Miracles Notes Essay example

Submitted By Rowyourb0at
Words: 886
Pages: 4
Open Document
MIRACLES REVISION
INTRODUCTION
- Begin w. Hume’s definition: “the transgression of a law of nature by a particular volition the Deity, or by the interposition of some invisible agent”.
- Much debate in an attempt to establish a definitive meaning. Despite the efforts of many eminent scholars, most definitions have been of too close a likeness and all are inevitably subjective. Inevitably reflects an individual’s faith/outlook.
- There are innumerable reasons as to why an individual may believe in the possibility of miracles. For theists in particular, miracles can be a way of authenticating one’s idea of God; inexplicable events appearing to be the work of a deity, demonstrating its transcendental power and parental love. Miracles can also be interpreted as God’s response to “special pleading” (Swinburne) in times of adversity, and so in light of this, any miraculous events are likely to greatly affirm one’s faith in God.
- Miraculous events pose 2 challenges to the believer: is the idea of a miracle coherent?/is it ever rational to believe in miracles?
- Lie at the heart of Christian belief (first w. Jesus birth, then w. crucifixion and resurrection, showing that Jesus was the Son of God) and therefore, any challenge raised against the coherence/for the impossibility of miracles may also challenge the integrity of one’s faith.
AQUINAS
- 13th century theologian defined miracles as “those things done by divine power apart from the order usually followed in things”. Regarded in modern theology as a traditional definition, which allows God to shape and influence his creation as he wills.
- 3 categories:
• The naturally impossible (stopping the sun – Joshua, 10:13)
• The naturally unlikely, done without the laws of nature (Exorcisms – Mark, 1:31)
• Those things which, although able to be explained by nature or science, have strong religious significance and point towards divine intervention.
- All miracles may be attributed to God; even those things which may be accounted for logically and without complication.
SWINBURNE
- As the laws of nature are reasonably predictable, it would be fair to regard anything seemingly “impossible” or occurring outside of these laws as a miracle.
- used the examples of turning water into wine without any scientific apparatus or a man being cured of polio in under a minute; claiming that the extraordinary nature of these events lent them to be classed as miracles (the time frame and circumstances under which an event occurs determines whether it may or may not be a miracle)
- For an event to be truly miraculous, it must be of some religious significance. Thus, if God were to “upset a child’s box of toys, just for spite”, it would be misconstrued to consider it a miracle.
TILLICH (MID 1900’S SCHOLAR)
- Adopted a far more orthodox stance on miracles, describing them to be “shaking, astonishing and without contradicting the rational structure of reality”.
- Tillich proposed miracles to be divine acts of God, which defied logical or scientific explanation or accountability.
- Still maintained in secular society, as well as religious organisations.
Tillich proposed miracles to be divine acts of God, which defied logical or scientific explanation or accountability.
HUME
- In his writings, Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Hume constructs four arguments in opposition of miracles, claiming that a “rational” man would discredit any testimonies or claims that appear to be of a miraculous nature.
1 - Hume suggests that there have never been, in all cases of attested miracles, enough witnesses to resolve a case
Show More

Related Documents: Miracles Notes Essay example

Abstruse Philosophy In David Hume's Analysis

philosophy.” In a section of the Enquiry entitled “Of Miracles”, Hume casts doubt upon the veracity of miraculous claims, arguing that it is, as a maxim, irrational to accept the existence of a miracle on the basis of testimony. Hume’s argumentation for this claim begins with the fairly uncontroversial contention that our senses are fallible. As such, they may lead us astray in establishing matters of fact. Continuing on from this, Hume notes that not all apparent causes are followed by certain effects;…

Words 1063 - Pages 5

Miracle And Bleachers: Movie Analysis

weaknesses. Such unison and work ethic combined with lead to victory; without it, a team will fail. Miracle is the true story of the United States Men's Hockey team and their preparation and defeat of the thought-to-be-unbeatable Soviet Union, during the 1980 Winter Olympics. Bleachers is about the dying Messina Spartans' football Coach, Eddie Rake and his past players who come back for his burial service. Miracle and Bleachers are both about sports, however, their differences are apparent when analyzed in…

