human rights violations Essay

Submitted By CeCe1314
Words: 1094
Pages: 5
Open Document
How do we address rebuilding societies after human rights violations, while also holding perpetrators accountable?

Transitional justice holds perpetrators of human rights violations responsible and attempts to give closure to the victims. The main concern is to rebuild societies after mass atrocity crimes. The three paradigms that explain the distinct ways of approaching transitional justice are retributive, restorative and reparative justice. These three paradigms work together to achieve the same goal, rebuilding fallen societies. In the field of transitional justice there is much debate of how these paradigms can, if at all work together. I believe that the only way that transitional justice can be reached is through retributive and reparative justice.
Retributive justice involves trials and punishments towards the people responsible. The rationale behind this paradigm is 1) wrong doings need to be acknowledged so that they will not be repeated in the future, 2) the perpetrator should be held accountable and punished, 3) the effect of deterring society, and 4) emphasizing the power of the justice system. The benefit of trials correctly shows how to solve conflicts and maintain order within a community. It also acknowledges the difference between individual guilt and collective group guilt. Essentially singling out solely the people responsible and keeping others innocent.
For restorative justice the main goal is to bring the victims and the guilty party back together into the community. In contrast to retributive form of justice where the focus is on the perpetrator, restorative empowers the victims and seeks to provide some sort of dignity back to them. The mechanism behind restorative justice is truth commissions which are executed and run by the national government or the international community. What victims want to hear is the truth and to hear the criminals admit to their crimes.
Reparative justice works to fix and repair the damage done. One approach to mending a broken state is through an official apology. Issuing an apology is beneficial in the sense that the perpetrator takes responsibility for the victim’s suffering and the pain caused. Pain can be physical, emotional and mental. Another benefit is that an apology can alleviate the bitterness towards the criminals. Vindication can also be achieved along with diminishing any related trauma the victims may have. The second approach is through compensation in hopes to get forgiveness for wrongs.
Although these forms of justice may seem to be the answer, they are also flawed. As stated before, the advantage of retributive justice is finding who is at fault then punishing them. However one problem this paradigm has is that these trials can take a long time to get through because the perpetrators are usually a large group. Justice will not be reached in a timely manner, which can also anger the victims more. These trials are also costly and expensive to run. The national government may not always have the funds to provide trials. Monetary funds are the same problem the international community faces as well. The advantage of restorative justice is that it verifies the actual events and the truth behind the crimes. The disadvantage of this method is that people can claim to be telling the truth but in reality are just lying to put someone responsible even if that person is not guilty of anything. The advantage of reparative justice is that it seeks to find peace and a chance for victims to accept and acknowledge the wrongs committed by perpetrators. One major flaw to this form of justice is that victim’s may feel that there is no amount of compensation even in terms of money that can account for the loss of a family member or make them forget what has happened.
All three paradigms of transitional justice support the responsibility to protect, emphasizing that these crimes can never be repeated again in the future. Only
Show More

Related Documents: human rights violations Essay

Human Rights Violations Of Tibet

A Research Paper on the Humans Rights Violations of Tibet The world isn’t perfect. Sometimes it can feel like paradise, and sometimes it can feel like hell. Sometimes people are rich and have all they could ever dream, and sometimes people suffer day and night just to get some food. Sometimes people get what they deserve, and sometimes people don’t get the justice they should. Sometimes people can speak freely and voice their opinion, and sometimes people have to keep quiet and don’t have a voice…

Words 1898 - Pages 8

Human Rights Violations In To Kill A Mockingbird

Boone, a remedial English teacher in Arizona, who was convicted of sodomizing an 11-year old Hopi boy in 1987 and who had nude pictures of 142 Native American boys as keepsakes of his actions (Walker, 1989). It is needless to note that the human rights violations of the children forced to attend these boarding schools are appalling and countless.…

Words 373 - Pages 2

Violation Of Human Rights In Elie Wiesel's Night

Violation of Human Rights During the Holocaust in Germany, many human rights were violated, which can be read in the memoir Night. The memoir Night was about Eliezer, a twelve year old boy trying to survive the Holocaust with his father. The UDHR (Universal Declaration of Human Rights) is all the human rights and some of them are being violated in the Holocaust. Every human has the right to be free from slavery, away from torture and degrading treatment, and free from arbitrary arrest and exile…

Words 522 - Pages 3

Human Rights Violation In Letter From Birmingham Jail

Have your human rights ever been violated at school or your workplace? Human rights are rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, religion, language, or any other status. We are all equally entitled to our human rights without discrimination. These rights are all interrelated, interdependent and indivisible. This paper will expose how the writers develop their position on various human rights violations. The texts being used to develop my response are “Letter…

Words 998 - Pages 4

Examples Of Human Rights Violations In Night By Elie Wiesel

In the novel, Night, by Elie Wiesel, human rights of the jews were violated. They were starved, beaten to death, and even hung for being a jew. They were sent to forced labor camps throughout Germany to be eliminated and work for Hitler. Hitler wanted to purify Germany and make a master race. As a result Jewish human rights were violated. During the Holocaust the human rights of Jews were violated. They were forced to go to work camps that were controlled by the Nazi’s. For example, “I have terrible…

Words 394 - Pages 2

The Universal Declaration Of Human Rights

Universal Declaration of Human Rights, almost every aspect of human life is addressed. They range from torture to slavery and beyond to what exactly freedom is. All around the world, these same rights apply to every human being on earth. In rural countries, and even in wealthy and thriving countries, human rights are violated everyday. The law takes over and these simple rights thats are promised and given to us from the moment we are born are taken away just like that. The human rights were put in place to protect us…

Words 626 - Pages 3

Sheryl He ATS1314 Essay

Critically analyse the feminist explanation for why violence against women has often not been considered a human rights issue. In doing so, you should recount and critique the explanation offered, and comment on the practical implications of accepting/rejecting it. Violence against women is seldom, if ever, considered a human rights violation, yet it has a significant impact on women across the world. The feminist approach explains this datum because such abuses occur in the private realm, therefore…

Words 1753 - Pages 8

Essay On Boko Haram

INTRODUCTION WHAT ARE HUMAN RIGHTS? There are various definitions and opinions about what human rights are or ought to be. Human rights can simply be defined as the “rights that every individual have simply because he or she is a human being”. Human rights are natural and may even be described as God given rights which every human being is entitled to. Human rights are also universal and entitled to everybody and cannot be taken away by anybody. However, there are situations where a person, who…

Words 1130 - Pages 5

Essay On The Violation Of The American Revolution

Who would ever want to have their unalienable rights to be taken away? Unable to choose or protest? Well, that’s what happened to the citizens in the thirteen colonies. The violation of rights was how England snatched away the untouchable rights of colonists. The colonists couldn’t say anything, as their rights, like free speech or choice, were stripped from them by England. The American Revolution was caused by the violation of rights, because of the Townshend Act, the Declaratory Act, and the Declaration…

Words 567 - Pages 3

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Powerful Speech By Hillary Rodham Clinton

Imagine being a woman in the 19th century, feeling useless, unpaid, under-appreciated, and isolated from the world of possibilities. Throughout the 20th century, our opinion on women changed drastically. From not being able to vote and barely treated as human beings, women today are thriving. Though this is true, there is still much more to be done for them to be considered “equal” to men which is why women got together at the United Nation’s fourth world conference on women in 1995. UN’s fourth world conference…

Words 859 - Pages 4