Law Case Essay

Submitted By harreyy
Words: 7078
Pages: 29
Open Document
Mark v Citic (NEGLIGENCE PHYSICAL HARM)
Issue : Can Mark’s wife sue Citic for negligence?
Rules & Application :
Modern law of negligence was leaded by the case of Donoghue v Stevenson where The House of Lords provided 3 elements of a negligence action: duty, breach, damage.
1. Did Citic owe Mark a duty of care?
Reasonable Foreseeable Test
Citic employed Mark as its employee and it is reasonably forseeable that Citic ensure a safe work evironment. If Citic did not tell Mark about the tobron that could cause explosion if it has contact with water, therefore, it is reasonably forseeable that Mark would be injured or dead- Donoghue v Stevenson
2. Is there any breach of duty of care by Citic to Mark?
a. Reasonable Person Test
Being a reasonable person, Citic should take reasonable care by informing their employees about the explotion of Tobron if it contacts with water. In this case, there was a breach of duty of care as they did not exercise the care of reasonable person ought to have taken to prevent that risk - McPherson v Eaton
b. Weighting Test - Wyong Shire Council v Shirt - s48 Wrong Acts 1958
1. Magnitude of risk
The magnitude of the risk is very high because if the tobron has contact with water, it will cause explosion which can result to Mark’s death.
2. Expense of eliminating the risk
There is no expense,difficulty or inconvinience All Citic has to do is just to inform their employees.
3. Probability of risk
The probalitiy that Mark will get injured or death because Citic did not tell Mark about tobron that could cause explosion if it has a contact with water is high.
3. Did Citic cause the death of Mark?
a. Causation Test – to obatain damages Mark must establish that the negligence caused the damage.
But for the action of Citic by telling Mark about explosion that tobron could caused if contacts with water, Mark would not have died - Chapel v Hart
b. Remoteness Test
The death must not be too remote. In this case, the explotion is a direct consequences of Citic for not informing the danger of tobron and accidently it contacts with water. It is reasonably foreseeable that the death of Mark is reasonably forseeable and not too remote as the result of the explotion –
The Wagon Mound No. 2
4. Citic may have defence against Mark. The defences are:
a. Voluntary Assumption of Risk
Mark did not knowingly and willingly accept the risk of the explotion. Therefore, he did not voluntary accept the risk - Moore v Woodforth
b. Contributory Negligence
Mark while washing the bottle accidently dropped the tobron and came into contact with water. Mark failed to exercise reasonable care for his own safety, and that failure contribute to his death. Therefore, the damages and liability will be apportioned (March v Starmare).
Mitigate Losses
Mark must take step in reducing his losses from the breach but in this case, Mark cannot mitigate because he had already dead.
Conclusion :
Mark’s wife can sue Citic for negligence, but the damages and liablity will be apportioned.

Priscilla v Angela (NEGLIGENCE PHYSICAL HARM)
Issue : Can Priscilla sue Angela for damage in relation to the tort of negligence act of carelessly apply the cosmetic with a fragnance?
Modern law of negligence was leaded by the case of Donoghue v Stevenson where The House of Lords provided 3 elements of a negligence action: duty, breach, damage.
Rules & Application:
1. Did Angela owe Priscilla a duty of care?
Reasonable Forseeable Test
Angela did not take reasonable care to avoid acts or omission which Angela can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure Priscilla. Angela should provide non-fragnance cosmetic. Therefore, it is reasonably foreseeable if Angela apply a fragnance cosmetic, Priscilla would be injured (Donoghue v Stevenson).
2. Was there a breach of duty of care by Angela?
a. Reasonable Person Test
Being a reasonable person, Angela should take reasonable care not to use the fragnance cosmetic. In this case, there was a breach of duty of care as she
Show More

Related Documents: Law Case Essay

Law and Case Law Questions Essay

legislation and case law QUESTIONS 1. The case study references one state statute. Identify it and explain what it prohibits. The state statute is the Tex. Penal Code 42.09(a)(3) It prohibits the “desecration of a venerable object” (Case Study) 2. Which branch of government (executive, judicial, or legislative) created the state statute? The Legislative branch of the government created the state statute. 3. The passage above also discusses one court case. Who were the parties involved in the case? The parties…