Words 1524 - Pages 7

Essay on Book of John

Messiah and the Son of God. What makes these miracles so special is the difficulty faced to create them and what each is trying to teach. There are seven main miracles, seven being a significant number throughout the bible, that are used to help better understand Jesus and his true identity. We can also find a last miracle in His resurrection, which in itself is simply put that Jesus is a part of God because of how impossible this action seemed. The last miracle is sometimes skipped as a sign that Jesus…

Words 1922 - Pages 8

Humility In Russian Orthodoxy

orthodoxy has evolved over time with the deterioration of some elements and the addition of others, but certain influences in the religion always remained constant. Comparing the “The Life of Archpriest Avvakum by Himself” and “The Life, Acts, and Miracles of Our Blessed Father Sergei of Radonezh” one can see that some aspects of the Orthodox faith did not change despite decades that separate the times in which the two Saints lived. Both figures act humbly and experience suffering without complaint…

Words 1567 - Pages 7

Beowulf: A Literary Analysis

the epic nature of it, and possible oral beginnings. Beowulf has been deemed as the “Great English Epic.” Beyond the story itself, this text provides insight into the beliefs and ideas of the Anglo-Saxons, before the Norman Invasion of 1066, is a miracle of the manuscripts existence, and has influenced literature. The story of Beowulf has a brave young man (Beowulf), travel to another kingdom (Scandinavia) and fight the fights the locals could not (Grendel and mother). This story promotes a man of…

Words 696 - Pages 3

Essay about Personality of Jesus

perfect. He healed the sick, performed miracles, and never sinned. I guess you could say this was true, but it is true to us in this time. Back in the day, Jesus was considered a drunk, a man shouting obscenities, he was known for the company he kept. He touched people that were exiled from their communities because of their illnesses; he was friends to “harlot” and people who engaged in what the church considered promiscuous behavior. Even when he performed miracles he was accused of being possessed…

Words 437 - Pages 2

Mirabello Cavalori

great Florentine artists of earlier generations, especially Jacopo Pontormo and Andrea del Sarto. The dazzling use of contrasting colors in the draperies is like del Sarto’s but in a palette that goes beyond him in its audacity. The scene depicts the miracle of the resurrection of Lazarus, the brother of Mary and Martha. The…

Words 1008 - Pages 5

Analysis of the Gospel of John Essay

blueletterbible.org/blb/2013/03/05/the-work-and-person-of-the-holy-spirit-in-the-gospel-of-john/ http://www.stempublishing.com/authors/davison/Rdgs/JOHN.html 12 R+L Continue with Assessment booklet Form a plan for you in Class Essay Create half page of notes regarding booklet material to help you with your essay. “The Holy Spirit guides and empowers the Church in its mission to proclaim Jesus Christ to the world” Date: The gospel was apparently written near the end of the 1st century. Circa 85-90 A.D…

Words 632 - Pages 3

Essay about Interpretation of Matthew

practical decisions about the rule of life for a Christian. The main structure of the book of Matthew is mostly chronological. It is basically a biography of Jesus, so of course it only makes sense that it is put into chronological order. On another note Matthew could be considered of having a bit of geographical structure to it too. Matthew has lots of place indicators, and can profitably be read with an open atlas at hand. The most important geographical marker in Matthew is the distinction between…

Words 1054 - Pages 5

Essay about Safe Journey On

in a ball cap handed me the script. So without missing a beat I looked it over, made some final notes, took a drink of water from the cup that made the journey with me all these years, and began to speak: The memories attached to the following pages are filled with horror, joy, pain, deep sorrow and indescribable miracles. But if you are holding this book in your hands just now, you are the miracle in it all..read on. I remember seeing President Jimmy Carter on the second-hand television in our…

Words 659 - Pages 3