New York Ratification Convention Analysis

Words: 1163
Pages: 5
Open Document
Speeches debating the Constitution from New York ratification convention The reading is all about the speeches of speeches of Melancton Smith, Alexander Hamilton, and Robert Livingston from New York in the process of debating whether or not to ratify the new Constitution in 1788. There were two groups that are Federalists and Anti-Federalists, they are delegates and debated on the New Constitutional Convention about the three main issues at the New York ratification convention: representation in Congress, sources of corruption, and the Constitution’s effect on the states. Each group has their perspectives on each case, they both think the Constitution will be perfect if the government follows their perspectives. Therefore, both Federalists …show more content…
In the first case, representation in Congress, Melancton Smith was Anti-Federalists member chief objections to the constitution was that the house representatives were not representative enough. Smith believed, “Representatives should be a true picture of the people…while it embraces the men of the first class, it should admit those of the middling class of life” (page 2). I think Anti-Federalists was worrying about the lower-class, such as the middle-class farmer (Yeoman) will hardly ever be chosen. According to the Anti-Federalists’ arguments, when the number of representatives is small, it means the representatives is not enough to serve the government, and there will be a competitive for only rich people because …show more content…
Melancton Smith states, “We have no reason to hold our state governments in contempt, or to suppose them incapable of acting wisely…The state constitutions should be the guardians of our domestic rights and interests, and should be both the support and the check of the federal government” (page 9). The Anti-Federal worrying about the reducing the benefits of the state government while the federal government was taking interests over state governments. However, Federal very supports this system because they believed this could help both sides of state and federal governments to cooperation together, and developing in various fields. Alexander Hamilton said in his speech, “Gentlemen ought not, then, to presume that the advocates of this Constitution are influenced by ambitious views. The suspicion, sir, is unjust; the charge is uncharitable” (page 10). Hamilton was angry when the Anti-Federalists said that Federalists only interested in rank and power, but as Hamilton’s opinion that the federal government will be ruined if they against the interests of the people. Whereas the Anti-Federalists insist assume, the country is infested because of the government taking people’s
Show More

Related Documents: New York Ratification Convention Analysis

United States and Essential Questions Essay

frame class discussions; these are often used as writing assignments. Assessment of essays are measured by the following: the degree to which they fully and directly answer the question, the strength of thesis statement, level and effectiveness of analysis, amount and quality of supporting evidence, and organizational quality. In addition to these standards, DBQs are graded on the basis of the degree to which a significant number of the documents have been used to support the thesis, and the amount…

Words 7288 - Pages 30

Legalization Marijuana Essay

possibility of tyranny This is crucial because it becomes the Bill of Rights. III. Patrick Henry was an Anti-Federalist who wasn’t going to sign without a Bill of Rights. Henry laid out his concerns for the changes in Government at the Virginia Ratifying Convention: 1) the Preamble is ordained by “We the People,” and not “We the States,” 2) the Constitution departs too far from the Articles of Confederation, 3) representation in the House is inadequate, 4) the rights of the people are not properly protected…

Words 3988 - Pages 16

Anibolic steriods Essay

programs have caught their athletes using anabolic steroids since then. It all started during the 1950s when a physician named John Ziegler, who is considered to be the father of anabolic steroids in the U.S., travelled to Vienna with the American/York barbell weightlifting team. While he was there he conversed with a Russian physician whom he eventually learned that the Russian lifting team was equipped with performance enhancing drugs too from which he blamed for their success. Upon Ziegler’s return…

Words 2726 - Pages 11

Bill Clinton Essay

to 2001 as the 42nd President of the United States. Inaugurated at age 46, he was the third-youngest president. He took office at the end of the Cold War, and was the first president from the baby boomer generation. Clinton has been described as a New Democrat. Many of his policies have been attributed to a centrist Third Way philosophy of governance. Before becoming president, he was the Governor of Arkansas for five two-year terms, serving from 1979 to 1981 and from 1983 to 1992. He was also the…

Words 8036 - Pages 33

Essay on WLDoc 14 11 06 9 47 PM

taken into account through market processes”. Such effects have increased, with: “… growing numbers of people, greater economic interdependence, and an outpouring of chemicals and industrial products of uncertain environment effect; workers absorbing new chemicals in work place; the general public affected by waste residues interacting with one another in the environment”. Large corporations may also contribute more directly to negative externalities as a result of their size, geographic dispersion…

Words 8834 - Pages 36

Compare And Contrast Cannabis And Alcohol

Cannabis and alcohol have a more similar history than most people know. At times both were considered medicine. And both have gone through a prohibition periods in twentieth-century America: Alcohol with the ratification of the Eighteenth Amendment in 1919 and cannabis starting in the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937. Cannabis’ prohibition came in gradually and it has been illegal for almost a century. Alcohol, on the other hand, indifferent locales at different time but in 1920 nationally with a Constitutional…

Words 6829 - Pages 28

United Arab of Emirates Country Notebook Essay

Emirates Country Notebook Presented to Dr. Shahira El Alfy Prepared by: Mohamed Ibrahim Osama Mosher Ismail Ahmed El-Mohamady Hesham Mostafa Eslsca 36 – Global Management I. Cultural Analysis: Identification of the Emirates History: The United Arab Emirates (UAE) consists of the seven emirates, which are: Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Sharjah, Ras Al-Khaimah, Ajman, Umm Al-Qaiwain, and Fujairah. They were united as a federal state on 2…

Words 18853 - Pages 76