Ottoman Brothers Analysis

Words: 1186
Pages: 5
Open Document
Notions of Brotherhood throughout the Late Ottoman Period:

In Ottoman Brothers, Michelle Campos attempts to dispel the misconceived notion of the role of ‘ethnic nationalisms’ in the last Islamic Empires disintegration. By utilizing a wide range of sources, Campos illustrates how the Ottoman Empire was far from a ‘prison of nations’, where ‘natural nationalisms’ slowly deteriorated the national composition. That it was, in contrast, a melting pot of ethnicities sharing in the faith of newly acquired liberties. Campos’s specific focus on Twentieth-Century Palestine highlights the broader challenges faced by the evolving empire as a whole. Amongst these challenges is the overall failure of the Ottoman bureaucracy to deliver the promises …show more content…
The usage of the term Ottoman after the revolution is indicative to the changes that were taking place. Instead of referring to the bureaucratic elite, as in they, Ottoman was now reflected in first person, as in ‘we’ and ‘us’. As Campos cites, “this bond of kinship and brotherhood was seen as having been born of the revolution, literally through the constitution and through the bonds of imperial citizenship.” The practice of this new citizenship was captured in local councils of the CUP. Due to the CUP’s involvement in restoring the constitution, they were seen as the bearers of modern citizenship and thus attracted a considerable following. As a result, many local branches of the committee began to spring up after the revolution across the empire. Membership to these committee’s was religiously diverse, but was dominated in age by younger members of the white-collar middle class establishment whom were products of the modern education system. The religious diversity is seen in the leadership of the Jerusalem branch, which elected a ten-member leadership committee of five Muslims, four Christians, and one Jew.
Foreign infiltration was amongst the hottest topics circulating through Ottoman society post revolution. This is due, in part, to the prevalence of capitulations and how they affected local Ottoman trade and prosperity. Long standing privileges awarded to foreign coffers left Ottomans virtually unable to compete economically. Although Ottomans were not able
Show More

Related Documents: Ottoman Brothers Analysis

Responses Of The Muslim Ruling Elites

India Africa Asia Reactions to change: 1. Refusal 2. Acceptance 3. Tolerate it 4. Protest it The Ottoman Empire * By the 1800’s, it was weak * In 1830, Greece won its independence and Serbia won the right to govern itself * European nations eyed what remained of the empire * Russia hoped to win control of the Black Sea * 1850’s—Ottomans lost almost all of their land in Europe and parts of Africa * European imperialism took three forms in the early nineteenth…

Words 411 - Pages 2

Dbq Ap World History

the region and explain the path it took to independence. With the beginning of World War I, Britain place Egypt under it’s direct control with the purpose of protecting the country during the war. Egypt prior to World War I was legally park of the Ottoman Empire while Britain maintained a presence in the country the late 19th century. England imposed control over local trade, and attempted to reform the local cotton trade. This was met with initial contempt, followed by resistance from members of…

Words 369 - Pages 2

Stansberry Scott Unit 4 Writing Assignm Essay

Qutb, born in Egypt in 1906, joined the Muslim Brotherhood amidst the recent collapse of the Ottoman Empire. He experienced an emergence of what he believed to be secular, western-influenced governments in the Middle East, and efforts of the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine. Sayyid Qutb had a relatively normal childhood growing up in Asyut Province, Egypt. He attended the western-styled university, Dar al-Ulum where he met the Muslim Brotherhood founder – Hasan al-Banna. Banna influenced…

Words 1089 - Pages 5

Iran's Government Like To Describe It As An Islamic Democracy

PO 380 Midterm Paula Sanchez 10/20/2014 7. Iran’s government likes to describe itself as an “Islamic democracy.” Is this a fair characterization? What features of its political system are—or are NOT—democratic? In your opinion, can democracy and theocracy be blended? Is it reasonable for foreign governments to think that they can push Iran towards embracing democratic reforms? If yes, how? If not, why not? Traditionally, the debate on whether or not religion and democracy can be blended is not…

Words 2632 - Pages 11

Rise of Islam Essay

The Rise of Islam Oasis Towns and Desert Life Islam appeared in the Arabian Peninsula, part of southwest Asia, which is mostly desert. Bedouins, or nomadic herders, adapted to the conditions of the desert. They regularly traded with people from oasis towns like Mecca. Mecca is located in Western Arabia. Mecca was a thriving pilgrimage and economic center. It was a market town at the crossroads of two routes, one that linked S. Arabia to India and to Syria and Palestine on the Med. Coast, and the…

Words 2814 - Pages 12

History Of Lebanon

II once said, “We wish to declare before the world the importance of Lebanon, its historical mission, accomplished down the centuries. A country of many religious faiths, Lebanon has shown that these different faiths can live together in peace, brotherhood and cooperation.” Indifference in Lebanon has seemed to become inevitable. Beirut, the capitol, has been destroyed and rebuilt seven times. War and combat has shaken the land for many years due to religious conflict and political strife. Although…

Words 879 - Pages 4

Israel and United Nations Essay

sparked his inspiration to create the Muslim Brotherhood, one of the largest Islamist party. The Muslim Brotherhood was created in March of 1928, which focused primarily on utilizing the Quran as the as a reference point in maintaining the values of the Muslim community. The Muslim Brotherhood advocated piety and the cleaning-up and reorganization of Egypt through the use of charitable events and gradually building the institution. The more the brotherhood began to evolve, the more it focused on its…

Words 1338 - Pages 6

History 600-1850 Essay

Five Pillars of Islam – core practices and beliefs of every Muslim. Found clear expression in the Quran. Undergirded Islamic practice and gave the imperial system a doctrinal and legal structure and broad appeal to diverse populations. Caliphate – political institution of the early Islamic state. Signified both the political and spiritual head of the Islamic community. Rose as the successor to Muhammad’s leadership. Muhammad – former trader. Went to Mecca where God gave him revelations. Preachings…

Words 718 - Pages 3

Syllabus of Jus1234314 Essay

inspired by Obama’s speech, began with great optimism only to become 4 years later what many are now calling the “Muslim Winter”. Libya is now an unstable region fractured by militias and conflicting world views; Egypt is controlled by the Muslim Brotherhood and its government is opposed by the moderate liberals who began the revolution; Syria is wracked by a bloody civil war; Yemen is unstable; Iraq and Afghanistan are barely functioning states; Iran is aggressively pursuing a policy that puts it at…

Words 1902 - Pages 8

Young Moshe's Diary Essay

later. Furthermore, during World War One the Middle East was just beginning to become volatile, this is due to the intervention of Western Countries, especially the British. Great Britain convinced countries in the Middle East to revolt against the Ottoman Empire, which at the time was allied with Germany.…

Words 1696 - Pages 7