Essay about Hopwood, A.

Submitted By cia06ska
Words: 974
Pages: 4
Open Document
Over the past few decades, due to an increase in demand for improvements in accounting thoughts, understanding of organisational forms and development of new accounting practices, there have been a revolution in accounting. Anthony G. Hopwood, a pioneer in this field, has conducted new directions and theories in organisational and social contexts since early 1980s. This critique will firstly outline Hopwood's ideas. Salem's findings will then be discussed and lastly, a conclusion will be drawn in relation to the application of Hopwood's theories in a contemporary society.

Hopwood suggested that analysis on accounting could not be a neutral and straightforward process as other factors such as competitive environment, regulators and social practices all have impacts on the business enterprise (Hopwood 1983). Although Hopwood's argument had been proven as impractical and challenging to apply in 1980s, it has been considered as a fundamental concept in determining the important links between ideologies which provide changes and wider institutional and regulatory developments in accounting. Heeffer, Albrecht (2009) and David Tate (2011) have shared a similar conventional view as Hopwood. It has been suggested that historical perspective and significant improvement of reporting allow entities to take into account how accounting approach and policies would be shaped and impacted by political actions, the evolution of contemporary economies and the internationalisation of accounting practices, causing wider and more complex social processes. In additions, Loft (1986) and Miller & O’Leary (1987) have contributed the same thoughts as Hopwood, concerning the importance of accounting evolvement into interrelationships between the current society and organisations with reference to the accounting history literature. International Accounting Standards Board have also set out several developments in accounting regulations and policies which are considered to be beneficial for improving the quality of decision-making. These changes have appeared to align with Hopwood's argument that an enhancement of decision making quality was urged by the pressure of the needs in developing new and comprehensive systems and practices.

A paper review on Hopwood (1980,1983)'s study, particularly in the area of the role of accounting based on the historical studies and accounting practices to provide information for decision making has been conducted by Salem. In his findings, a number of case studies including Enron in 2001 and Lehman Brothers in 2010 were illustrated in response to Howpood's suggestion on the powers of accounting interrelations between organisations and society (Hopwood &Miller, 1994). Salem also expressed his opinions on Hopwood's conceptual framework, suggesting that changes in accounting process could help to improve business performance as well as fulfilling organisation's social obligations.

In spite of being able to present a few real life examples to support his argument, Salem failed to elaborate further on matters related to decision-making. Many accounting professions' perspectives were cited to illustrate his argument, one of which was Burchell(1980)'s disagreement on the use of historical data as basis in decision making. Salem also confirmed that the fall of Lehman Brothers in 2008 was caused by multiple contingencies such as poor management and misjudgement in making investment decisions as well as underestimating potential risks, which has precisely supported Hopwood's view on the subjectivity and bias in decision making process that is highly influenced by different criteria such as the competitive forces in the industry as well as stakeholders' concern. Nevertheless, his stand point has not been clearly stated. Despite numerous of real-life examples and quotes from other scholars were being demonstrated, Salem's review lacks for supporting evidence provided in the articles. His overall personal judgement and
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Hopwood, A.

Affirmative Action essay

encouraged in the past, from having equal opportunities as the majority. However, affirmative action results in a backlash for the supposed 'majority.' Two cases, Hopwood and Bollinger dealt with discrimination against accepting Caucasian applicants that had higher scores/GPA than those of minorities. While one court was in favor of Bollinger, Hopwood lost his case. Those who agree with affirmative action would believe: '' a racially mixed student body is desirable because it allows them to learn more than…

Words 721 - Pages 3

TCU Diversity Issues

In 2003, the United States Supreme Court reversed the Hopwood decision with their Grutter v. Bollinger decision where the court confirmed the constitutionality of the affirmative action admissions procedures at the University of Michigan Law School and subsequently legalized these policies nationwide (Hopwood v. Texas, 2022). As public universities such as the University of Texas-Austin started to use race as a factor in admissions…

Words 2990 - Pages 12

Microsoft Word 2 Essay

skills such as technical skills and decision-making skills are essential for managers to operate a company. Technical skills are used by all levels of managers to understand how productionoccurs in a company and directemployeeseffectively (Dwyer & Hopwood, 2009, p.8).Furthermore, decision making skills are needed in choosing an appropriate alternative in order to bring the maximum profit to the organization (Horsley et al. 2000, p.7). However, communication skills are the foundation of most skills…

Words 460 - Pages 2

The Crucible Research Paper

educational background includes graduating from the University of Michigan around 1932 and graduating from Abraham Lincoln High School . In 1936 Miller receives the Hopwood Award , which he got for his first play , No villain . He later uses the prize money to help pay for his tuition . In 1937 Miller acquires another Hopwood Award , this time for his play Honors at Dawn. In 1940 he marries his first wife , Marry Grace Slattery . Miller also made his contributions in WW2. In 1941 he is a ship…

Words 869 - Pages 4

Case Review: Wards Cove Parking V. Antonia

jobs that may pose reproductive health hazards, even though the jobs may pose similar threats to men. 1992: Planned Parenthood v. Casey The court upheld the view of a right to abortion, but that states could make it very hard to do so. 1996: Hopwood v. Texas Was the first successful legal challenge to a university's affirmative action policy in student admissions. The court eventually proclaimed that universities did not have the right to admit black or Latino students just because they were…

Words 636 - Pages 3

Essay about Affirmative Action & Admissions Policies

the purpose of remedying past discrimination, and/or that diversity is not a government’s compelling interest. This is an interesting tendency that is common among the lower courts. For example, delivering the opinion of the Fifth Circuit court in Hopwood v. Texas (1996), Jerry E. Smith writes "The University of Texas School of Law may not use race as a factor in deciding which applicants to admit in order to achieve a diverse student body, to combat the perceived effects of a hostile environment…

Words 2094 - Pages 9

Sermon of St Teresa Essay

Kemper Hopwood The Doctor of the Church Saint Teresa of Avila is the saint that I chose to talk about. Her birth date was March 28th and her feast day is October 15th. She was born during the protestant reformation and died years after the council of Trent. Her struggles were that she was a woman during the times of men. She wrote about prayer and discipline. She was wise, courageous, intelligent, persistent, caring, and filled with the Holy Spirit. All these qualities made her the great reformer…

Words 570 - Pages 3

Tasteless Tea Company Essay

ISSUES IN ACCOUNTING EDUCATION Vol. 26, No. 1 2011 pp. 163–179 American Accounting Association DOI: 10.2308/iace.2011.26.1.163 Tasteless Tea Company: A Comprehensive Revenue Transaction Cycle Case Study Ronald F. Premuroso, William S. Hopwood, and Somnath Bhattacharya ABSTRACT: It is challenging for students taking the introductory accounting information systems AIS course to envision how to apply the topics and concepts learned during the course in real-world situations. The motivation for…

Words 8228 - Pages 33

American Domestic Policy Pros And Cons

The United States of America is commonly referred to as the great “melting pot”, meaning our country’s composition is made up of many different types of people and cultures. Immigrants have poured into this great land for centuries now. Originally, the United States sought to assimilate immigrants in hopes of achieving homogeneity. After countless years under the assimilation strategy, American domestic policy evolved. Washington acknowledged the potential advantages of its citizens possessing different…

Words 1846 - Pages 8

Essay on Report the Role of Accounting in Organizations and Society

take into account different stakeholders interest like investors, suppliers, customer, etc, which automatically creates a strong bond between organization and society. There are three important accounting phenomenons’ that were discussed in Anthony Hopwood article. Accounting as a changing phenomenon:…

Words 908 - Pages 4