Essay about Perception and External Things

Submitted By imalazyfuck
Words: 1294
Pages: 6
Open Document
Handout 27: Hume’s Skepticism II: The External World
Philosophy 322: Modern Philosophy
Professor Geoff Pynn
Northern Illinois University
Spring 2011
1

the “universal and primary opinion of men”

The “natural” or “common” view about the external world and our knowledge of it consists of two parts. First, that the external world exists independently from us; second, that we are directly aware of this world in sensory experience.
Both quotes from the Enquiry, Section XII, Part 1 (AW 594b):
“It seems evident that men are carried by a natural instinct or prepossession to repose faith in their senses, and that without any reasoning, or even almost before the use of reason, we always suppose an external universe which does not depend on our perception, but would exist though we and every sensible creature were absent or annihilated.” 1. It is “natural” to believe that there is a world outside of ourselves; i.e., that:
(a) The world doesn’t depend on my perceiving it in order to exist.
(b) The world would exist even if I didn’t.
(c) The world would exist even if all “sensible creatures” ceased existing.
(Interesting question for Hume: if these beliefs are the result of “natural instinct”, are they innate? In his earlier book A Treatise of Human Nature, Hume gave a very detailed empiricist account of where they came from (in Section i.4.2); short version: they come from the imagination. Now, they simply result from “natural instinct or prepossession”.)
“It seems also evident that when men follow this blind and powerful instinct of nature they always suppose the very images presented by the senses to be the external objects and never entertain any suspicion that the one are nothing but representations of the other. This very table which we see white and which we feel hard is believed to exist independent of our perception and to be something external to our mind which perceives it.”
2. It is also “natural” to take our sensory impressions to be the external objects themselves.
(In the second sentence, Hume is using the phrase “this very table” to refer to our sensory impression of the table—which we naturally take to be the table itself.)
1

2 “destroyed by the slightest philosophy”
“But this universal and primary opinion of all men is soon destroyed by the slightest philosophy which teaches us that nothing can ever be present to the mind but an image or perception, and that the senses are only the inlets through which these images are conveyed, without being able to produce any immediate intercourse between the mind and the object. The table which we see seems to diminish as we remove further from it. But the real table which exists independent of us suffers no alteration. It was, therefore, nothing but its image which was present to the mind. These are the obvious dictate of reason and no man who reflects ever doubted that the existences which we consider when we say this house and that tree are nothing but perceptions in the mind and fleeting copies or representations of other existences which remain uniform and independent.” (AW 594b)
1. The big claim here is that philosophical reflections leads to representationalism; the view that: (a) The objects of sensory awareness are “in the mind”.
(b) Those objects represent external (“real”, “independent”) things.
2. Why should we believe that the objects of sensory awareness are in the mind, and not external things?
(a) Hume gives the Argument from Perceptual Variability
i. The “table” present to my mind gets smaller when I move away from it. ii. The real table doesn’t get smaller when I move away from it. iii. So, the “table” present to my mind ̸= the real table. (By Leibniz’s Law)
(b) More famous: the Argument from Illusion
i. Consider the Rotating Snake illusion of Akiyoshi Kataoka. ii. The object I am aware of is moving. iii. The external thing (in this case, the colored shapes on the page / screen) is not moving. iv. So, the
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Perception and External Things

Section 13 Section 14

This follows from the assertion that substances flow from God as isolated notions, all holding views of the entire universe and of every perception they experience. Each perception arises from those which came before it, in a regression of mental states to that substance's inception. Therefore, were one to view the notion of a substance in its entirety, one would find every event, or predicate, of that substance…

Words 1500 - Pages 6

Nussbaum Perceptions And Needs Summary

which is strongly correlated to our sensory perceptions, and system of beliefs. She groups the possibilities of beliefs, and perceived objects that can cause an emotion in to four possible categories, as necessary, sufficient, or constituent (as fully, or in other parts). However, she rejects that perceptions and judgements are necessary, sufficient, or constituent (of other parts) to cause an emotion. Rather, Nussbaum focuses that belief and perceptions are wholly constituent to the emotion. Within…

Words 752 - Pages 4

John Locke Research Paper

observation...perceived and reflected...is that which supplies our understandings...of thinking”(Rauht, Pg. 63). Sensation is a sensible object that coneys a specific perception such as texture, taste, and color. Locke indicates that understanding is derived from the external objects around one’s self and therefore produces one’s perception of those objects and the world. Furthermore, knowledge comes from reflection, which is an internal sense. The internal senses are when we think, doubt, perceive, believe…

Words 937 - Pages 4

Attribution Theory Essay

What is attribution theory? Explain the process the manager will use to form judgements about employee job performance? When we observe people we attempt to explain why they behave a certain ways. Judgements or perceptions are influence by the assumptions we make about a person’s internal state. An attempt to determine whether an individual’s behaviour is internally or externally caused. Internally under persons control Externally behaviour we imagine the situation force the individual…

Words 451 - Pages 2

Garry Winogrand The Animals

of diverse possibilities, individuals have differing methods to run after their contentments, the feeling of satisfied and delighted. Undoubtedly, the difficulty of the choices we choose are mostly depend on our tendency to follow our perceptions or allowing external forces to influence our conclusions. The photograph, “ the Animals”, taken by Garry Winogrand has significantly demonstrates the contrast between being in charge of the way to pursue happiness and permitting outsiders to be in the driver’s…

Words 696 - Pages 3

Empiricism And Knowledge

particular sensible objects, do convey into the mind several distinct perceptions of things, according to those various ways wherein those objects do affect them. And thus we come by those IDEAS we have yellow, white, heat, cold, soft, hard, bitter, sweet and all those which we call sensible qualities; which when I say the senses convey into the mind I mean, they from external objects convey into the mind what produces there those perceptions. This great source of most of the ideas we have, depending wholly…

Words 821 - Pages 4

Brand and Perception Essay

the role of consumer’s perception in marketing decision Introduction It is universally acknowledged that people live in world where physical sensations spread up every corners such as odour, taste, sounds . Those sensations can be transformed by marketers into advertisements, product packages,TV commercials, billboards to clamour for customers’ attention. Each of us is exposed to this bombardment through paying attention to marketing stimulus and select satisfied one( Solomon et al, 2006). When…

Words 3165 - Pages 13

George Berkeley's Argument Analysis

In the mind of an ordinary, non-philosophical individual, the mind and body are looked as being one complete system. Nonetheless, in the case of George Berkeley he argues that the only things that prevail as being real are our minds, thoughts and feelings. His main arguments that he presents are focused around the idea of subjective realism, whereby he argumentatively states that in order for one to evoke sensations of an object then it must be existent in the mind, or at least some part of it. In…

Words 1050 - Pages 5

Paper Perception Motivation Behavior

Perception, Motivation, and Behavior – Week 3 Organizational Behavior – BSA 532 October 7, 2014 Perception allows us to experience the world around us and is very important in Organizational Behavior (OB). It is defined as “a process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment” (Robbins, S., & Judge, T.). Some individuals may not be as conscious as they should be about perception because they may not realize how…

Words 996 - Pages 4

Notes On Learning Styles Inventory

1/ Session 1 & 2 Learning Styles Inventory Visual: you learn by reading or seeing pictures. You understand and remember things by sight. You can picture what you are learning in your head, and you learn best by using methods that are primarily visual. You like to see what you are learning. Auditory: learn by hearing and listening. You understand and remember things you have heard. You store information by the way it sounds, and you have an easier time understanding spoken instructions than…

Words 1231 - Pages 5