Justice: Law and Maximum Liberty Essay

Submitted By erfesto

Words: 335

Pages: 2

Open Document

Liberty, Equality, and Distributive Justice
Sir Isaiah Berlin said "If you have maximum liberty, then the strong can destroy the weak, and if you have absolute equality, you cannot have absolute liberty, because you have to coerce the powerful... if they are not to devour the poor and meek... Total liberty can be dreadful, total equality can be equally frightful." This quote Berlin paints his point of view of liberty, equality, and justice. He specified that humanity can’t have both total equality and liberty working together. Implying, that both of these are conflicting each other due to the nature of their laws.
If humanity was able to reach maximum liberty it would contribute further supremacy to the strong, upper-class citizens, to rule over the feeble, lower-class citizens. As the consequence of maximum liberty is humanity would be far from equality. For example a person that is rich would be wearing expensive clothes, driving nice sport cars and the person that is poor would be struggling to pay the monthly bills and support their family. The wealthy would be able to afford a good lawyer when in trouble with the law and will a good chance of “getting out of it” but a poor person in the same situtiattion would not be able to afford a good lawyer and would face the maximum pushiment for the crime.
If humanity was able to reach total equality, it would make it a sad world to live. Yes, its happy idea knowing that everyone is equal but think about it imagine going to

Gault Case Summary

sentence at the state’s juvenile reformatory. Thus, Gerald could potentially spend six years in prison. By contrast, an adult who committed the same crime could have received only a maximum sentence of 60 days in jail and have been ordered to pay a $50 fine. Norman Dorsen, who litigated Gault for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), considered the case the logical extension of Gideon. After the court announced its decision in Kent, Dorsen never doubted that the Supreme Court, during this revolutionary…

Words 1447 - Pages 6

John Locke Research Paper

theory of justices, John Locke contractor from the theory of libertarianism, and Immanuel Kant argued that our action has more worth if the precisely our capacity by rising above self-interest and inclination and to act out of duty, while John Rawle argue that theory of justice as fares is what describes a society in which all citizen holds equal basic right and liberties in order to cooperation with in an egalitarian economics system. The basic principle of liberal theory of justice by John Locke…

Words 1036 - Pages 5

Criminal Justice Process

Criminal justice is a process, involving a series of steps beginning with a criminal investigation and ending with the release of a convicted offender from correctional supervision. Rules and decision making are at the centre of this process. Rules Sources of rules in criminal justice include the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights, state constitutions, the U.S. Code, state codes, court decisions, federal rules of criminal procedure, state rules of criminal procedure, and department and agency rules…

Words 1730 - Pages 7

Patriot Act Essay

Patriot Act There have been numerous critics of the Patriot Act. Many groups like the ACLU, and other privacy and civil liberties advocates, assert that the Act violates too many individual freedoms and liberties, especially those regarding privacy. They argue that the Act makes it too easy for law enforcement officials to collect personal information and monitor organizations and individuals, especially American citizens, under the auspices of terrorism-related investigation. Specifically among…

Words 1871 - Pages 8

North Carolina V. Alford

that his attorney informed on what’s the difference between first degree murder and second degree murder and because of this he chose to plead guilty to a lesser charge. The trial court sentenced Alford, to 30 years of imprisonment which is the maximum penalty for second degree murder. Alford wanted the conviction reversed because he stated that he pleaded guilty only because of fear and coercion. Procedural History United States District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina and Court…

Words 645 - Pages 3

Plea Bargaining In Court Cases

The court component of the justice system is normally viewed as an adversarial system of law between the prosecution and defense presided by a judge. In a criminal trial, the goal is to bring the procedure to a successful close with adversarial framework. Historically, prosecutors present cases and argue to prove a defendant is culpable for a crime. Prosecutors represent the people and are involved in all phases of the court proceedings. It is the job of a prosecutor to secure a conviction. Defense…

Words 438 - Pages 2

Essay Ethics: Political Philosophy and John Rawls

Summary The objective of the John Rawls of justice is to provide justice for the community and the betterment of the individual. In this report, John Rawls of Justice has been described to know the business practices depicted in the Fall of Lehman Brothers promotes justice as the first virtue of the community (Brown, 1984). In this report, it has been described how the primary social institutions like Securities Exchange and Commission promotes justice as fairness in accordance with Rawls. The maintenance…

Words 2002 - Pages 9

Muller V. Oregon Case Study

It all began when the State of Oregon passed a law concerning the maximum hours a woman can work at a job. The protective labor legislation restricted women to work more than ten hours a day. This occurred during the Progressive Era when the world was advancing in technology and machinery work. When a man named Curt Muller was accused of having a woman work more than ten hours, he was charged with a fine of ten dollars. He then filled for an appeal which lead to the Supreme Court. Prior to the Muller…

Words 807 - Pages 4

American Freedom Party Research Paper

The Libertarians believe in three main items: personal liberty, economic liberty and the right to secure liberty ("Libertarian Party Platform"). Personal liberty has to do with having full rights over one’s body. If one wants to use alcohol that is their choice. They oppose government censorship and government spying on its citizens. They do not feel the government…

Words 1890 - Pages 8

Essay about Classical Theory and Its Effects on Criminal Justice Policy

Classical Theory Classical Theory and its Effects on Criminal Justice Policy With the exception of probation, imprisonment has been the main form of punishment for serious offenders in the United States for over 200 years. Americans can be said to have invented modern incarceration as a means of criminal punishment. Although Europe provided precedents, theoretical justifications, and even architectural plans for imprisoning offenders, Americans developed the blueprints for the typical prisons…

Words 1440 - Pages 6