Essay about Nursing/Medicine Research Report Critique

Words: 2280
Pages: 10
Open Document
Critique of a Research Report:
Comparison of Communication Outcomes in Traditional versus Simulation Strategies in Nursing and Medical Students

Khaoula Louati
University of Athabasca

Introduction
The purpose of research in nursing and medicine is to acquire knowledge that would improve nursing and medical practices. The research paper that will be critiqued is “Comparison of Communication Outcomes in Traditional versus Simulation Strategies in Nursing and Medical Students”. The aim of this critique is to evaluate the Substantive and Theoretical, Methodological, Ethical, Interpretive as well as the Presentation and Stylistic Dimensions of the research paper mentioned above. Following the evaluation of these aspects will be a …show more content…
In addition, the reliability of the data increases to some degree as there was no variation in the administration of the survey; the amounts of questions as well as the questions themselves were the same for all participants. In terms of the credibility it too exists to some extent as proof of triangulation and persistent observation of the data was present. On the other hand the data could have possibly been more credible had there been prolonged engagement of the data collection (Loiselle & Profetto-McGrath, 2011). Within the data, conformability is present as there is congruence in the answers given by individuals of definite groups. This is seen in the qualitative data were nursing students of the simulation group stated that they felt they should follow directions in comparison to medical students who felt more as leaders. This data was collected from the students individually, within their specified groups. And so it can be seen that congruence in the data is present as the individuals of groups had similar thoughts about their roles (Reising, Carr, Shea, & King, 2011).

The study made note of the reliability of its data as it stated under its limitations that “…no tools existed that were specific enough to measure the concepts under study” (Reising, Carr, Shea, & King, 2011) . The previous
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Nursing/Medicine Research Report Critique

Qualitative Critique: Evidence Based Nursing Research And Practice

1 QUALITATIVE RESEARCH ARTICLE CRITIQUE Qualitative Critique: Opinions of Nursing Students on the Art of Nursing Evidence Based Nursing Research and Practice NU-431-8A April 2, 2017 This paper is a nursing critique of a qualitative research article written by Emel Duran and Esin Uslusoy (2015) entitled: Opinions of Nursing Students on the Art of Nursing. Throughout the period of May 2012 through June 2012 male and female nursing students from the Nursing Department in Turkey…

Words 1635 - Pages 7

Comparing Quantitative Research Studies

Comparing Quantitative Research Studies Paula Knight, RN NUR 4165 Introduction  The purpose of this paper is to critique, contrast, and compare two research studies. “Assessment of Anxiety in Intensive Care Patients by Using the Faces Anxiety Scale” written by McKinley, Stein-Parbury, Chehelnabi, & Lovas will be referred to as study one (2004). “Prevalence of Limited Health Literacy and Compensatory Strategies Used by Hospitalized Patients” written by Morris, Grant, Repp, MacLean, & Littenburg…

Words 2478 - Pages 10

Essay on Concept Analysis

1 Concept Analysis on Communication Felecia Turner Nursing 201 Dr. R. Otten Dr. Tori Canillas-Dufau November 3, 2009 Introduction Mary had a seizure on May 7th. She was subsequently diagnosed with a brain tumor by physicians at a prominent Boston hospital considered to be one of the finest healthcare institutions in the country. My mother received excellent medical and physical nursing care in the hospital. , But but she and my family received little empathy…

Words 1740 - Pages 7

Critical Appraisal

A critical appraisal of a published piece of research related to practice. Evidence Based Practice - HEN62029-5 Student number 10039687 Word count 3150 The following ssion of this assignment attempts to critically appraise the venUS III randomised control trial (RTC) published in the British Medical Journal. As a student/healthcare worker who is new to critical appraisal I am aware that I do not fully understand some of the calculations involved in reporting of findings, however Greenhalgh…

Words 4112 - Pages 17

Nursing Contextual Project Sample

entitled Research in Nursing. 1. Variables 2. Research Questions 3. Literature Review 4. Manipulation 5. Purposive Sampling 6. Abstract Writing 7. Hypothesis 8. Informed Consent 9. Observation in Research 10. Reliability 1.0 RESEARCH VARIABLES This is a concept, characteristic or trait that varies e.g. takes on measurably different values within an identified population in a research study (Rae W Langford 2001). The research variables of any scientific experiment or research process…

Words 4339 - Pages 18

Jsb170 Research Worksheet

JSB170: Introduction to Criminology and Policing Potentially Harmful Consequences of Child Abuse for Victims Assessment One: Research Worksheet Name: Jessica Panton Student Number: n9451765 Tutor: Susan Bothmann Statement of Authorship: In submitting this work I declare that, unless otherwise acknowledged, this work is wholly my own. I understand that my work may be submitted to SafeAssign and consent to this taking place. Part 1 Question 1: Identify four (4) key words/phrases you…

Words 2689 - Pages 11

Research and Study Essay

Assessment Part 1 Ethical Protocols The purpose of this essay is to produce guidance for educational researchers in relation to ethical protocols that should be followed. When conducting research it is vital to provide all participants with a Code of Ethics. Ethics are very important in any kind of research. Ethics is defined as a set of moral principles or values. It distinguishes between what is good and bad; determines moral duty and obligations; and establishes principles of conduct for an…

Words 3301 - Pages 14

Childbirth and Screening Tools Essay examples

women. The intervention is the use of depression screening tools. The comparison intervention is maternal education. The outcome is preventing and treating postpartum depression. Literature Search I began my literature search by using the following nursing and health databases on the USF Gleeson Library: CINAHL and PubMed. I also utilized Google Scholar. I used the key words “postpartum depression”, “postnatal depression”, “screening tools”, “maternal education”, “teaching” and “prevention”. Many…

Words 1772 - Pages 8

Advancing Equity In Clinical Preventive Services

1 Division of General Internal Medicine and Geriatrics, Department of Medicine, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL 60611, USA 2 Robert H. Lurie Comprehensive Cancer Center of Northwestern University, Chicago, IL 60611, USA 3 Institute for Public Health and Medicine, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL 60611, USA 4 Center for Advancing Equity in Clinical Preventive Services, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago…

Words 9218 - Pages 37

Mexican Health Paradox Essay

possible to oppress these people. However, there is an issue emerged in the recent studies of scholars which points to the serious impairment between the health state of a Mexican American and the US born Americans. Despite the overall opinion, today’s research reveals that the state of health of Mexican Americans is much better than the health of average American born inhabitants. Such a paradox is especially strange taking into account the state of modern health care system in the country. In addition…

Words 7506 - Pages 31