Humanitarian Intervention

Words: 457

Pages: 2

Open Document

1) How is the contemporary landscape of humanitarian actors different from previous eras? What has driven these changes?

The contemporary landscape of humanitarian actors has changed since previous eras. Weiss explains that there are three transformative trends: militarization, politicization, and marketization. These trends are driven by a higher demand for humanitarian relief by a booming population. The new era of humanitarianism is struggling to keep pace with the increasingly complex crisis’s that occur. These disasters are affecting more people and requiring aid for a longer period of time. Modern humanitarianism however, is not always about helping the victims. In many cases, it is about agenda pushing, making a profit, and bias towards …show more content…
• The International Committee of the Red Cross
• Oldest international humanitarian organization
• Works only in war zones
• Challenges: run by Swedish elites, so they can be biased to their own agendas.
• The UN system
• Key to worlds response to disasters
• Has a bunch of organizations in their system
• Challenges: plays a pivotal role in civil wars and suffers from bias.
• Bilateral aid agencies:
• Challenges: donors are not shy to push their own agenda and exercise their control over these orgs
• Outside Military Forces:
• soldiers remain part of their country so their loyalties are always with their nation and not with the affected group.
• Challenges: obvious bias and difficult to remain neutral
• Provide services others cannot in war zones
• For profit firms:
• “guns for hire”, mercenaries
• challenges: care for profit and not victims, can be illegal
• The media:
• Type of for-profit business
• Challenges: seeks drama to make a good lead story and does not showcase the good humanitarians do
• Local actors:
• Smaller and less financially

Humanitarian Intervention Essay

African countries. This can be witnessed in the military intervention by western countries which is to some authors is done for humanitarian purposes or to expand neo-colonialism. “Neo-colonialism entails the domination in social, economic and culture of countries from the developed world that is the western countries in the respective internal affairs of the countries of the developing world that is African countries” (jean Paul: 2001). Intervention is a term which covers a wide variety of situations…

Words 2145 - Pages 9

Humanitarian Intervention Essay

Tom Hepp Humanitarian Intervention Unless there is a genocide accruing in a nation it’s not our responsibility. Many countries go through hard times that challenge the nation’s ability to govern and protect its people and may require aid to give them stability, but to have intervention just takes away that states sovereignty and is not the responsibility of the international community. The United States has gotten involved in many countries in both aid and intervention but when it comes…

Words 745 - Pages 3

Christopher Hitchens: Humanitarian Intervention

argues that humanitarian intervention is a vital piece of American democracy. Hitchens argues that borders are becoming ever open and contingent that everyone is getting involved in humanitarian aid. War is vital for human rights reforms and aid discussions. The 1994 Rwandan genocide is an example of our mistakes in foreign policy and how we should have intervened more with humanitarian aid or even with the military (Hitchens, Christopher. "Just causes: the case for humanitarian intervention".) Those…

Words 480 - Pages 2

Arguments Against Humanitarian Intervention

up the United States’ intervention in other countries such as Rwanda and Somalia, and more recently Iraq and Syria. These talks are by no means unwarranted and are crucial to the creation of new foreign policy in the US. There are many debates about whether intervention on the basis of humanitarian purposes is justified and whether the US should pursue this strategy. Humanitarian Intervention is justified and has proven to be effective. Many critics of humanitarian intervention point out the failures…

Words 1576 - Pages 7

Human Rights And Humanitarian Intervention

Human Rights and Humanitarian Intervention: An international regime = set of principles, norms, rules and decision-making procedures that states and other international actors accept as authoritative in an issue- area. The Charter of the United Nations, signed in San Francisco on 26 June 1945, promoted respect for human rights as one of the principal objectives. It also created a commission on Human Rights. The commission was drafting the ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’ – list of…

Words 614 - Pages 3

Humanitarian Intervention in Syria Essay

MEMORANDUM With the growing carnage inflicted on the civilian population by Assad’s government, Syria’s twenty-one-month old political and humanitarian crisis does not seem to show any sign of progress. Hundreds of people, including women and children, are slaughtered every week in what the international community describes as a «massacre» of the syrian population. The establishment of human rights as a key component of international politics has allowed external actors to scrutinize and judge…

Words 1151 - Pages 5

Military Intervention: Financial Analysis

military intervention regarding humanitarianism is a matter of political will and ability of political actors to prevent and end abuses of human rights, as well as the potentially destabilizing consequences of the local violence caused by political crises. It is therefore clear that in deciding where, when, and how to intervene, political actors must maintain a financial analysis of the reasons for and against intervention, which will reflect a combination of security, strategic and humanitarian objectives…

Words 211 - Pages 1

Humanitarian Imperialism Essay

force in the humanitarian intervention. The puzzlement that this measure unavoidably carries with itself is the ostensible contradiction between the concept “humanitarian” and armed intervention. The Red Cross movement indeed, as many other organizations, finds abhorrent the association of humanitarian with any form of military action. Another critical point, as previously argued, regards the combination between intervention and the idea of colonialism, also defined as “humanitarian Imperialism”…

Words 480 - Pages 2

Aff humanitarian aid '14 Essay

Aff I affirm the resolution placing political conditions on humanitarian aid to foreign countries is unjust. I offer the following definitions for clarification Humanitarian Coalition (2012) Humanitarian Aid: Humanitarian aid is designed to save lives, alleviate suffering and maintain and protect human dignity during and in the aftermath of emergencies Cesi Cruz and Christina Schneider. (2012) “The (Unintended) Electoral Effects of Foreign Aid Projects.” Conditional Aid: refers to aid that…

Words 1757 - Pages 8

Arguments Against Just War

Subsequently, if Australia is to intervene for humanitarian purposes, in support of US, then they are not justified, as they must be requested by the Syrian government to intervene. The second consideration is of proportionality, and how the benefits do not currently outweigh the costs in participating…

Words 1371 - Pages 6