Mexican American War Dbq

Words: 463
Pages: 2
Open Document
Was the United States Justified in Going to War With Mexico?

It was destiny, not inhumanity or invasion. The war with Mexico was in 1846 until 1848. The war was ignited by the 16 soldiers slaughtered on what was disputed land and Texas’s statehood. So, was the war with Mexico justified or not? The United States was justified in going to war with Mexico because manifest destiny, the people supported the war, and the legislature supported it. One reason the war with Mexico was justified was because a belief called Manifest Destiny. Manifest Destiny was a belief that it was God himself’s will to have the United States to stretch from the North to the West. Document A states that Manifest Destiny was a huge part in the war. It also states that …show more content…
Document D states that says Charles Sumner, a state legislature from Massachusetts, had the people of Massachusetts on his side. Also in Document B it shows the results of voting to go to war with Mexico: in the House of Representatives 174 people voted yes and only 14 voted no, that is about a 90% difference. This evidence shows that Constitutionally the United States was justified. A third and final reason on how the Mexican-American war is justified is that the government supported the idea of retaliation. Document A states that 16 American soldiers were slaughtered at the hands of Mexican soldiers. This aggravated many American’s because these Americans were killed on “American soil.” The legislative branch held a vote which the results from the House of Senate were in Document D. The results of the poll, 40 yes and 2 no, this is a 95% difference between the voters. So, as usual, majority won and the U.S. went to war. The United States was justified in going to war with Mexico because of Manifest Destiny, the people supporting the war, and the legislature supporting the war. It is important for the United States to be justified in going to war with Mexico because we might not be able to have the states and the country we have today. This an important topic for today because if this war did not happen we might not have the West
Show More

Related Documents: Mexican American War Dbq

The Mexican-American War DBQ

To some, the war between Mexico and America (also known as the Mexican-American war in America, and The American invasion in Mexico,) was a war based on lies sustained by the nefarious intent of President Polk, but to others a declaration of liberty and a demonstration of American power. The Mexican-American war was a war between America and Mexico due to Texas yearning to be annexed into America, America and Mexico then went on to fight over Texas. In the end America won the war and took Texas along…

Words 498 - Pages 2

Mexican-American War Dbq

In the 1800’s America was different than what it is now. Like, how wars were always happening even if they shouldn’t have been started in the beginning. Take, for instance, the Mexican- American War. The US was not justified in going into war with Mexico because they intruded on land they didn’t own, they didn’t abide by Mexican laws, and the Us went straight to the idea of war instead of working things out. On December 19, 1836, the Congress of Texas declared the Rio Grande a boundary between…

Words 421 - Pages 2

Mexican-American War Dbq

The Mexican-American War of 1846 played a significant role in the history of the United States and Mexico. There were some reasons for this war: annexation of Texas and “Manifest Destiny” theory. First, by 1936, there was a strong movement for Texas independence. After several bloody battles between the Mexican army and Texas Freedom Fighters, the Texans won their independence. However, hostilities rose again from a dispute over the southern boundary between Texas and Mexico. During the 1843 presidential…

Words 308 - Pages 2

Mexican American War Dbq Analysis

4/29/15 English-3rd Social Studies-2nd The Mexican and American War Slaves coming unwillingly with their rebel owners trying to be part of the U.S. While trying to become a free state. The Mexican War was from 1846-1848 at the Alamo. This lead up to Texas having it’s freedom. Both sides have different ways of seeing the War. America sees it as, “U.S. historians refer to this event as the Mexican War.” (Document C Paragraph 1). The Mexicans see it as “The American government acted like a bandit who came…

Words 610 - Pages 3

Mexican American War Dbq Analysis

The background essay says, “ Thousands of Mexicans and Americans died, and half of the country of Mexico was taken by the United States as a war prize”. During the Mexican- American war, many people from both countries died trying to claim the land that they believed was theirs. The U.S. took Mexico’s land as a prize of their own, they believed they needed that land because they wanted to fulfill their Manifest Destiny.The war started when the annexation of Texas to the United States started to happen…

Words 611 - Pages 3

Mexican American War Dbq Analysis

end result concluding who gets some of the most valuable lands in the world, the Mexican American war was sure to bring the best of the two countries against each other. During the western expansion of the United States, the need for land increased as the population rose. The sight of Texas and California interested the United States, but at the time was owned by Mexico. Although Texas was owned by Mexican, American families were allowed to live in Texas. Soon after, the people of Texas rebelled…

Words 797 - Pages 4

Mexican American War Dbq Research Paper

The Mexican–American War can be blamed on the United States presidential election of 1844 between Democratic Candidate James K. Polk and Henry Clay, the Whig Party Candidate. A Campaign that was fought on foreign policy, with Polk favoring the annexation of Texas and Clay opposed. James K. Polk who campaigned on a platform that embraced American territorial expansionism, an idea soon to be called Manifest Destiny by John O’ Sullivan won the election. “At their convention, the Democrats called for…

Words 496 - Pages 2

Democracy DBQ Essay

Democracy in new Nation DBQ The democratic state of America was in shambles in the 1800s. The women began to start rising up and speaking out. They wanted a say in what was happening to their new nation. Westward expansion would also be a problem. It was difficult to get a balance between free and slave states and with all the new land coming in from the Mexican-American War, there will be a big controversy on which territory will be what. As the country expands as a whole, the government will…

Words 603 - Pages 3

United States and Essential Questions Essay

Advanced Placement Untied States History Dr. Alba 2014-2015 School Year Course Description: AP U.S. History covers the spectrum of American history from pre- Columbian days to the present. Using chronological and thematic approaches to the material, the course exposes students to extensive primary and secondary sources and to the interpretations of various historians. Class participation through seminar reports, discussions, debates, and role-playing activities is required; special emphasis…

Words 7288 - Pages 30

CAM RADCLIFFE EXPANSION DBQ Essay

CAM RADCLIFFE AP HISTORY DBQ EXPANSION The idea of Manifest destiny emerged in the 1840’s and said that the people of America were chosen by God to control the North American continent. But as Americans pushed West in hopes of territorial expansion, they encountered many problems. The North and South became increasingly belligerent towards each other specifically over the controversies of slavery. Due the nation annexing new lands, the status of slavery was on everyone’s minds. The Missouri…

Words 550 - Pages 3