Essay on Obedience and Conformity Experiments Response

Submitted By tyywilson123
Words: 1020
Pages: 5
Open Document
Obedience and Conformity Experiments Response

Dietrich Bonhoeffer once said, “Only he who believes is obedient and only he who is obedient believes”. In the experiment videos we watched, the subjects had obedience and believed in the authority figure in each setting. If these subjects did not believe or be obedient to the authority figure, the experiment would not have worked. I feel like obedience to an authority figure is something that is naturally instilled in us. When we were younger, we were compelled to obey our parents as they stood for an authority figure in our lives. If Milgram and Zimbardo were to conduct these experiments again today, I think that they would receive similar results, although slightly decreased with compliance to obedience and conformity as they did the first time the experiment was conducted. People have changed in many ways since these experiments originally took place, but with regards to conformity, people would still act in the same ways. These experiments showed that people will conform passively and even sometimes unthinkingly to both the instructions and roles that authorities figures provide, even if they are inhumane and wrong. If these studies took place at Point Loma, I think the results would still be the same. No matter what the people will say, how they would never conform to inhumane acts like these. This is evident in some aspects of every day life, such as fashion or sports. One clothing trend becomes popular and you can start seeing people conform to that trend. Another example is sporting teams. When a professional sports team becomes popular, by winning a national title, more and more t-shirts and hats of that team start popping up around campus. From a Christian perspective, I think these experiments are a good reminder for us in our journey with God, as long as no one gets hurt mentally or physically. First of all, it is good for us to take a step back and question who we are following or being obedient to. If it is a false idol or some other god or leader causing evil, we should recognize that as wrong and turn away from it. But if it the one true God then there should be no problem. Second, it is a good for Christians to realize not to get too caught up in their selves. Such as in the Zimbardo experiments the subjects started feeling they were actually the people they were pretending to be within just a few days. The prisoners started to play the role of actual prisoners, as they conformed to what the prison guards were saying and acting. This showed that this was a situational attribution that these prisoners were displaying. Meaning, that it seemed the subjects were responding to the situation rather than the prisoner’s individual thoughts and personalities, caused the subjects to behave in the way they did. At this point these results from the Zimbardo experiment are very similar to the results with the Milgram experiments. Signifying, that ordinary people fulfill orders to inflict pain, weather it be the prison guards or the electric shocks that were thought to be pain. These people all put on different personalities when confronted with a new and different environment. In others words, these people are conforming in these experimental situations. That can be dangerous as a Christian if we put on a personality that reflects the environment we are placed in. Since the environments around us are continually changing, it is important for us to stay true to who are personalities truly are. For Christians and for people here at Point Loma, obedience will probably be stronger than compared with other groups of people. This is because here at Point Loma we are constantly reminded of scriptures of the Bible whether it is in chapel or the classroom or in everyday residential life. Most of the time these scriptures have to with obedience and following or giving up control to
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Obedience and Conformity Experiments Response

Theories Of Conformity

Conformity is a type of social influence that causes a change in your beliefs or behaviour in response to a real or imagined social pressure. Insko et al (1985) stated that there are two main psychological reasons for why people may conform. The first reason is normative social influence which means that we conform because we want to be liked or have the approval of others or to be accepted into a group. The result of normative influence is that the person may publicly agree or go along with the…

Words 2371 - Pages 10

Conformity And Obedience Essay

Conformity and Obedience The term Social Influence is used to describe what happens when an individual’s opinions, behaviours of emotions are affected or changed due to the influences of another person or persons. This might be Normative Social Influence or Informational Social Influence. Normative often results in compliance as people often put their own opinions to one side and go along with the majority whereas informational could well be minority led, as it is based on an informed point of view…

Words 837 - Pages 4

Essay on Conformity and Obedience

Conformity and Obedience Task: outline and evaluate findings from conformity and obedience research and consider explanations for conformity (and non-conformity), as well as evaluating Milgram’s studies of obedience (including ethical issues). The following essay will be about understanding what is meant by and distinguishing the differences between the terms conformity and obedience. It will show the evaluation of two key psychological studies which seek to explain why people do and do not conform…

Words 3311 - Pages 14

The My Lai Massacre: A Crime Of Obedience

responsibility for their actions, no matter how morally unjust (Kelman and Hamilton 1989:230). These soldier’s actions become so routine that they do not even think of the repercussions or consequences that follow. These soldiers can fit into any of the conformity categories. They are all heavily influenced to conform by the authorization, routinization, and dehumanization that military units like this are susceptive to. The soldiers involved in the My Lai Massacre overlooked any objections they may have…

Words 1303 - Pages 6

Milgram Experiment

Stanley Milgram, in 1961 as a twenty-seven year old associate professor, conducted a series of experiments that would explore social theory, authority, and obedience, the findings of which would influence and continue to influence psychology’s approach and understanding of these subjects. the exploration of Milgram’s studies delve into the way we understand social influence and deindividualization while the reaction of the blind participant opens a dialogue regarding cognitive dissonance. Inspired…

Words 1083 - Pages 5

Discuss research into conformity Essay

Discuss research into conformity (8 marks) – Theory based NSI/ISI ZIMARDO WITTENBRINK AND HENLY This is a direct form of social influence where the individual has less choice in whether they give way or not. (obedience to authority) The individual is faced with the choice of whether to comply with a direct order from a person with higher status, or whether to defy the order. Social Influence Motivation Obedience Direct order from someone with perceived authority Fear of punishment, belief…

Words 328 - Pages 2

Essay on Obedience: Asch Conformity Experiments

Obedience. In July of 1963 a psychologist by the name of Stanley Milgram eternally sealed his fate in psychological journals almost over-night with a single study, the obedience to authority figures experiment. The original point and intended purpose of the experiment was to see how long a subject would inflict pain on another in order to please an authority figure. The entire experiment was designed to answer the increasingly relevant question at the time, “Could the Nazi’s have just been following…

Words 830 - Pages 4

Socialization Paper

That need for acceptance often serves as motivation for our behavior in group settings. Conformity and obedience are two phenomenon that have produced some disturbing results in various social experiments that have been conducted over the years. Some experiments have shown how people will often change their responses, even when they believe they are correct, simply because the majority of people in the experiment gave a different answer. Whether it was out of fear of being ridiculed if they were indeed…

Words 468 - Pages 2

Holocaust: Nazi Germany and Asch s. Essay example

Everyone nowadays has a vague analysis and understanding of the Holocaust. The views about the killers are various. Psychologists and sociologist with the help of some famous historians studied the behaviors of the killers and through their different experiments they tried to explained those behaviors. One the other side, the victims of the Holocaust ave their own opinion about their murderers. General approach of the killers Battalion 101 or 101 Unit Policemen and officers were middle-aged family men from…

Words 2465 - Pages 10

From Honor Roll To Wannabe Gangster

was called “From Honor Roll to Wannabe Gangster”. This episode aired on June 10, 2022. The first psychological theory I am writing about is the operant conditioning theory, by B.F. Skinner. The other psychological theory I am writing about is the conformity theory by Solomon Asch and Stanley Milgram. PHIL EPISODE This episode of Dr. Phil is about a boy named Aidan. He was once an honor roll student and also an athlete. His mom and sister brought this to Dr. Phil as a last-ditch effort. This was due…

Words 972 - Pages 4