essay

Health Care Utilization Kerlyn Joseph HCS/235 Health Care Delivery January 25, 2010 Anne Packham Health Care Utilization With the current health care reform that has been passed, it is now the law and mandatory for people to get health insurance through their employer, government, or individually. Each person should have health insurance to take care of their health. For many years there have been issues concerning with people all across the US, affecting access to the care they want and…

Words 1239 - Pages 5

Health Care Reform Essay

Examine Impact of Health Care Reform Provided by your Health Care Reform Experts, Corporate Care International, CCI www.ccibenefits.com 2975 Westchester Avenue, Ste. 403 Purchase, NY 10577 sfeuerman@ccibenefits.com 2/13/2013 Corporate Care International, CCI Your Healthcare Reform Experts CPAS EXAMINE IMPACT OF HEALTH CARE REFORM: Criticism of "Obamacare" and promises to repeal the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), a.k.a. the new health care reform law, President Obama's…

Words 522 - Pages 3

Health Care Reform Essay

Health Care Reform Sharee Allen HCS/ 235 March 5, 2013 University of Phoenix Health Care Reform Health care has changed on every level, since the beginning in which, started from most patients being treated in their homes before the 1920s. But then something happened; doctors started to learn more about diseases and how to treat them, and so doctors started to charge more for their serves (“Stay Smart Stay Healthy,” 2013). It is happening today, where medicine is evolving and the cost…

Words 595 - Pages 3

Health care reform Essay

Health Reform Plan Paper Health care reform has been a controversial topic between the government and public alike for many years now. President Harry Truman in the 1940’s was the first to recognize that our country needed some sort of universal health care (McLaughlin 2008). Fast forward to the year 1990 and little has changed since then. The health care act of the 1990’s proposed by Clinton was one that originally gained momentum but eventually didn’t pass. This was because of a major disconnect…

Words 959 - Pages 4

Affordable Health Care Reform

about amongst conservative and liberal people, but Health Care has always been one of the most “touchy” topics to be conversed about. The most recent Health Care Reform, (the Affordable Care Act (ACA) which was set in place by our president Barrack Obama), has been amongst the most controversial in our nation’s history. “On March 23, 2010, the Affordable Care Act (ACA) became federal law. It initiated the most significant changes in the U.S. health care system since Medicare was established in 1965”…

Words 1030 - Pages 5

Health Care Reform Effects

Healthcare Reform Act and its Effect on Women’s Access to Care and Coverage A good healthcare reform should be cost effective in its implementations and affordability because it not only effects on patients, but also on healthcare providers, government spending as well as on biomedical researchers. For the reason of expense, this is especially important to women as they are more likely to go without compulsory health care together with preventive care then men. In the United States, health care reform…

Words 1385 - Pages 6

Health Care Reform Essay

15 Main St Sometown, NY 5 Brian H. Valentine5555 Phone: 555-555-5555 someone@example.com Marketing Communications Manager Nationally award-winning marcom professional with 14 years of experience leading corporate marketing and internal communications for multimillion-dollar companies across diverse industries. Respected leader of creative teams, multimedia divisions and corporate communications departments. Conceptualize and orchestrate marketing campaigns that effectively reinforce…

Words 709 - Pages 3

Health Care Reform Essay

birth complications are significantly more common in women without health insurance, preventing them from being able to receive proper prenatal care. Increasing availability and reducing costs of insurance for pregnant women will greatly reduce birth complications. As of 2010, health care plans are no longer allowed to discriminate. Insurance cannot be denied to women or their children based on pre-existing conditions. In 2014 Health plans based on job status will no longer be able to deny babies…

Words 550 - Pages 3

Health Care Reform Research Paper

Healthcare Reform Lackawanna County and the state of Pennsylvania’s health care system is challenged by ever growing demographic, economic, and political pressures. The growth of the chronically ill and mental health populations, without adequate health care, increases in health care spending. This population is also a majority of low-income residents in Lackawanna County. The more low-income residents, the more likely residents are to be uninsured (Leonard, 2017). Enlightenment to the reader…

Words 958 - Pages 4