human organs Essay

Submitted By marshallboy0907
Words: 1490
Pages: 6
Open Document
The market of human organs is one that lives in the shadows. The selling of organs is currently illegal in every developed country; although a black market is prevalent throughout the world. Whether or not the selling of human organs should be legalized is a strongly debated issue. In the book Why Some Things Should Not Be Sold, Debra Satz presents a detailed case on why selling human organs should not be legalized, and how regulations could possibly make a difference. Her case is done in a very scientific and economic manner, addressing familiar topics as equality and motivation. I believe that the selling of human organs expands beyond the moral limits of the market.
In 2003 there were more than 50,000 people on the waiting list to receive a kidney in the United States. That same year had only 12,000 donors. (Satz, 190) On average, for every 100,000 transplant operations needed only 10,000 operations are performed. (Andre) This is not due to a lack of medical expertise or knowledge. In fact, advances in the medical field have greatly increased our capacity to perform such operations. The problem is in the supply.
It is currently illegal to sell human organs in all developed countries of the world. People have the right to donate their organs, but not sell them. This lack of supply and a market has led to a black market that sells and trades organs. This black market lives mostly in third world countries. Specifically in rapidly developing countries like India and Brazil. These two countries have the infrastructure and medical knowledge to perform the operation and a large class of impoverished people who are willing to sell their organs.
Whether or not the selling of human organs should be legalized is a strongly debated issue, along with what sort of regulations or systems should be imposed. Economically, it would make since that legalizing an organ market would increase the supply of organs. Many fear that a legal organ market would have the same outcome as payment for blood in the United States.
Richard Titmuss, in his study The Gift Relationship, found that a blood market based off of donations only was more efficient then a blood market with monetary incentives for donors. In this study he compared the United States to the United Kingdom. The United Kingdom had a system to collect blood, for those in need, that was strictly based on donations. While the United States’ system offered monetary incentives in hopes of getting more donations. Logically, one would assume that the United States would have a larger blood pool then the United Kingdom. People are expected to be more likely to sell their blood then to give it. Titmuss found the opposite to be true. In his study he found that not only did the United Kingdom have a greater supply of blood, but the blood was of a higher quality. In the United States people were much more likely to hide any known medical problems and give blood that they knew was not good to receive payment. In the United States the donors were mostly impoverished, donating for the money. Once he United States put a price tag on blood they lost what the United Kingdom had; a moral obligation to give the gift of life. Titmuss concluded that for blood, a market based off of donations is far superior then one based off of monetary incentives. A donation based market led to greater quantity and quality of blood.
In the book Why Some Things Should Not Be Sold, Debra Satz gives an example that illustrates this same kind of human behavior in parents. A day care was having a problem with parents arriving late to pick up their children, so they imposed a late fine on the parents. The day care assumed that the fine would give the parents extra incentive to arrive on time. Surprisingly the parent’s lateness doubled in length and continued even after the day care removed the fine three months later. One explanation of this bizarre behavior is in the parent’s moral obligation. Once the day care put a
Show More

Related Documents: human organs Essay

Joanna Mackay: Banning Human Organ Sales

Joanna MacKay was arguing that organs sales should not be banned and continue to be sold. She talks about the government wanting to ban human organ sales, but instead of banning it they should regulate it. Joanna does this by using lot of evidence to back up her argument. She uses a lot of evidence to explain why her stance is better than the other argument. She does this by giving background information, then the counterargument and lastly the reasoning. She states in her essay “About 350,00 Americans…

Words 297 - Pages 2

Essay about Lecture: Organ Transplant and People

ENG 112 28 Feb 2013 The Sale of Human Organs With today's technology in medical science, there is no doubt that organ transplants can save countless human lives. However, the major contemporary problem that the world is facing is that there are not enough organs available for the people who are in need. Many people die every day demanding an organ for their bodies because the National Organization of Transplantation Act has prohibited the sale of human organs since 1984. Millions of people…

Words 1258 - Pages 6

Transplant Waiting List Research Paper

said to be very useful while waiting for kidney organs. Dialysis patients have to go through too much while waiting for a transplant. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center acknowledges that most people believe that are living off of the dialysis treatment is possible because it is lifesaving, but it is not entirely true. Dialysis treatment can impact the body and cause health complications. These health complications can begin to impact other organs. It will then be leaving patients with more time…

Words 993 - Pages 4

Essay about Xenotransplantation Intro

Transplantation of human cells, tissues and organs have been used since the 1960’s from deceased and live donors to successfully treat disease within the human race. However, this has resulted in a demand for these desired organs that far exceed the supply. This need is only likely to increase with the never ending growth in population and the lifespans of humans increasing. The introduction of Xenotransplantation has provided another option to reduce the shortfall in organ donation. Xenotransplantation…

Words 299 - Pages 2

Commercialization Of Organ Transplant Research Paper

COMMERCIALIZATION OF ORGAN TRANSPLANTS Student: Patrick Frost Instructor: Professor Edwin Martinez del Rio Business Ethics 309 October 21, 2013 Strayer University COMMERCIALIZATION OF ORGAN TRANSPLANTS Arguments in favor of organ commercialization Commercialization of human organs from consenting adults will lead to an increase in the supply of organs needed for transplants (Kanniyakonil, 2005). The major challenge in hospitals is the lack of organs needed for transplantation to the increasing…

Words 934 - Pages 4

Artificial Replacement Research Paper

Artificial replacement of organ has existed for a long time. This process is very helpful for people but costs a lot of money. By this surgery sick people whose organs do not function in a proper way are able to replace organs, in order to live a healthy and longer life. There are different kinds of artificial replacements of organs and tissues such as: eye replacement, liver, lung, heart and ear. Another problem which some people struggle is the problem with the spine which can be replaced and fixed…

Words 1250 - Pages 5

Nkf Noooooo Essay

legalize payments for human organs for use in transplantation and urges the federal government to retain the prohibition against the purchase of organs that is codified in Title III of the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984. Offering direct or indirect economic benefits in exchange for organ donation is inconsistent with our values as a society. Any attempt to assign a monetary value to the human body, or body parts, either arbitrarily, or through market forces, diminishes human dignity. By treating…

Words 443 - Pages 2

Argumentative Essay: Everyone Should Be An Organ Donor

to dying and the only way to save them is to get a new organ. Family members who are on dialysis go to have it done 2-3 times a week. Each session lasts four to five hours each. The sessions weaken patients to a degree where 71% discontinue work after starting. Organ donation is the process of removing tissue and organs from a human body and transplanting them into another human, in a sterile environment, in need of them. Normally, these organs come from someone who is brain dead and their loved ones…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Essay on Xenotransplantation: Organ Transplant and Promises Surrounding Xenotransplantation

Clinical organ transplantation is a life-saving procedure for patients with terminal organ failure and requires deceased or living donors. The increasing number of patients with various organ failures and the world shortage of donated human transplantable organs have created a gap between organ supply and demand. This imbalance has resulted in increasing waiting times and death of patients on waiting lists. Xenotransplantation carries the 'hope' of alleviating the shortage of deceased human donated…

Words 1922 - Pages 8

Human Body Vs Pig Research Paper

The human body is complex in its structure and function. It is composed of cells and organized into tissues, organs and organ systems. To know better the body structure and its function we need anatomy and physiology. Anatomy is the study of body structure and physiology is the study of the function of the body’s organs. To learn more about the structure and organs of the body and be able to see it, we dissected a pig. There’s a number of similarities between the human body and pigs when we…

Words 760 - Pages 4