Marbury Vs Madison Supreme Court Case

Words: 550
Pages: 3
Open Document
The Supreme Court case of Marbury v. Madison took place in 1803 under the presidency of Thomas Jefferson. The reason for this case was the petitioning of William Marbury, who was appointed last-minute Justice of the Peace by John Adams, but the commissions were not delivered by the Secretary of State James Madison. The Court ultimately ruled in favor of Madison, and the Jefferson administration. However, the point that the podcast makes is that the decision of the case was not just a simple rejection of the position to Marbury. The verdict of the Supreme Court in the Marbury v. Madison case had a substantial impact on the structure of the nation through the establishing of judicial review, which gave the Supreme Court the power to declare laws …show more content…
Madison, the podcast offers some interesting insight into some of the major characters of the case. One example is that the Chief Justice John Marshall and President Thomas Jefferson were in fact second-cousins with extreme ideological differences, since Jefferson was of the Democratic-Republican Party and Marshall was a Federalist who was Secretary of State under John Adams. Another fact mentioned by the podcast is that the Supreme Court did not have the power and reputation that it does today, but Marshall and the court case changed all that. Marshall not only changed the way the Court presented itself in terms of items such as clothing, but he also changed the way that the other branches of government saw the Court. Marshall knew that Marbury had every right to pursue the position appointed to him by John Adams and that the Jefferson administration was in the wrong for not sending in those commissions, but he also knew that the Court did not have the power to force Jefferson to send them. Keeping this in mind, Marshall made the decision in favor of Madison because of a simple technicality: the law that Congress passed allowing for Marbury to go directly to the Supreme Court went against the Constitution. By declaring this act unconstitutional and denying Marbury of his position, the Supreme Court benefitted greatly from this since it established this institution as the official interpreter of the Constitution and allowed for greater power in government, by being able to keep the other branches in check
Show More

Related Documents: Marbury Vs Madison Supreme Court Case

Marbury Vs. Madison: Supreme Court Case

The Marbury v. Madison was the first decision by the Supreme Court to declare a law unconstitutional. The case of Marbury v. Madison, in 1803, was one of the most crucial court cases and decisions made in this period. Thomas Jefferson, was the new president, and refused to recognize the appointment of Marbury. However, before Adams lost his position as President to Thomas Jefferson, Jefferson tried to control Congress by passing the Judiciary Act of 1801. The Judiciary Act represented an effort…

Words 245 - Pages 1

Marbury Vs. Madison: Supreme Court Case

Marbury v. Madison was a Supreme Court case that was held as a political statement that stated the powers of the Supreme Court. Although the purpose of the case was to settle the commission of Marbury who was promised the position of Justice of the Peace by former president Adams. Marbury filed a petition that the Secretary of State, James Madison, would be forced to hand over their commissions.The case settled by the Supreme Court settled the strife between Marbury and Madison however Judge Marshall…

Words 363 - Pages 2

Pros And Cons Of Marbury Vs Madison

Marbury vs. Madison: Judicial Review Since the birth of the United States of America, there have been many court cases that have helped shape and form the laws of the land in which we live. In 1803, Supreme Court Justice John Marshall, had to make a ruling on the case Marbury vs. Madison, which is considered to be one of the most important decisions ever made concerning judicial power within the history of the United States of America. (US Courts.) When the U.S. Constitution was written, there…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

Essay on Marbury Vs Madison

Jefferson took office. This led to the famous court case in 1803 Marbury vs Madison. Adams appointed various Federalists to the judiciary branch. Leading to the single most significant case of the Supreme Court, Marbury Vs. Madison, a struggle between Republicans and Federalists that would end with a decision. This controversial landmark case established the constitution as the “Supreme law” of the United States and developed the power of the Supreme Court, enhancing its independence and the precedent…

Words 561 - Pages 3

The Marbury Vs. Madison Case In 1803

The Marbury vs. Madison case in 1803 is seen by many to be the most important case in Supreme Court history. It is the first case where the court declared an act of Congress void because it went against the Constitution. The case originated when President John Adams appointed several Federalist judges to the D.C. courts prior to leaving office. The judiciary appointments were approved by congress and signed by President Adams. The last step needed for the judges to take office was a piece of paper…

Words 321 - Pages 2

Marbury Vs Madison Case Study

Marbury Vs. Madison was a landmark U.S. Supreme court case. This case made the Court form a basis for the exercise of Judicial review in the U.S. under Article 3 of the Constitution. This case helped define the boundaries between the two government branches, Executive and Judicial. William Marbury was appointed Justice of the peace in the district of Columbia by President John Adams but the commission was not delivered. Marbury petitioned the Supreme Court to make the new Secretary of State…

Words 167 - Pages 1

Marbury Vs Madison Case Summary

Marbury vs. Madison, 1803 This case was between William Marbury and James Madison. In the “lame duck” period following the Election of 1800, John Adams was appointing new justices of the peace. He had commissioned six “midnight judges’ on the last day of his term. John Marshall was the Secretary of State and was in charge of delivering the appointment commissions. He failed to deliver three commissions, including the commission of William Marbury. Thomas Jefferson then took office along with his…

Words 338 - Pages 2

APUSH 11B Essay

election and the inauguration of a successor, had to elect president in 1800 when there was a tie. B. This was a nickname given to a group of judges that was appointed by John Adams the night before he left office. He appointed them to go to the federal courts so there would be a long term Federalist influence in the government, since judges serve for life instead of limited terms. C. A law passed by the Federalist Congress. This law allowed the president, President Adams, to stay up until midnight signing…

Words 402 - Pages 2

Essay on Change in American History

Change has been a crucial part of history and will continue to be a crucial part of the future. There are three major aspects of change that I am going to talk about. They are: The Declaration of Independence, Shays’ Rebellion, and the trial of Marbury vs. Madison. Not only were these three topics important aspects of change, but in these examples, each of them significantly paved the way for future change and how things would be difference after each event. Typically in history, a major event or some…

Words 1014 - Pages 5

Supreme Court of the United States and Brandt the Judiciary Essay

Patrick Brandt Constitutional Basis for Courts • Constitution only creates the Supreme Court – others were established by Congress shortly after. • Congress can create “inferior” courts as it sees fit. Examples: District and Appeals courts, Bankruptcy Court, etc. • Courts are a primary example of federalism: courts exist at both levels and enforce the same laws of the nation (state and federal), and the laws of states (state courts). • Courts stand in a pyramid structure at the state…

Words 2527 - Pages 11