Essay on Higher education, Waste or Wonderful?

Submitted By Koadmaster
Words: 1617
Pages: 7
Open Document
Higher education, Waste or Wonderful? Should something be done differently for higher education? This question is rather important, seeing as how it will affect far more people than can be counted. Higher education has flaws in it right now, we would all agree with that. So what should be done to improve college? Two people have stated their own opinions on the topic: Charles Murray and David Leonhardt. These two people, as well as myself, all have opinions on what would be the best way to address this problem, but our opinions differ greatly. College is a works fairly well right now, but it could be improved with a few changes.
Murray has written an article called, “For Most People, College Is a Waste of Time” about his idea of what should be done with the higher education system. Murray declares several things that are wrong with college; notably he makes it seem as though the current system is not only poor, but also immoral. Continuing this, he states that the education that a person would get in college will likely not even be needed once a person has graduated. He does admit, however, that having a college degree will give you much better odds of having a well-paying job. Having noted that college is inefficient, Murray presents his solution: to have some form of a test that potential employees would take to ensure that the individual be competent in the job. He notes that this would solve a lot of problems (Murray).
Fortunately Murray does not just leave his opinion as just an opinion; he goes on to support it. Murray argues that his plan would allow for people to use far less of their lives in a learning environment. This would generally be a good thing, seeing as how many people dislike having to go to college for more schooling after high school. Another thing he notes it that the amount of money that is currently needed to get through college is far more than most people want to pay; his plan would do away with costly tuitions and other costs associated with college (Murray). Since everyone dislikes paying a large sum of money to simply attend college, it is hard to argue that doing away with tuitions would be unpopular for anyone.
Murray goes on by claiming that his plan would help solve another problem with college, specifically that people often have to move into a different form of housing that, in addition to costing more money, is not desirable to live in. I myself rather dislike this, as I have recently moved out of the house of my parents and I am now forced pay rent and other expenses on my own. Murray generally portrays college housing as undesirable, but I, looking back on the last few weeks, think that it has been a great step to truly being an adult. Murray’s plan would eliminate the need for these less than popular practices by allowing people to study for their tests anywhere, rather than forcing them to commute to universities in order to learn (Murray). For non-traditional students, it would have very little down side. However for traditional students, the system would likely cause just as many problems as it would fix, seeing as how many people would then have little reason to leave home.
Continuing this, Murray also makes mention of the fact that his plan would benefit people who would otherwise not go to college, whether for financial reasons or simply because they do not want to. This is hard to argue with; it is clear that people who currently do not and will not have a degree will benefit from a system like the one Murray has proposed, but the people who have already spent years of their lives acquiring a degree will likely feel cheated. In addition to all this, Murray claims that this plan would not be hard to implement from our current state, as all we would have to do is start requiring tests instead of just degrees (Murray). This is, however, not really proven by anything; it could cause massive upheaval to the education system and may cause far more problems than
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Higher education, Waste or Wonderful?

College Conspiracy Documentary Report Essay

idea 2: The United State government is making a college bubble that student can borrow money so easy to pay tuition. However, make the tuition even higher. Main idea 3: Students can not pay the loan which led to bad debt and endanger all holders of U.S. dollars. Main idea 4: College is worthless. It does not provide a higher opportunity or higher quality job.…

Words 884 - Pages 4

Andrew Carnegie - 1 Essay

differences between the rich and the poor. He held strong to his belief that the rich have worked hard on their education and business duties, therefore are in charge of the much less successful and much more incompetent, and will put forth the needed efforts to improve the lower end of society. Through Andrew Carnegie’s interpretation, the rich are highly educated, goal oriented, driven, and waste no time to complete their intended actions. They have many responsibilities such as owning and running…

Words 824 - Pages 4

Is College Worth The Price Final Final Essay

getting the basics of a liberal education. But for most students, the places to provide those basics are elementary and middle school.” (Murray 223). He is saying that one problem of the higher education system is that some of the things these students are paying six figures for are subjects that can easily be taught and understood in middle school and high school. If the education system was reformed than we may be able to cut down on the cost of getting a college education. One of the biggest problems…

Words 1479 - Pages 6

The Summary of and Response to “the Trouble with Talent” by Kathy Seal Essay

The Summary of and Response to “The Trouble with Talent” by Kathy Seal In “The Trouble with Talent”, Kathy Seal, who frequently writes about children and education in magazines, wrote about the way of education in the U.S. which only focused on the value of inborn aptitude could breed children to become artful people and waste many of American children’s potential. At the beginning of this article, Seal told about an experiment of Jim Stigler, who was a UCLA psychologist, which tested the…

Words 935 - Pages 4

Importance Of Arts In The Arts

A child’s education cannot rely on reading and math alone. A wide range of educational opportunities need to be made available to a child to allow them to explore their talents and interests, whether it be through arts programs, athletics programs, or other activities outside of subjects on standardized tests. Not every student wants to be an engineer or scientist and those children should not be denied opportunities in their education. Creativity in the classroom plays a big role in how children…

Words 1293 - Pages 6

Essay about Antibiotics: Bacteria and Antibiotics

Antibiotics Antibiotics are one of the most important medications in the complex world of medicine. Through the years antibiotics have evolved making them the first method used to treat many dangerous bacterial disease. Unfortunately there are some controversial arguments about the use of antibiotics. Moreover, I believe everything in life should be used with moderation, not too much or not to little. In addition this debate with antibiotics arises because many people take for granted or abuse…

Words 922 - Pages 4

College Plans Essay

Starting my senior year in high school I had to consider whether to go right into a four-year university or to a community college. Some argue that one receives a better education by starting in a university; however, others argue that its smarter to start at a community college because you save money while receiving the same education for the first two years. The only news I heard about community college during high school was that if you got a cumulative GPA of 3.5 or better, you could receive two…

Words 1442 - Pages 6

Charlotte Moon Research Paper

Lottie deserted her life of ease to minister to the poverty-stricken people of China. Although she exhibited care and commitment after she found Christ, Lottie formerly rebelled against God and especially mission-work. “If there was a single way to waste a life, Lottie told herself, being a missionary was it.” Lottie’s resistance eventually changed and God used her to begin a catapult of great missionary endeavors in China. Charlotte Diggs Moon, known as Lottie, grew up in a wealthy family of plantation…

Words 1331 - Pages 6

Essay on Effects of Smokeless Tobacco

the privileges given to student athletes to be widely publicized. A popular question has been, “Should student athletes be receiving these benefits?” There are those who oppose the idea of giving student athletes any special treatment, saying that education should be put first in a student’s schedule and extra-curricular activities, like sports, are just that, extra. Another view is that these special privileges help to motivate an athlete to work towards their academic goals. I believe that special…

Words 1613 - Pages 7

Canadian Blood Essay

awareness. It is more cheaper and efficient method. Broad industry: World Charity Canada Charity Healthy Charity Foundation Disease foundation Donation Organ donation Narrow product: Blood donors Core Product: wonderful feeling for helping others Actual Product: the feeling of pain for drawing blood Augmented product: Friendly nurse attendants, thoughtful care, free pizza, free body check Keys Success Factors Reputation High quality Maintain a good relation with…

Words 2862 - Pages 12