Essay on Pharmacology and Discussion Case Question

Submitted By Betsy-Butler
Words: 1355
Pages: 6
Open Document
Case 5: Discussion Case Question 1
Do you believe that Merck acted in a socially responsible and ethical manner with regard to Vioxx? Why or why not? In your answer, please address the company’s drug development and testing, marketing and advertising, relationships with government regulators and policymakers, and handling of the recall.
There is considerable controversy surrounding this case study; I believe problems in the pharmaceutical industry continue today due to politics and lobbying. Overall, I believe that Merck acted in a socially responsible and ethical manner with regard to Vioxx. According to Gilmartin (2011), “After analyzing the data further and consulting with outside experts, the Merck scientists recommended that we voluntarily withdraw the drug. They said that it might be possible to go to the FDA, add warnings to the label, and keep Vioxx on the market, but they believed that the most responsible course of action in the interests of the patient was to voluntarily withdraw the drug. I, along with the rest of my management team and the board, agreed with the recommendation, and the drug was withdrawn.” As for management of the recall, I believe it was done well, without pomp and circumstance and in a manner that focused on the patient rather than the loss the recall was going to have on Merck.
In my opinion, if Merck had been focused on revenues, it would have gone back to the FDA to simply add more warnings to the label to keep Vioxx on the market. Instead, the corporation withdrew the drug and forfeited those revenues in the best interest of patients.
As for Merck’s drug development and testing, something seems to be fishy. At one point a scientist raised concern but those concerns weren’t followed up on. According to Winslow and Johnson (2008), “The reports, based on internal Merck documents that surfaced during litigation over its withdrawn painkiller, Vioxx, reprise some allegations the company faced in courtroom testimony. But researchers said the studies provide an unusual inside look at how pharmaceutical companies can use academic collaborators and medical journals as important tools to market their drugs. They also fuel a growing debate over drug companies' conduct in controlling and reporting results of clinical trials.” It seems that Merck may have swept this concern under the rug which I believe is unethical. That said, sometimes information is not known by the right parties.
In thinking about the corporation’s approach to marketing and advertising, all pharmaceutical companies provided ‘gifts’ to promote goodwill among physicians. Merck cannot be singled out for this approach. However, $422 million is a considerable about of money to have spent on marketing one drug to physicians. Merck also cannot be singled out for using celebrities to market its product as other pharmaceutical corporations did the same thing. I struggle with television advertising because there is simply not enough time to disclose the amount of information that should be disclosed in a 30 second spot. I think the quote from Hank McKinnell, CEO of Pfizer, as quoted by Lawrence and Weber (2014), says it all, “I’m beginning to think that direct-to-consumer ads are part of the problem. By having them on television without a very strong message that the doctor needs to determine safety, we’ve left this impression that all drugs are safe. In fact, no drug is safe.”
The relationships Merck has with government regulators and policymakers is clearly strong. According to Lawrence and Weber (2014), “Merck spent $40.7 million on lobbying between 1998 and 2004.” That is an impressive amount of money spent in six short years. I do not believe these types of relationships to be healthy as it has a negative downstream impact on physicians and patients.
Case 5: Discussion Case Question 2
What should or could Merck have done differently, if anything?
There are a handful of things that Merck could have done differently in the handling of
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Pharmacology and Discussion Case Question

MSN Meeting Reflection

Initial meeting with Dr. Best was informative and engaging. Discussed course syllabus, expected learning outcomes and schedule for Accelerated Bachelor of Science in Nursing or ABSN track of NUR 309 Pharmacology Interventions course. Active participation of the faculty during the BSN meeting pertained to advising, registration, curriculum committee and requirements for Institutional Review Board or IRB process. Capstone presentation of MSN student on purposeful hourly rounding: An evidence-based…

Words 838 - Pages 4

Muscle Spasticity: A Case Study

For this weeks discussion, I will focus on the concept of baclofen for the treatment of muscle spasticity. Working as a pediatric nurse, baclofen was a common medication given to our patients who had cerebral palsy. This medication was commonly given orally or through the g-tube by the nursing staff. However, with advancements in medicine and technology, it was not uncommon for patients to have an intrathecal pump in order to deliver continuous doses of baclofen to control severe muscle spasticity…

