Is It Possible To Build Better Bureaucracies

Words: 3211
Pages: 13
Open Document
Is it possible to build better bureaucracies?
Introduction
The conception of bureaucracy is one of the most dominant notions in both organization theory and social science. It plays a significant role in modern society. (Clawson, 1980) Ever since the basic characteristics of bureaucracy were formulated by Max Weber, it has been suffered from derogatory remarks and harsh criticism and from various perspectives. For example, feminists such as Kathy Fergusson (1984), liberals such as Mills (1951), Marxist writers such as Dan Clawson (1980), management researcher such as Michel Crozier (1964), Austrian economists such as Ludwig von Mises (1944), they all expressed critiques on bureaucracy. (Styhre and Börjesson, 2006) Various studies are …show more content…
That is to say, lack of innovation and motivation is not inherent in bureaucracy; it is the poor implementation methods that create the problem.
In the same vein, Styhre and Börjesson (2006) conducted a study interviewing 28 managers worked in an automotive company Volvo and a pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca. The two companies have the same organizational structure and Max Weber’s bureaucratic characteristics are significantly in the organization. However, both organizations are successfully in providing innovative products. After the interviews with 28 managers in the two organizations, Styhre and Börjesson (2006) find no relations between the innovation and the functional, hierarchical characteristics in the organization. In contrary, managers agreed that the obstacles of innovative capacities are the various poor managerial practices, which forcing extra workload and complicating operations. Therefore, the problem of bureaucracy is unlikely to be inherent. As long as the right method to develop innovation and motivation in bureaucratic organizations are found, it might be possible to building better bureaucracy.
Find possibilities for building better bureaucracies
Actually, many analysts and theorists have proposed the evidence that it is feasible to create innovation and increase motivation in bureaucratic organizations. Especially for innovation, it could be developed in bureaucratic organization where rules, procedures, functional specialization also existed.
Show More

Related Documents: Is It Possible To Build Better Bureaucracies

Essay on Assignment 2 Gore

and founded W.L. Gore & Associates, Inc. in the basement of his home, he had a theory that he could build an organization that was free from bureaucracy much like the small task forces he was assigned to within Dupont. However, his dream to create an innovative enterprise had several questions: Could he build a company with no hierarchy where everyone was free to talk with everyone else? Could he build a company with no bosses or titles? Could the company be successful by letting people choose what…

Words 1994 - Pages 8

Essay on Satire in Catch-22 by Joseph Heller

Catch-22, by Joseph Heller, is a fictitious novel that depicts life on an American bomber squadron on Pianosa, an island off the coast of Italy, during the closing years of World War II. A bombardier by the name of Yossarian, the main character in the story, is joined by many others to create a comic drama unlike any other. But aside from the entertainment, Heller uses Catch-22 to satirize many aspects of everyday life that consist of hypocrisy, corruption, and insanity. From the laziness of policeman…

Words 2043 - Pages 9

Kelly 1998 Essays

An Inclusive Democratic Polity, Representative Bureaucracies, and the New Public Management Author(s): Rita Mae Kelly Source: Public Administration Review, Vol. 58, No. 3 (May - Jun., 1998), pp. 201-208 Published by: Wiley on behalf of the American Society for Public Administration Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/976560 . Accessed: 14/10/2014 18:01 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms…

Words 4572 - Pages 19

Kay-Sunderland: Making the Grade at Attain Learning Essay

colleague she has worked with for two years and really values. 5. What should Sunderland do? Please be specific about the approach and tactics she should use. A. The kind of working relationship that Kay and Mike share suggests that Kay would be better off using direct one to one tactics in approaching the problem at hand. Despite differences of opinions, they are known for having long conversations and working together well, which is suggestive of the fact that persuasion, assertion, bridging…

Words 864 - Pages 4

Habitat For Humanity Case Study

thousands of lives across the globe. Whether through building affordable housing for the poor, providing financial education, or redistributing resources provided by government agencies and businesses, this organization doesn’t just build affordable housing; they build communities by truly preparing families for home ownership. While it was founded as a Christian organization, H4H provides their services to families in need regardless of religion, race, ethnicity, gender identification, or sexual…

Words 1084 - Pages 5

Managing Change in Organisations Essay

Edexcel Level 7 ASSESSMENT ACTIVITY : UNIT No: 2 UNIT NAME: Managing Change in Organisations ASSESSMENT NO: 1 OF 1 FOR THIS UNIT Full Name: RAHUL DESHMUKH 4 Intake: October’ 2008 Date issued: ____________ Date due: February 13, 2009 Date submitted: June 01, 2009 Assessor(s):_______________________________________ Learning Outcomes: 1, 2, 3 Unit outcomes Outcome Evidence for the criteria Feedback Assessor’s decision Internal Verification 1 Explore the background…

Words 4895 - Pages 20

Essay on Modern management benefits of history

experiences, failures and successes. Newton is quoted in a letter from 1676 saying; “If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants”. With these words he laid the foundation of leadership for future leaders, meaning that we have to build on previous discoveries and learn from past experiences. The modern organisations of today are complex and dynamic institutions. Managerial expertise and leadership are key factors in controlling and leading the organisation to accomplish its particular…

Words 2897 - Pages 12

Conressional Influence Essay

higher education finance (Lowry, 2001; McLendon, Hearn, and Mokher, 2009; McLendon, Mokher, and Doyle, 2009; Okunade, 2004; Richardson and Martinez, 2009; Tandberg, 2006, 2010; Wong and Shen, 2002). We build on this growing body of research by employing a framework of political control and influence to better understand how federal agencies make…

Words 8439 - Pages 34

Case : Yogyakarta Bus Terminal: The Private Provision of Municipal Infrastructure Essay

Case : Yogyakarta Bus Terminal: The Private Provision of Municipal Infrastructure Questions: 1. Is the bus terminal project a success or failure? Cite the “success” or “failure” specifically from the case story In the short run the project is success but in the long run it is failure. The reason is as below:- 1. Short run success evaluated based on stakeholders benefit and motive analysis:- Benefit & Motivation (Stakeholders) Indicator: Success/Good Performance Political Context 1.Get…

Words 1915 - Pages 8

Juvenile Court Case Study

that of any other corporate business, it has undergone different periods of leadership, social change, and cultural influences. Everything put aside, there are three eras that mark the juvenile justice system. First, funding. The system needed to build a solid foundation before it could start accommodating the youth that needed its help. Secondly, due process. This is exclusively shown in the 1967 In Re Gault U.S. Supreme Court case, affording juveniles the same legal rights as adults in criminal…

Words 1491 - Pages 6