Essay on Part B Platos Criticisms

Submitted By EleanorRawson
Words: 807
Pages: 4
Open Document
‘A’ Level Philosophy and Ethics
Notes

Criticisms of Plato’s Theories
Plato’s Analogy of the Cave
Plato used the Analogy of the Cave to criticise the unphilosophical and to
“get back” at the rulers of Athens who had executed his tutor, Socrates. He argued that the world that we perceive is a world of illusions, of “shadows” of the “real” world of the Form. He thought that every object in our world corresponds to its Form in the World of Ideas.
Criticisms

Plato believes that our experience of the Form pre-dates our experience of the “real” object.
Aristotle, Plato’s pupil, was critical of this idea – he believed that the “Form” is developed through continued experience of physical things.

Is the World of the Form Reasonable?

It does not seem reasonable that we have access to this
“World of Ideas”. It may be reasonable that there can be
“perfect forms” of concrete objects, and those ideas can exist eternally, whereas the concrete objects are subject to constant change.
§ There could be concepts of perfection – beauty, justice and the good – but Plato’s argument that there is a world where these concepts exist seems unreasonable.
§ Are these concepts simply a way of understanding the world around us? If this is so, they exist only in the realm of language, and not in a real “World of the Form”.
§ Plato argues that the World of the Form is “self-evident” – most people would disagree! Self-evident is usually taken to mean that there is evidence that is incontrovertible!
Assuming there are Forms of all the things in the world – what are these forms like? If, as Plato claims, they are self-evident , then their nature should be self evident too.
There would be no debate over the nature of the Form of the Horse – we would all know it.
§ Does the World of the Form also include the Form of the
Cockroach and Smallpox Virus?

How do things in the real world relate to their Forms?

We can imagine there being a “Form of the Horse” to which the objects in the real world refer to.
§ Does the single Form refer to all objects, or does each object have its own form?
§ If the single Form of the Horse is perfect, are the varieties of horses different through their imperfections, or is there an individual form for every horse, mule and donkey ever to have lived?

Criticisms of Plato’s Theories

Plato believed that the highest form is the Form of the Good. He believed this
Form to be like the sun in the Allegory of the Cave – it illuminates all the other forms. All the other forms are a derivation of the Form of the Good. We recognise things in our world which are “good”, but they are still oart of the contingent world and subject to change. We know they are good because we have knowledge of the Form of the Good.
Criticisms

How do we know what goodness is? There doesn’t appear to be complete agreement on this!
§ There is an argument over relative and absolute ethics.
§ Society’s values change – over time and also in
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Part B Platos Criticisms

Is Aristotle Right to Say Virtue Is a Mean? Essay

According to Plato the soul has three aspects or parts. Does Plato put forward good arguments in support of this tripartition? In Book 4, Plato gives us an account of the sou and he delves into this again in books 8 and 9, but for the purpose of this essay I shall focus on book 4 as it is here we get the most substantial argument for the tripartition of the soul. Hi argument is based on a number of premises; namely that the same thing cannot be characterized in the same respect, in relation to…

Words 1703 - Pages 7

Essay on Philosophy outline

instruction • What does Plato want to prove with these three arguments? Plato wants to prove the error of skepticism and relativism • What are the Platonic Forms? The forms are not anything we can smell, taste, touch, or see, but that is not to say they are unreal or imaginary. You can’t know what is not, for the simple reason that in that case there is not anything there to know. You can only know what is; if you do know something, there must be something in reality for you to know Plato agrees with Parmenides…

Words 2004 - Pages 9

Essay Idealism in Education

in the East and to Plato in the West. Generally, Idealists believe that ideas are the true reality. According to them, the human spirit is the most important element in life. Matter is not real. It attaches great significance to the study of man and his mind. It maintains that the material and physical universe is subordinate to a higher type of reality, a spiritual universe. CHIEF EXPONENTS OF IDEALISM (I) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) (vii) (viii) The Videc Rishis of India Plato – (427-347 B.C) Kant…

Words 2944 - Pages 12

Aristotle: Epistemology and Knowledge Essay

God Pontos- Sea-God Kronos- Son of Gia and Ouranos. Mythic Language A) Metaphor, analogy B) Animistic forces in nature. C) Polythesism- Believes in more than one Gods. Act as personified forced of nature. Pre-Socrofic Philosopher Thales ---> 626-545B.C. Believes water basic to human life. air, fire, earth. Water is always an eternal element A) Rationa Argument B) Natural Cause - (Not Divine) C) Natural Elements behavior---> Water -->Air. Democritus (460-370…

Words 1541 - Pages 7

Iwc1 Literature, Arts and Humanities Essay

Multiple Choice The historical revival of Classical culture began during the: a) Middle Ages b) Renaissance c) Baroque Era d) Romantic Era Feedback: The correct answer is b. The historical revival of Classical culture began during the Renaissance. Question 2: Multiple Choice Which of the following was a key feature of ancient Chinese humanism? a) An emphasis on theoretical philosophy. b) A subordination of intellectual life to religious faith. c) An elevation of intellectual life…

Words 10011 - Pages 41

The Design Argument - as Level Essay

a. Outline the Key Concepts of the Design Argument [21 marks] The design argument is also referred to at the Teleological Argument stemmed from the Greek work ‘Telos’ meaning end or purpose. It is an ‘A posterior’ argument (from experience) based on our empirical senses and it is synthetic meaning that it is from observation. The argument is also inductive meaning there a number of possible conclusions. The main basis of the Teleological argument is based on a designer commonly known as ‘the…

Words 3129 - Pages 13

What Is Psychology?

effect is the name given to a type of subjective validation in which a person finds personal meaning in statements that could apply to many people. Philosophical roots of psychology: • 2000 years ago Greek philosopher Socrates and his followers Plato and Aristotle wrote extensively about all kinds’ human thoughts, feeling and behaviour, and human nature in general. Nature vs. nurture debate: • The influence of the genes we inherit from our biological parents compared with that of our various…

Words 4380 - Pages 18

Law 12 Notes Essay

By Bridget Walsh Legal Literacy Actus reus- latin for guilty act, must be voluntary Mens reus- latin for guilty mind, intent Obiter dictum- opinion necessary for the decision of a case Ratio decidendi- latin for reason for decision Style of cause- part of the title of a case referring to the parties involved Stare decisis- latin for rule of precedent Conciliation- a voluntary method of settling disputes whereby an impartial 3rd party mediates Voir dire- trial within a trial Patriate- to bring back…

Words 4154 - Pages 17

An Experimental Comparison of Dispute Rates in Alternative Arbitration Systems Author Essay

An Experimental Comparison of Dispute Rates in Alternative Arbitration Systems Author(s): Orley Ashenfelter, Janet Currie, Henry S. Farber and Matthew Spiegel Reviewed work(s): Source: Econometrica, Vol. 60, No. 6 (Nov., 1992), pp. 1407-1433 Published by: The Econometric Society Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2951527 . Accessed: 26/12/2012 14:25 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms…

Words 8840 - Pages 36

Essay on Qualitative Research Methods

Therefore, a researcher uses four factors: creates research questions, investigates tactics, sets up variables, and predicts an outcome. There are three types of case studies: (a) an instrumental case study focuses on the general aspects of the case; (b) an intrinsic case study focuses on understanding the details of the case; and (c) a collective case study which allows a researcher to compare multiple cases within a single research (Stake, 1995). The commonality among the three types of case studies…

Words 13344 - Pages 54