Political Sectarianism

Submitted By justkarim
Words: 1155
Pages: 5
Open Document
To be sure, the issue of political sectarianism and the prospects of reform have divided Lebanese society since the country’s independence. In fact for much of the Republic’s modern history, religion has been the maidservant of political expression whereby primacy subsumes democratic procedures. But how has public attitude toward this issue emerged? More importantly, what variations, if any, can we draw between the various sects?

When asked whether or not today was the right time to eliminate political sectarianism in Lebanon, respondents were sharply divided: 49.1 percent found the time to be somewhat or very suitable; 40.7 percent disagreed; and 10.1 percent were somewhat indifferent. Upon closer analysis, these divisions proved to be anything but arbitrary.

|In general, do you think that today is the right time to eliminate political sectarianism? |
| |Frequency |Percent |Valid Percent |Cumulative Percent |
|Valid |very suitable |197 |33.6 |35.3 |

Not surprisingly, this divergence among the respondents was found to be primarily driven by sectarian affiliation. The survey showed that Shi’ites expressed the most enthusiasm for deconfessionalization, whereas Christian confessional groups, and to some extent the Sunnis, were much more hesitant to abolish the current system (see Table below for percentages).

Sectarian affiliation remains a strong determinant of attitude toward political reform, particularly with regards to political deconfessionalisation. Overall, 65.5 percent of Shi’ites found such reforms to be very, or at least somewhat, suitable compared to only 20.9 percent of Maronites and 49.1 percent of Sunnis.

If Lebanon’s current demography is any indication, this polarity clearly reflects the deep-seated concerns of the Christian community of being relegated into a political minority, assuming that a proportional representation electoral system emerges in place of the current one. (Perhaps demography) Muslims, on the other hand, and particularly the Shi’ites, are much more eager to translate their demographic advantages into political gains. According to Dr. Salamey, “Christian fears and Sunni hesitancy may have further been consolidated as a result of the contemporary rise of ‘political Shi’ism.’” Regardless of the reason, the common denominator underlying this apprehension seems to stem from fear of political marginalization. As a result, many sectarian partisans cannot bring themselves to deal forthrightly with a system that may potentially undermine their political power.

Another consideration lies well outside of Lebanon, on the international horizon. If the domestic balance of power is tilted in favor of one sectarian group over another, regional calculations may undergo an equally dramatic paradigm shift. This will surely have resounding implications on external aid in the form of financial, military, political and diplomatic support for both the Lebanese state and its substate actors. And of course, one cannot discuss the regional implications without accounting for the Israeli factor, for no Lebanese is naïve enough to ascertain that political reform can be had without an increased threat in security. Thus the topic of political reform amongst Lebanese is one that cannot be viewed in a vacuum lest its multiple dimensions are ignored.

In the absence of a unified social contract, many Lebanese have come to view various policy initiatives through a sectarian prism. This is clearly reflected in the above data whereby the atmosphere of mutual distrust amongst Lebanon’s sects has been nothing short of palpable, creating a stalemate ultimately defined by political paralysis, social discord and conceptual
Show More

Related Documents: Political Sectarianism

Comparative Study Of Texts And Contexts

Module A: Comparative Study of Texts and Contexts -compare texts in order to explore them in relation to their contexts -effects of contexts & questions of value (morals, ethics, principles) First Value -> 1st text -> 1st paragraph ->2nd text -> 2nd paragraph -> draw links to 1st text -> 3rd paragraph -> analysis: what’s changed? Second Value : As above -Talk about similarities AND differences -Topic sentences: This text reveals this value about this context Second text: how…

Words 1040 - Pages 5

Comparative Religion Study Essay

I believe in ‘Islam’ and whoever believes in Islam is called Muslim. There are lots of people who are Muslim because their parents are Muslims, I learned about Islam from my parents at the early of my life. The more I grow up the more I learn about it and also other religions. I searched why it is need to learn religions in so many different ways? I always feel better when I learn something new, so learning about some other religions also. I felt religion is the one way to stay on the right path…

Words 1379 - Pages 6

Hamlet Comparative Film Study Essay

Hamlet Comparative Film Study Topic 1: the portrayal of the King and Queen: How are the moments leading up to their deaths presented? Does this direction suggest the audience should convict them or absolve them-or a combination of the two? Topic 2: the portrayal of the entrance of Fortinbras: how is this important entrance staged? How has the director interpreted Fortinbras role in the conclusion of the tragedy. Due to the popularity of Hamlet, many versions of it have been made in film and theatre…

Words 1025 - Pages 5

Module A: Comparative Study Of Texts And Context

Module A – Frankenstein and Blade runner Module A: Comparative Study of Texts and Context This module requires students to compare texts in order to explore them in relation to their contexts. It develops students’ understanding of the effects of context and questions of value. Each elective in this module requires the study of groups of texts which are to be selected from a prescribed text list. These texts may be in different forms or media. Students examine ways in which social, cultural…

Words 504 - Pages 3

A Bottlenose Dolphin: A Comparative Study

The reproduction between a squid and a bottlenose dolphin is similar. For example a male squid first has to attract a women and does this by swimming early in the morning and swim rapidly while forming large circles. Female squids then join to swim in the circle while the colors of a male squid change to attract the female , then mating takes place. There is a ink sac which is hidden under a set of glands and works as a shell for the eggs. In males , they have a shorter arm and this is how he places…

Words 478 - Pages 2

Essay Comparative Study of Online and Offline Trading

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL MANAGEMENT CENTRE FOR AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT STUDIES TAMIL NADU AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY COIMBATORE-641003…

Words 5499 - Pages 22

Essay on English Assignment Comparative Study

The inevitable desire for control and power throughout society stems from an individuals longing to decide their own fate. This yearning for control is explored both in Alfred, Lord Tennyson’s ‘The Lady of Shallot’, ‘Tears, Idle Tears’ , ‘In Memoriam - Cantos XVI, XVII, XVIII,XIX’ and Jessica Anderson’s prose fiction text ‘Tirra Lirra by the River’. These texts look at women and artists inability to gain power, the loss of control of emotions and the absence of control in the world. After close analysis…

Words 1049 - Pages 5

Comparative Study Of HUL P G Www Essay

PROJECT I. OBJECTIVES Study culture and climate of The HUL AND P & G. Study The Financial Activities And Share Market. Study The Marketing Strategies of HUL AND P &G. Study The Shares Procurement System Of HUL AND P &G. Study The Drawbacks And Plus Points Of HUL AND P &G. To get practical touch to theoretical knowledge. To study on the assessment of working capital. To study on Capital profitability management. Compare Competitors Identify…

Words 6545 - Pages 27

A Comparative Study On Smoking Between Science And Non-Science Majors

Running Head: Smoking between Science and Non-Science Majors A Comparative Study on Smoking between Science and Non-Science Majors Student’s name North Lake College Abstract There has been a great talk about what do you fear the most. This study evaluates which one out of the two things that you fear most. Those people fearful of spiders reported having a family member with similar fears, but the study was unable to separate genetic factors from environmental ones. According…

Words 953 - Pages 4

Comparative Study of Teamwork at Toyota Manufacturing Company and Microsoft Company Essay

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF TEAMWORK AT TOYOTA MANUFACTURING COMPANY (TMC) AND MICROSOFT COMPANY (MSC) 1. Introduction Modern and prudent organizations realize that the best way to achieving business goals, effectively and efficiently, is to organize work in definable units by pulling together various talents and skills. In fact, Ian Brook (2003) confirms that no one can be the best at everything, however when all of us combine our talents, we can be the best at virtually everything. Palmer, A…

Words 2475 - Pages 10