Essay on on opposite spectrums

Submitted By jvillar
Words: 667
Pages: 3
Open Document
The war against animal inequality (defined by some, as humans being morally more significant than nonhuman animals) has begun. Peter Singer, in his article “Ethics and Animals” makes a few valid points. The way that these animals are treated on factory farms is indeed horrendous and should definitely not be occurring in the 21st century. But, to compare animals to humans is completely preposterous. Bonnie Steinbock in her paper “Speciesism and the Idea of Equality” stated, “ human beings have a different moral status from members of other species because of certain capacities which are characteristics of being human. We may not all be equal in these capacities, but all human beings possess them to some measure, and non-human animals do not. For example, human beings are normally held to be responsible for what they do.”(Steinbock 252) I’ve never witnessed a lion on trial for murdering a gazelle or a cat cleaning up a mess that it made. This by no means condones the torture and suffering that animals may go through, but it does show a sense of moral superiority.
Singer’s argument is that humans being superior to animals in sense of reasoning and other intellectual capabilities, is not enough to justify the line we draw between humans and animals. He argues that if reasoning and intelligence are the only characteristics which dictate whether you live a life of pain, that of an animal,or a human one, then infants and people with profound mental disability who clearly lack these skills have to be subject to that life of pain as well. He believes that this idea justifies the use of infants and people who are mentally ill for painful and lethal scientific research instead of animals who are superior to such. ( Singer 2) Evidently, Singer does not know the purpose of scientific research. We spend millions perhaps even billions of dollars a year on scientific research for the benefit of humans. So it would be very contrary to use humans and risk harming them, when our ultimate goal is to save and benefit their lives. Steinbock agrees that, “If we can free human beings from crippling diseases, pain and death through experimentations which involves making animals suffer, and if this is the only way to achieve such results, then I think that such experimentation is justified because human lives are more important than animals lives,” a point which Singer fails to acknowledge. (Steinbock 253)
Even though, Singer may not agree, intelligence is definitely a factor in how we treat others. Just take a look at society, anywhere that one tries to apply for a
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on on opposite spectrums

Electromagnetic Radiation and Negatively Charged Particles Essay

substance that allows electricity or heat to flow through it easily 4) Electrical energy: one of the most useful forms of energy. It is used in heat and light, which are two very valuable things that would be difficult to live without 5) Electromagnet spectrum: the wide range of wavelengths from lower frequencies such as radio waves, short wave, AM, FM, TV, and radar to infrared rays, visible light and ultraviolet, and, finally, the shorter wavelengths of x-rays and gamma rays 6) Electrons: negatively…

Words 360 - Pages 2

The Friar In Geoffrey Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales

morality would be the Knight and the Friar. Whereas the Knight fully personifies his esteemed, noble archetype, the Friar is the exact opposite of his. Through the perfect depiction of the Knight, Chaucer praises the profession, and through the immoral, hypocritical Friar, he criticizes the Church and its upper constituents. The Knight and the Friar are complete opposites, and as such, they show both the good and the evil of society during the Middle Ages. From the Knight’s introduction in the General…

Words 673 - Pages 3

The Role Of Bias In The News

society apart. The first one is the conservative or republican side. This means to be “Disposed to preserve existing conditions, institutions, etc., or to restore traditional ones, and to limit change” (Dictionary.com). The second side on the opposite end of the spectrum is to be liberal or democratic. To be liberal is to be “Favorable to progress or reform, as in political or religious affairs” (Dictionary.com). Our population today feels the need to pick sides and with bias in the news, it can add more…

Words 1015 - Pages 5

Rhythm National Analysis: Interpretation Of Music

Music is different, powerful and open to interpretation. We as humans, can hear the same type of music as the person sitting right next to us, but have completely different interpretations of the sounds. For some, we love it right away and instantly feel attached to it. There is something about it, something that makes our minds drift elsewhere and our bodies tingle with joy. But just as one human can fall in love with the sound, another can instantly be turned off by it. We can’t explain it completely…

Words 638 - Pages 3

Old: English Language and Mirror Perfect Twins Essay

Much of history is dotted with brave, shining examples of revolutionaries that rise up against governments who dare to oppose them. Yet how are revolutionaries so different from terrorists like al-Qaeda? How can these two rebels be on the opposite sides of the spectrum of moral and immoral? For example, George Washington is hailed as a founder of our nation since he led the American revolutionaries against the British. On the surface he seems to be a man who could not stand injustice, but he was a British…

Words 719 - Pages 3

Comparing The Vietnam War: The Beatles And The Rolling Stones

who created anthems for anti-war, pro-peace protests, despite having no direct involvement in The Vietnam War in their home country. The Beatles and The Rolling Stones are on two opposite spectrums of the rock genre, with The Beatles being more “soft” rock and The Rolling Stone being more “hard” rock; however, both spectrums were able to connect with a common cause of protest against the war. Noting that both are in different domains of rock, Beatles band member, John Lennon, exudes a more passive stance…

Words 875 - Pages 4

Comparing Mercutio In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

of the play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare. Mercutio is a scene stealing character in this play being the complete opposite of his friend Romeo, but without Mercutio Romeo’s core values of love would not be projected for the audience or reader to feel. Romeo is a believer of the idea of “true love” .Mercutio is not and on the complete opposite side of the spectrum. Mercutio can see how Romeo is heartbroken over another women early on in the play but mocks his friend by making fun of the…

Words 308 - Pages 2

Autism Spectrum Disorders Essays

Jennifer Sladky SPD 160 Article #1-Due 8/28/13 Autism Spectrum Disorders “Autistic spectrum disorders refer to a range of disorders related to the core disorder of autism and including Asperger’s syndrome” (Lewis 110-121). The ASDs have 3 things in common. They all have impairments in the areas of social and emotional understanding, all aspects of communication, and the flexibility in thinking and behavior. The actual core of autism has been acknowledged for 60 years. ASDs have not been recognized…

Words 810 - Pages 4

Logical Persuasion In Advertising

“When you do things right people wont be sure you've done anything at all.” -God, Futurama Advertisement is the first wave of attack in the business world and in most cases it will spell out the beginning of an empire or the fall of dynasties. But what makes an advertisement effective and is there any way to break it down into a formula to use. Many great minds have worked almost endlessly to breakdown the way to grab keep and profit from the consumer by simply observing testing and researching the…

Words 988 - Pages 4

Historical References In George Orwell's 1984

As I've been reading the historical references may not appear directly but appear indirectly in the novel. Orwell wrote 1984 just after World War II ended, wanting it to serve as a warning to his readers. He wanted to be certain that the kind of future demonstrated in the novel should never come to reality, even though the practices that contribute to the development of such a state were abundantly present in Orwell's time. The society in 1984 depicts the political ideas of the societies that existed…

Words 209 - Pages 1