How Is Scrooge Similar To A Christmas Carol

Words: 504

Pages: 3

Open Document

Although Scrooge from, A Christmas Carol, and George Bailey from, It’s a Wonderful Life, seem like very different characters, they also have some similarities. At the beginning of their stories they have almost nothing in common. Their family life is different, and so is their involvement in their communities. Towards the end of their stories is when they begin to be more the same. Their transformations show that similarity. Starting with their family; they don’t have any similarities. Scrooge is an old man who lives alone. He doesn’t have a wife or kids, just a nephew, Fred, whom he doesn’t have much of a relationship with. Fred is the opposite of Scrooge. This is demonstrated when Fred states, “Uncle Ebenezer! I cannot tell you what a joy it is to see your happy, smiling face.” On the other hand, George Bailey has a wife and four kids. He loved his wife, Mary, since they were in high school. They also live in an old abandoned house that Mary wanted to renovate for their own, which is a complete contrast from Scrooge. …show more content…
Scrooge rarely does anything to help in his community. When charity workers came to his house and asked if he would donate, he turned them down. Everyone in the town hates him, including Mrs. Cratchit. She told her husband that she didn’t want Scrooge to stay for dinner with them. Meanwhile, George spends his whole life helping and contributing to his community. He gives his own money so that people can continue living in the houses he helped provide for them. He positively affects everyone and is selfless in giving to them. It is apparent that it is true when Clarence told him, “Strange, isn't it? Each man's life touches so many other lives. When he isn't around he leaves an awful hole, doesn't he?” Clarence impacted George in a way that changed his life

Greed In A Christmas Carol

In the story A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens it shows this happen to a man named Scrooge. Scrooge was a grumpy old man he was very greedful. The similarities and differences in this story although there are few are the character past, present, and future. In the play of A Christmas Carol Scrooge was a lonely old greedful man he thought christmas was all just a big Bah -Humbug (Dickens 3). Marley was a ghost that came to his house to tell him to stop being so greedful. Scrooge was always mean…

Words 603 - Pages 3

A christmas Carrol Essay

Story of the Christmas Ghosts In the original text by Charles Dickens and the 1984 film adaptation of A Christmas Carol, there are three ghosts. The ghosts are called Ghosts of Christmas Past, Christmas Present, and Christmas Yet to Come. There are many differences between the 1984 film adaptation of A Christmas Carol and the original text by Charles Dickens. There are also many similarities between the original text by Charles Dickens and the 1984 film adaptation of A Christmas Carol. The first…

Words 486 - Pages 2

Comparing Everyman And A Christmas Carol

Comparison of Everyman and A Christmas Carol Everyman and A Christmas Carol are likewise similar in that they are both dramas telling a story of an immoral person, but are different in how the dramas play out. While, Everyman deals with an immoral man trying to gain salvation and redemption from sin. A Christmas Carol deals with an immoral man being told to change his vices and change his morals. Likewise, the two main characters are destined for a reckoning and are summoned by a supernatural figure…

Words 218 - Pages 1

Comparing Scrooge In Red Kayak And A Christmas Carol

Digger and Scrooge are very different characters, but change in a similar way over time. In Red Kayak, Digger changes from being violent and bitter to serious and understanding of the consequences of his actions. He learns to see what other people see in him, and he thinks about how he only wanted revenge, but ended up going too far, and committed second-hand murder. Likewise, in A Christmas Carol Ebenezer Scrooge learns what it feels like to be happy, and he changes from a dark, moody old man to…

Words 477 - Pages 2

Fate In A Christmas Carol

Lastly, there is Charles Dickens and his story, “A Christmas Carol”. Dickens and Seuss had similar views on fate. Within “A Christmas Carol”, the reader can see that Dickens also believes your fate is not predetermined and with enough hope and desire to change, change will happen and your fate can also become different. But with Dickens, the idea of how time influences your fate is more significant. In “The Lorax”, we saw time playing a role in that it wasn’t limited and that as long as there were…

Words 409 - Pages 2

Comparing Scrooge And A Christmas Carol

Although the movie and the play form of A Christmas Carol are similar, there are some major differences as well. Scrooge, for example, is different in the movie then in the play. Here are some examples that show how Scrooge is different between both forms of the story. First, when the Spirit of Christmas Past visits Scrooge in the movie and the play, it is almost as if he is two entirely different characters. In the movie, Scrooge is full of sadness and regret when he visits his past. He is different…

Words 487 - Pages 2

What Does Scrooge Symbolize In A Christmas Carol

When considered through a Christian perspective, the story A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens can be seen as an allegory of Christian redemption. Before Marley’s ghost visited Scrooge, he was a greedy, cruel person. The three spirits in the story show Scrooge that he is a bad person, but can still redeem himself. The first ghost to visit Scrooge was the Ghost of Christmas Past. It is indescribably young and old. The ghost is short like a child, but with the white hair of an old man. The glowing…

Words 490 - Pages 2

LITERATURE REVISION BOOKLET 1 Essay

English Literature Revision Booklet on the Texts Contents Pg 3 – 20 Of Mice and Men (Unit 1 Section A) Pg 21 – 29 A Christmas Carol (Unit 2b Section B) Pg 30 – 40 Blood Brothers (Unit 2b Section A) Pg 41 – Final Revision Tips *IMPORTANT NOTE!* This revision booklet has been designed to help you learn as much about the books you’ve read as possible. You should use it: complete the tasks and do the extensions tasks because that is revision – not just reading a booklet! **IMPORTANTERER NOTE**…

Words 6597 - Pages 27

Alliteration Of Macbeth's Death In 'A Christmas Carol'

which is about ambition, shows how it can be destructive to yourself and those surrounding you if you give up everything to succeed which is similar to Scrooge in the novel, A Christmas Carol. In the passage, the…

Words 485 - Pages 2

Essay on Hamlet: Seven deadly Sins and Middle Ages

He explains distinctively the moral of the story of how some the characters mentioned are a façade to true characters in the real life situations of a character during the Middle Ages by incorporating one of the seven deadly sins to their story. Some of these characters are meant to have the values of what they are for example like the knight has to obey chivalry which it is like a code of conduct among people. But not all of them act like how they are supposed to be comparison to the story and the…

Words 1118 - Pages 5