John Stuart Mill Ethical Analysis

Words: 1031
Pages: 5
Open Document
John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant views can be applied to see if prison labor is generally good or wheatear it is bad and should be prohibited. Both Mill and Kant views can be applied to justify both ends of the spectrum. Mill’s argument revolves around Utilitarianism; that action is right if they are useful or beneficial for the majority. While Kant’s argument revolved around the preservation of one’s autonomy. The prison labor industry is an 8.9 billion dollar industry. This industry benefits America because it pumps more money into our economy, instead of cheap labor being done over sea and that money is going into another nation’s economy. By applying Mill’s greater happiness principle to justify this action because overall all of …show more content…
Mill would be in favor of this view because prison labor is beneficial overall to our society because it brings a decline in criminals and crime. A counter argument to this view can be that prison labor is the equivalence of involuntary servitude. Prisoners are exploited as slave for cheap labor in America. The amount they are being paid is similar to what people who are exploited around the world for cheap labor are paid; for example, in the Congo people are exploited by Nestle and GAP exploit labor in Thailand. Both companies face scrutiny for the wages they pay to workers, prison labor industry should be held to the same level of scrutiny since they are doing the same thing. Prison labor exploit prisoners meaning the industry is using prisoners as a mere means, which Kant emphasizes that we should never …show more content…
While both men hold separate views, Mill believing in Utilitarianism and Kant believing in autonomy their views can overlap to represent both sides of the argument. My personal view is that prison labor should exist in America. However, it should be heavily regulated. The labor the prisoners do should not be too severe or backbreaking. I believe the wages being paid are ridiculously low, with a wage of 20 cents an hour a prisoner would not have money left over after paying court obligation, child support for spending or release saving. The producers gain close to a 100% profit minus the cost of material since the labor is so cheap. I don’t believe tax dollars should not be going to pay the prisoners. Instead, I believe the company employing them should be giving them at least half of the minimum wage in the state they are located. In addition, no one should be forced to work, which is implemented in some states. A person should be allowed to choose if they want to work for this wage or not so their autonomy does not get breeched and they are not used as a mere
Show More

Related Documents: John Stuart Mill Ethical Analysis

Bhagwati Discussion Questions Essay

state Bhagwati’s main claim (this is his response to the Templeton question about the free market and moral character). Is this a claim of fact, policy, or value? Why? Globalization...leads not only to the creation and spread of wealth but to ethical outcomes and to better moral character among its participants. This claim is a value because it’s an opinion stated about the outcome of moral character which cant be measured. What assumptions or common beliefs/values/attitudes, etc., must the…

Words 564 - Pages 3

Ethical dilemmas Essay

Ethical Dilemmas in Business Case 2: Kathryn McNeil (A) Charles Foley’s Ethical Dilemma At stake here are several conflicting values, the concern for a fellow human being, self-preservation, success of the company and the pressure to perform. As VP of the division, I am under scrutiny to deliver substantial results to my president, John Edmonds, to be seen as sensitive to my product managers needs. Lisa Walters, Kathryn’s supervisor, has pressed me for a resource action for boosting staff morale…

Words 1390 - Pages 6

Essay on A Debate Over Utilitarianism

– provide publicly acceptable norm for determining what kind of laws England should enact. Example Theft analysis John Stuart Mill (1806 – 1873)  “ The Utilitarian doctrine is that happiness is desirable, and the only thing desirable, as an end; all other things being desirable as means to that end” 2 A Debate Over Utilitarianism WHAT IS UTILITARIANISM?   Text definition– An ethical approach that emphasizes the consequences of an action and seeks the action or decision where the benefits…

Words 481 - Pages 2

Essay on Ethics and Greatest Number

EAI (R) RESULTS Ethics Awareness Inventory - Gain New Insight Into Your Ethical Perspective Your Ethical Perspective You tend to base your ethical perspective on the results or consequences of your actions. You believe that conduct should be directed toward promoting the greatest good for the greatest number of persons. In judging whether an individual’s actions are ethical, you look for concrete evidence. It is not enough for an individual to “talk the talk.” Results are needed to indicate that…

Words 825 - Pages 4

Triple Bottom Line Report Essay

Triple Bottom Line Report: Walt Disney Corporation Business ethics is a relatively new field of study in philosophy. It examines the ethical principles and moral or ethical problems that arise within a business environment. Business ethics was born through scandal and seems to regenerate itself with each succeeding wave of scandal. For most of the 20th century, the only concern for major corporations was maximizing profit. Interests in business ethics noticeably accelerated during the 1980s and…

Words 2560 - Pages 11

Philosophy 241 Lecture Note Essay

of last time: Outline of the subject matter of this course: 4 units, each reflecting a different approach to normative philosophical ethics: 1. Teleological/Consequentialist Ethics: Utilitarianism and egoism. Readings by Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill, Bishop Joseph Butler; critique by Dostoevsky; some relevant contemporary feminist reflections by Marilyn Frye. 2. Deontological ethics: Immanuel Kant: Sections 1 and 2 of the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals; Kant's notorious essay…

Words 7807 - Pages 32

Essay on John Stuart Mill and Criminal Justice

of Justice Analysis Luca D. Iaria University of Phoenix CJA 532/ Ethics in Justice and Security Professor: Cyril Vierra February 2, 2015 The United States has held out against taking part in any of the world consensus that there should be a court of human rights or that there should be an international court of criminal justice. - Roger Waters Theory of Justice Analysis Three…

Words 1189 - Pages 5

Engineering Fetuses and the Ethical Conflicts Essay

Engineering Fetuses and the Ethical Conflicts In 2007, a group of biological engineers did an experiment to test a heart valve with gene therapy and other genetic engineering tactics. The report discusses their findings, and their analysis on all of their experiments. Through their data and analysis, they were lead to believe and were successful in locating the gene and locus for the heart valve. After they located this special locus, they began developing experiments and attempting to strengthen…

Words 1978 - Pages 8

Philosophy: Virtue Ethics and Natural Sciences Essay example

irretrievably (MacIntyre 1).” This is not an imaginary world; this is reality, to MacIntyre, only it is the language of morality that is lost in this “state of grave disorder” instead of the natural sciences (MacIntyre 2). MacIntyre, thus turns to an analysis of history as the only way to understand morality where he believes he discovers the very epoch where the catastrophe took place, the Enlightenment. The Enlightenment was a time when philosophy played a central role in society, unlike today, where…

Words 1973 - Pages 8

Cherine's Ethical Dilemmas

Company and key stakeholders’ background # II-Case Analysis # The facts # The ethical issues involved # The Stakeholders The available alternatives Weighting the Alternatives The decision # III-Assigned Questions # Section 3.1 # Section 3.2 # Section 3.3 # IV-Critical reflections # Muriel’s reflection # Melissa’s reflection Cherine’s Reflection Sami’s Reflection # i-Introduction Context Background In order to analyze a case with an ethical dilemma, we must be able to frame the whole situation…

Words 2787 - Pages 12