Words 417 - Pages 2

Sociology Of Law Case

In the piece “An Introduction to the Sociology of Law” we closely looked at the Renee Rogers discrimination lawsuit against Americans Airlines. Rogers accused the airline company of discrimination against her and other fellow African American women who felt their constitutional and civil rights were being violated due to the company not allowing them to have tight braid hairstyles. They felt discriminated as black women and believed their style of hair was symbolic of their racial and gender identity…

Words 742 - Pages 3

Case Study On Law

se(of(the(term(“common(law”?( Common%law%refers%to%the%body%of%laws%developed%by%judges%as%distinct%from%legislation;% None%of%the%above%statements%is%an%incorrect%description%or%use%of%the%term%‘common%law’.% Many%former%British%colonies%share%the%common%law%system%as%a%legacy%of%their%colonial%origin;% Common%law%was%developed%by%successive%Acts%of%the%United%Kingdom%Parliament;% The%rules%of%equity%developed%to%remedy%the%inflexibility%and%inadequacies%of%the%common%law;% % 2. Which,(if(any,(of(the(following(statements(is(correct…

Words 4004 - Pages 17

law case Essay

incorrectly, Mr Maclean will have an economic loss. It was also just and reasonable to impose the liability because Mr Maclean highly relied on Miss Cambridge’s technical skills. Lord Griffiths expressed the premises of a duty of care as follows in the case of Smith v Eric Bush: “only if it is foreseeable that if the advice is negligent the recipient is likely to suffer damage, that there is a sufficient proximate relationship between the parties and that it is just and reasonable to impose the liability”…

Words 1948 - Pages 8

The Law Of The Case Of Mr. Chou's Law

The judge read the charges Mr. Chou was being accused of which included break and enter with intent, mischief under $50, and fail to comply with probation. The judge then explained to him his rights and options to a trial where the onus would be on the crown to prove guilt, and asked him if he was sure that he wanted to plea guilty. The crown then proceeded to read the facts of the day of the offence while disclosing that the accused was a heroin addict. The offence took place on Feb 18th the accused…

Words 445 - Pages 2

Essay on Law case

United States v. Days Inns of Am., Inc., 22 F. Supp. 2d 612 (E.D. Ky. 1998) In this case, the plaintiff is Federal government and the defendant is Days Inn of American Corporation. The defendant got the lawsuit because they fall to design and construct the disable accessible facility when connect the new construction or alternations. In generally, the plaintiff wants to win just need to demonstrate three categories things. First is demonstrated there is unequal treatment for individuals disable;…

Words 913 - Pages 4

Comstock Law Case Analysis

was shocked to know that the Comstock Law was essentially ruining the lives of poor families. The second of these takeaways is about the dreaded Comstock law. I learned that the Comstock Law was created by Anthony Comstock, and that it was signed in 1873 by Ulysses S. Grant. It’s title was the Act for the Suppression of Trade in and Circulation of Obscene Literature and Articles of…

Words 830 - Pages 4

Unjust Law: Case Study

unjust law you will be examining in Essay 5 and why you think it is unjust I will be examining the federal regulation of legal marijuana in all 50 states. I believe this law to be unjust because I find it inexcusable that I can smoke in California, but if I cross into another state it’s a problem. It makes us feel divided as a nation and I think we should just put it to a vote just like we did in California. Kreit, Alex. What Will Federal Marijuana Reform Look Like? 2015, Case Western Reserve Law Review…

Words 278 - Pages 2

Immigration Law Case Study

The United States is known for its law of the land and busy cities, and what it is famous for is what causes families to fall apart. On August 21, 2016, Tatiana Sanchez, author of The San Diego Union-Tribune, stress the importance of immigration policy our country is debating over. Sanchez bring up an example of Emma Sanchez, a mother of two American born children. Emma was deported to Tijuana in a barbaric way, for her deportation happen while she was sleeping and has been banning her from returning…

Words 550 - Pages 3

law case study Essay

ended 30 June 2013. ISSUE: The main issue to consider with this case is whether the loss of licence insurance payment $250,000, long service leave payment $30,000 and the loss of income insurance payments $60,000 are assessable income? LAWS: S 6 -­‐ 1(1) ITAA 1997 Assessable Income = Ordinary income + Statutory…

Words 4499 - Pages 18