Open Lunch Policy

Words: 513
Pages: 3
Open Document
Ensuring student safety while maintaining operational efficiency poses a significant challenge for school leaders, as demonstrated by the scenario at Oak Creek High School. The debate over whether to maintain or close the open lunch policy involves weighing concerns over liability, student safety, business interests, fairness, and student rights. This essay examines these complex issues and explores potential compromise solutions.

Superintendent’s Concern over Liability: The superintendent’s concern over liability is justified considering the potential risks associated with open lunch policies. The data presented regarding automobile accidents, substance abuse, gang activity, and rumors of sexual activity during lunch hours highlight the tangible safety hazards that students face when off-campus without supervision.

Balancing Business and …show more content…
While students have certain rights, such as freedom of movement, these rights are not absolute and must be balanced with the school’s obligation to provide a safe environment for learning.

Liability and Foreseeability: If the school maintains the open lunch policy and a student is badly injured, both the school and the school leader could face expanded liability due to foreseeability. By acknowledging the known risks associated with open lunch and failing to take appropriate action to mitigate those risks, the school and its leaders could be held accountable for their negligence.

Compromise Position: A potential compromise position could involve implementing stricter supervision or safety measures during open lunch periods. For example, the school could designate specific off-campus lunch areas with supervision, provide transportation to nearby restaurants, or implement safety education programs to mitigate risks associated with off-campus
Show More

Related Documents: Open Lunch Policy

Motor Vehicle Crashes: Major Lull Policies In The United States

SCHOOL OFF-CAMPUS LUNCH POLICIES AND ADOLESCENT MOTOR VEHICLE CRASH RISKS Accession Number: 00989211 Availability: Elsevier Science Publishing Company, Incorporated 655 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10010 USA Find a library where document is available Order URL: http://worldcat.org/issn/1054139X Abstract: The purpose of this study was to examine differences in motor vehicle crash involvement for teenagers in communities with and without school policies enabling teens to…

Words 378 - Pages 2

Open Campus Lunch

to leave the premises during designated lunch schedules has a major effect on adolescents. Not being able to leave once for a break during a school day could increase inactivity from exhausted students. Lethargic and hungry teens have the potential to change socialization between students that have rushed lunch periods. (Our turn: Would teenagers benefit from having recess? www.mlive.com , 2010). Parents would argue the complication of why open campus lunch for students is conflicting is the issue…

Words 973 - Pages 4

Open Lunches Research Paper

Introduction: Should open lunches be allowed in high schools? Many people have said that when teenagers are allowed to eat outside of school, it helps reduce stress and anxiety. Many people feel that open lunches can be very beneficial for students in high school. On the other hand, many people believe open lunches are a bad idea for teenagers, and kids should stay in school the whole day. This topic is a very controversial subject, many sides are discussed and everyone has an opinion on each. This…

Words 1627 - Pages 7

Off Campus Lunches

food that you are craving instead of the same options at school every day. Two national reports on school policies, published in 2007 and 2016, indicate that, respectively, only 25% and 37.1% of U.S. high schools have open campus policies. There are plenty of benefits to why it would be a great idea to allow students to go off campus to get food. Allowing students to have an off-campus lunch can have several benefits. Firstly, it promotes independence and responsibility as students learn to manage…

Words 184 - Pages 1

Suspended From School

Suspended from school because of bringing cuticle scissors to open a wrapper at lunch? Teen in Georgia expelled for talking to his mother on the phone? (For which he hadn't heard her voice in 30 days because she was serving in Iraq) These two circumstances sounded outrageous to me the first time I read them. Both these situations involve the zero tolerence discipline policy. The policy is an arguably correct way to train children in the school world. It accepts no excuses regardless of the circumstance…

Words 140 - Pages 1

Nutrition and Lunch Essay example

Assignment 2.2: Changes to Lunch and Breakfast Menus Jerrell Cook Professor Michelle James English Composition 115 5/19/14 Changes are underway in your child’s school with the Breakfast and Lunch menus. The number of students who don’t eat healthy meals and we are going to change that. I understand that parents will wonder how these changes are going to affect their children as far as getting breakfast and lunch. We can gladly say that prices on lunch and breakfast will go up, which means…

Words 903 - Pages 4

School lunches need a monitor Essay

there is still the issue of implementation. The issue of regulating school lunch has three fundamental areas of concern for society, which are health, economic and social. With these three there still remains the central issue that the USDA does not have a method to insure that the standards are being followed, some schools are unable to budget for healthier options and parents can thwart the system by sending a packed lunch. How well the adoption of healthier school lunches performs requires cooperation…

Words 2405 - Pages 10

Essay on Reflective Account on the Importance of Non Verbal Communication in an Acute Setting

Introduction This assignment is a reflective account of my first experience when assisting a patient to eat lunch. For the purpose of this assignment I will refer to this patient as Mrs C to maintain confidentiality and comply with the NMC code (2008). It will discuss the importance of non-verbal communication when providing effective nursing care to the elderly. As a framework for this reflection I am going to use the Gibbs (1988) Reflective Cycle which uses 6 stages; description, thoughts and…

Words 1588 - Pages 7

Essay about Company X Version 3

Company X you will understand your position with the Company very rewarding and productive. Our success is very much depended upon the loyalty and dedication of you the employee; we are very much selective in choosing new employees of our team. The policies and procedures in this handbook are in effect at the time of publication. Your appointed supervisor or manager will be happy to answer any questions you may have at any time during your employment here. This handbook provides helpful and useful…

Words 2506 - Pages 11

Interprofessional Team

often feel obligated to be available to their patients at all times. Nurses are often overworked at the same time. According to the Workforce Institute (2017), the three top causes of nurse fatigue include excessive workloads, being unable to take lunch/dinner breaks, and not being able to take any breaks during the shift at all. Peters talks about compassion fatigue in the Nursing Forum, which has a direct relationship with risks associated with patient care. As fatigue increases, mistakes and safety…

Words 3399 - Pages 14