Poems Comparison Essay

Words: 2464
Pages: 10
Open Document
ICCSE ENGLISH LITERATURE POETRY COURSEWORK

In the poems you have studied a recurring theme is that of ‘loss’. This can take many forms: death; identity; hope or loss of innocence

Discuss the poets’ treatment of any aspect of the theme of loss in at least 6 of the poems you have studied.
A minimum of 3 poems should be taken from the anthology.

Poems for discussion:
In detail
- Prayer Before Birth (Louis MacNeice)
- Do not go gentle into that good night (Dylan Thomas)
- A mother in a Refugee Camp (Chinua Achebe)
Referred to
- Poem at Thirty-Nine (Alice Walker)
-Death Of A Son (Jon Silkin)
-Mid Term Break(Seamus Heaney)

Loss is universal. An inevitable condition of life; you cannot have one without the …show more content…
Despite this, an overwhelming sadness is still felt at the end of the poem due to the contrast between the on-going metaphor of the boy being a house and the descriptive writing that is coupled with it, and then the simplicity and shock of the fact that “he died”.
“Poem at Thirty-Nine” approaches death as a form of loss as well; however this is a memory of a loss rather than the reactions to an immediate or pre-empted loss. Walker describes some of the simple day to day actions that remind her of her father such as “writing deposit slips and checks”. Death is dealt with very simply as she has had time to come to terms with this loss and is honest as she exclaims “how I miss my father” in the first line of the poem. The free-verse structure creates a more relaxed feel while the enjambment reflects the spontaneous thought pattern. However when she writes more philosophically and emotionally punctuation is used to show the deeper thought, “He would have grown to admire the woman I’ve become: cooking, writing, chopping wood, staring into the fire.” The use of the word “would” subtly gives the impression that her relationship with her father was not very strong and that “many of” her “truths must have grieved him before the end”. This changes what would have been an affirmation of his life into something more poignant, concerning potential conflict.
In “A Mother in a Refugee Camp” there is a sense of false hope due to the inevitability of the child’s death.
Show More

Related Documents: Poems Comparison Essay

Poem And Supernatural Comparison

Text Connections to “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain” TEXT TO TEXT: “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain” vs Supernatural I connected the poem, “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain to the television show Supernatural. Both the poem and Supernatural have similar character traits; a few similar characteristics include mystery, death, and escape. Both the poem and Supernatural connect, or relate to one another as they both contain mysterious tensions. For example, in Supernatural, the first episode of the first…

Words 699 - Pages 3

Comparison of the Poems Quickdraw and Manhunt Essay

Essay Both poems explore strong feelings about their partners. The poem Quickdraw expresses dislike and rage towards the Duffy partner, as she compares their relationship to being like a duel in a Western film, whereas in Manhunt the poem explores feelings of shock and sympathy as the female persona, Laura, tries to reconnect with her husband after his return from war due to injury. In Quickdraw there is a fractured relationship presented to us. The poet reveals this as there is no rhyming…

Words 1152 - Pages 5

Hide & Seek Poem Comparison

Separation? Poets tend to form poems that mirror their lives and its circumstances in numerous ways. The subject of detachment and separation are present in many poems, however it is demonstrated distinctively in accordance to the backgrounds of the writing. Through analysing, I will show the differences and similar features in the poems "La Belle Dame Sans Merci" by John Keats, "Remember" by Christina Rossetti, and "Hide & Seek" by Vernon Scannel. These three poems will likewise be compared relation…

Words 2004 - Pages 9

Literature Comparison Between a Short Story and a Poem Essay

Literature Comparison between a Short Story and a Poem Gian Carlo O. Dela Cruz Literature Comparison between a Short Story and a Poem Literature? This form of entertainment had been around for ages, whether be in a form of a Poetry, a Drama or a Short Story. This Type of literature had been used by Poets and Authors to convey their deepest desires, feelings, Ideas, amazing imaginations which makes us, whoever we want and an escape to daily normal life and with this making it humorous…

Words 2144 - Pages 9

Comparison Of Cinderella Stories And 1 Cinderella Poem

Today I’ll be telling you about 3 different Cinderella stories and 1 Cinderella poem. The first story is “Ashenputtel” which occurred around 100 years ago in Germany. Then we’ll talk about “Yeh-Shen” which occurred around 1,000 years ago in China. After that we’ll talk about “The Algonquin Cinderella” which occurred around 100 years ago in a Native American tribe. The last thing we’ll talk about is the poem that was wrote in the modern age. All righty let’s get the ball rolling with “Ashenputtel”…

Words 400 - Pages 2

Poem Comparison: Dawes Vs. Paul Revere

Next, there were many differences of the facts that were presented in the two texts. According to the poem,it says “Hang a lantern aloft in the belfry arch of the North Church tower as a signal light, --- One, if by land, and two, if by sea,”(PBS# 9-11) This explains that Paul is letting his friend know that the British are coming by land and by sea because he sees them coming by both land and by sea. According to the article, it says “Over the years, Dawes’s relative anonymity has become something…

Words 194 - Pages 1

Comparison Of Longfellow, Emily Dickinson, And Walt Whitman's Poems

Prompt #1 In the poems written by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Emily Dickinson, and Walt Whitman these three poets share similarities and differences using literary devices such as mood theme and structure. In the poem “A Psalm of Life” celebrates life and all it demands. It encourages one to make something out of life instead of waiting for the end. The theme of the poem is embedded within these lines “Lives of great men all remind us we can…

Words 573 - Pages 3

Comparison and Contrast Essay Between Two Poems of Emily Dickinson and Mary Oliver

Comparison and Contrast Essay between two Poems of Emily Dickinson and Mary Oliver Emily Elizabeth Dickinson, or called Emily Dickinson for short (1830 – 1886) and Mary Oliver (1935), are the two poets who contributed great works of art to American society during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. In spite of several characteristics that can be found in both Emily Dickinson and Mary Oliver poems, there are undeniably things that distinguish them from one another, although outside…

Words 1294 - Pages 6

Essay about Comparison between movie full metal jacket and the poem like a winding sheet

I chose the movie Full Metal Jacket which to me has a common theme as to the poem Like a Winding Sheet due to the violence that takes place due to frustration. In the movie Full Metal Jacket during Marine boot camp when Sargent Hartman very hostile personality gives each of the marine’s nicknames; one of the recruits Lawrence was a tall and heavier set male that he named “Gomer Pyle” (Kubrick, 1987). The Sargent gave most of them not to nice names, one marine he was more mean and violent to than…

Words 815 - Pages 4

Comparing Babies To Tulips: A Narrative Poem

write an 18 lined poem, I consider this poem a narrative poem because it has characters and it tells a little story of a baby being born. this poem is a closed poem that follows a rhyme scheme of A,A,B,B,C,C,D,D,E,E,F,F,G,G,H,H, I,I. this is a free verse poem and doesn’t have strict unstressed/stressed pattern. This poem contains similes such as on line one when it compares babies to tulips. There is also another comparison at the bottom of the poem in the last two lines. The comparison there is saying…

Words 232 - Pages 1