The next day they ended up buying a brand new one with the “eighteen thousand francs left to him by his father” while they intended to loan the rest. Instead of trying to reckon and tell the truth to her “friend”, she tried to cover up her tracks by replacing it. If Mahdile really considered Madame Forestier a close trusting friend, she would have told the truth and found herself not worried by the small price of five hundred francs instead of forty thousand. For example, If you had borrowed your friend's favorite sweatshirt and end up leaving it at the movies, you would tell her the truth instead of retracing your every step in trying to find it or spending more money to buy a replica. It would save a lot of time and stress for you to just tell the truth and by doing that might even make you closer as friends. But again Mathilde didn't want to look shabby of poor and have Madame Forestier think twice next time she went behind her back and bought a real one. “ What would she have thought? What would she have said? Would she not have taken her for a thief?” All these thoughts were running through Mathildes head while giving back the necklace. She went behind her back because she was really just afraid of being judged or mistaken as a