Essay Marx and Weber

Submitted By haleema11
Words: 642
Pages: 3
Open Document
In this essay i will compare various aspects of sociological theories as outlined by two key sociological thinkers, Kark Marx and Max Weber by drawing similarites and diffrences. Both Marx and Weber in their wrightings saw the rise of capitalist society as emergiging during the industrial revolution in the 16th and 17th centuries in western Europe and aimed to understand the impact of such changes on society. i will begin by giving a breif outline of some of marx's writing concerning the the rise of capitalism and then i will outline some of Weber's thories, drawing comparisons and difftences.
Karl Marx was a German philosipher who looked at french politics and english economics as his main influences in his wrightings.
The British sociological journal looks at Marx and Weber's conflictiong interpretations of the rise of capitalism. Weber saw the function of ideology as an independant variable in social development, he struck upon this theme into his course of enquiry into the emergance of capitalism in the west, focusing on England. in comparison to to Marx, who saw historical materialism as the driving force in historical development. both Marx and Weber were deeply influenced by the historic tendancy of German social thought, which was found in the wrightings of Hegal, who held that social existance is a process that each historical epoch and social structure is unique and to be only understood by laws referable only to theirself. Both Marx and Weber in their own ways broke up with such postulates, Marx rejected idealistic interpretations in the context of social process, asserting that such decisive events are in the realm of social relationships, but not in the sphere of the evolution of ideas. He therfore fashioned a theory which looked at underlying regularities in social change, whilst retaining the historicism's sence of process and transformation. Weber attempted to formulate some general categories that would apply to all historical epochs, this too constitutes a break with hostoricism, thus both worked in the historist temper. marx gave emphasis to the scientific character of this materialist philosophy, taking on the idea that ideas and institutions are determined by matertioal unditions under which men work. According to this theory and understanding of the organisation of production would provide us with a major clue as to what drives development in society. hence, he undertook an ecomomic analysis of capitalism. page 150 ASR class and status
Both reconise the importance of private property marx proposed that capitalists abd workers would become nation-wide classes, as the
Show More

Related Documents: Essay Marx and Weber

Marx Vs Weber

"Marx, and Weber both have different views on the structure of capitalism and where it derived from. Weber's intention though, was to chase a path of determination; his main goal was to understand capitalism from a historical point of view." But this is not entirely true. The difference between both of their theories was not the historical point of view versus the contemporary detailed examination. But both of these theories follow an analysis that has developed and evolved through time. They both…

Words 1822 - Pages 8

Essay about Capitalism in Marx and Weber

The Concept Of Capitalism In Marx And Weber; What Is The Contemporary Relevance Of Their Ideas? Introduction: At the later nineteenth century many social and economical ideas were developed because of the past revolutions and the present conflict of individuals and organised assemblies. Capitalism, one of these ideas, leads bourgeoisie to dream of a capitalist society in order to advance their maintain lifestyle and gain wealth. This economic system which is dominated by private business and…

Words 3408 - Pages 14

Comparing the Ideologies of Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim, and Max Weber Essay

Ideologies of Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim, and Max Weber Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim, and Max Weber were three historical sociologists. Their views have become world renown and have shaped many ways of interpreting the social structure of many modern societies. This essay will take a glimpse into the three sociologists’ ideals and expose the similarities and differences they may have. Karl Marx’s view of society was based around the economy. All other social structures according to Marx, such as religion…

Words 1307 - Pages 6

Compare and Contrast Marxist and Weberian Theories of Stratification Essay

of both Karl Marx and Max Weber. O’Donnell (1992) defines social stratification as “the division of a society or group into hierarchically ordered layers. Members of each layer are considered broadly equal but there is inequality between the layers.” Functionalist Durkheim (1858-1917) argued that the reason for the existence of stratification was because it was functional or beneficial to the order of society. According to Browne et al (2009),…

Words 1513 - Pages 7

Karl Marx Vs Durkheim

Karl Marx, Max Weber, and Emile Durkheim all lived in a revolutionary era for Capitalism and witnessed its growing as well as some of the problems they associated with its growth. Karl Marx argued that Capitalism created an environment where labor becomes a commodity, one that may exploit, and more likely, one that may be exploited. The division of labor, according to Marx, separated the bourgeoisie and the proletariat. This relationship was hierarchal and depended on the passive acceptance from…

Words 261 - Pages 2

Sociology Essay

Durkheim, Weber & Marx Freedom & Control in the Modern World - Freedom Enlightenment: -goal was to prove oneself through intellectual development, or to seek re-justification of society, people have to be free from strains of old feudal older - modern world has enhanced human capacities to transform physical environment and fashion for useful things for people - greater degree of freedom - development of science and rational thinking liberates our minds from superstition (weber concerned…

Words 2792 - Pages 12

Auguste Commpte's Theory

Max Weber- (1864-1920) Max Weber was born in Germany and was influenced by the works of Karl Marx. He was however very critical of Marx’s observations. He saw class conflict as less significant; this was contrary to Marx’s views. According to Weber, social action was an action carried out by an individual and the individual takes account of the behavior of others. An action that a person does not think about cannot be a social action according to Weber. For example an accident…

Words 765 - Pages 4

contrast and compare Essay examples

are repeatedly mentioned in sociological theory are Karl Marx and Max Weber. In some ways these two intellectuals were similar in the way they looked at society. There are also some striking differences. In order to compare and contrast these two individuals it is necessary to look at each of their ideas. Then a comparison of their views can be illustrated followed by examples of how their perspectives differ from each other. Karl Marx was born in Trier, Germany in 1818. He came from a middle-class…

Words 606 - Pages 3

Conflict Theory, Karl Marx, and the Communist Manifesto Essay

Conflict Theory, Karl Marx, and The Communist Manifesto In order to understand Marx a few terms need to be defined. The first is Bourgeoisie; these are the Capitalists and they are the employers of wage laborers, and the owners of the means of production. The means of production includes the physical instruments of production such as the machines, and tools, as well as the methods of working (skills, division of labor). The Proletariat is the class of wage-laborers, they do not have their own…

Words 1335 - Pages 6

Marx, Marx And Engels In The 1927 Film, Metropolis

Metropolis, is a manifestation of ideas encompassed by Max Weber, Karl Marx, and Frederick Engels. Within the first moments of the movie, the audience is exposed to images of workers who have been stripped of their humanity and autonomy. Each worker moves as the other does, responding to one another and to their surroundings as though they were pieces of the machine that kept the extravagent city of Metropolis running. In describing bourgoise society, Marx and Engles state, "the work of the proletarians has…

Words 497 - Pages 2