Words 803 - Pages 4

Computer Ethics

our personal preference and personal information. From the IPad® to touch screen computers, there exists many opportunities for individuals to steal your information from your computer without anyone being the aware what has happened to them. The question that arises that coms to my mind is, “How can we be sure that the person that has access to my personal information will behave in an ethical manner?” Ethics is a set of moral principles that govern the behavior of a group or individual. Therefore…

Words 843 - Pages 4

Historical Perspectives For The Dilybility To The Development And Expression Of Mental Health Disorders

Single-subject research • Case Studies: detailed exploration of rare events (ex. P. Gage) • Help generate causal hypotheses • Allows test of causal hypotheses • Difficult to generalize to others Multiple Subject Observational Research • Population Studies (e.g. epidemiological NCS-R) • Note: Prevalence is always greater than incidence • Multiple group studies: Correlation • Correlational research style o defining characteristics of interest o Question is: is the correlation meaningful…

Words 1084 - Pages 5

Research Paper

25099373 CNF15_3 Research Methods Research Proposal Word Count: 1210 A look into the Memory Retention: Can stimulants increase a person’s memory? A quantitative research proposal. For this research proposal, memory will be looked into to see whether a person’s memory can be increased via the intake of stimulants. This quantitative research will then look into whether there are any future benefits in consuming stimulants if memory is found to be increased. There is already research similar…

Words 1359 - Pages 6

Essay on Nursing Care Plan and Module

[pic] School of Health and Wellbeing Undergraduate Module Guide Module title: Adult Nursing Practice 1 Module code: NH2309 Module Leader: Marina Kendrick Academic year: 2012/2013 Cohort 111 Welcome The members of the module team would like to welcome you. We hope that you enjoy the learning opportunities and experiences that this module provides. We aim to provide you with support…

Words 6931 - Pages 28

Designer Babies Essay

the words “Eugenics” and “Master Race” have been used, it fails to address the overall breakthroughs and benefits that science is making in genetics that seek to ensure a chance for a healthy life. Topics such as stem cell research have had open discussions in the public’s eye the need for further education is needed. The benefit of being able to genetically modify a child before birth to ensure a healthy child far outweigh the concerns against genetic modification. Where we are in terms of genetic…

Words 2227 - Pages 9

Mental Health Assessment Essay

Assessment Questions Some questions I would ask Mary during my assessment are: 1. “Have you now or in the past ever taken any medication for depression, anxiety, or other mental disorders?” This would set a baseline for her as far as what meds have worked and which haven’t, as well as find out if she had any type of adverse reactions or side effects to any medications in the past. We would be able to narrow down the right drugs to prescribe that will have the best therapeutic effects to help her…

Words 2690 - Pages 11

Ethics Reflection Essay

Ethics Reflection Agnes Annette Ghan Capella University ED 8112 u03a1 General Characteristics of Qualitative and Quantitative Research Methods In scientific research, there are two basic methods used primarily in research studies by educators: qualitative research primarily utilizes the application of inductive reasoning, while quantitative research applies deductive reasoning. Each of these methods will be explored with regards to ethical considerations within the research design. In many…

Words 3200 - Pages 13

Nurse Prescribing V150 a Case Study Essay

UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF SCOTLAND NURSE PRESCRIBING V150 CASE STUDY COURSE: NURS09125 BANNER NUMBER: B00113677 DATE OF SUBMISSION 13/12/10 COURSE LEADER FRANCES DOWNER WORD COUNT: 3745 CONTENTS PAGE 1. INTRODUCTION & GENERAL OVERVIEW, Pgs3-4. 2. ASSESSMENT PROCESS, Pgs 5-8 3. TREATMENT OPTIONS, Pgs 9-12. 4. EVALUATION, Pgs 13-16 5. CONCLUSION. Pg 17 6. COPY OF PRESCRIPTION, Pg 18 7. REFERENCE SECTION, Pgs 19-23 8…

Words 4598 - Pages 19