Presentation: Means of Production and Labour Essay

Submitted By Hassan-Badreddine
Words: 893
Pages: 4
Open Document
Essentially Marx is saying that looking at population would be a very generic image of the whole.
By looking at it like this empirically, concrete would dissolve into abstract. State --> DOL, Money, etc

HE DOES SAY LATER THAT THIS METHOD DID HAVE HISTORICAL VALUE
(THIS WAS THE METHOD OF 17TH C – PETTY AND DE BOISGUILLEBERT)

18TH C Economists
Marx says “there began the economic system, which ascended from simple relations such as labour, DOL, etc, to the level of the state, exchange between nations and the world market.”

So essentially, if you have the right categories, then Marx states “the journey would have to be retraced until I had finally arrived at the population again, but this time not hte chaotic conception of a whole, but a rich totality of many determinations and relations”

Musto kind of puts a sidenote here, and says that theres been a lot of different commentaries about this, but although Marx says that this is the “scientifically correct method”, this does not mean it is the one he emploeyd.

Musto says that Marx didn't believe as strongly as other economists that reconstructing concrete at the level of ideas was a real reproduction of reality.

MARX SHARES IDEAS WITH HEGEL, BUT THERE ARE RADICAL DIFFERENCES – not going to really discuss that.

Marx continues in the introduction by positing could simple categories exist before concrete ones?
NO – possession of propery, couldn't have existed before something more concrete like family.

But then Marx discusses stronger examples like money and labour... and he says about money – it existed before capital... but its use was primarily for trade – thus it shows it was historical.

Another simple category, and one that is a lot more complicated and Marx spent a lot of time discussing, is labour. He says, “Labour seems a quite simple category. The conception of labour in this general form – as labour as such – is also immeasurably old. Nevertheless, when it is economically conceived in this simplicity, ‘labour’ is as modern a category as are the relations which create this simple abstraction.”

Marx also draws this conclusion from labour because when it is economically conceieved, labbour is as modern a category as are the relations which create this simple abstraction. Thus, in societies today, labour transfers with people, there is no character to it or specific craft... and in regards to wage labour it is purely abstract labour.
And i mean, this is pretty clear today,

Today, when we say labour, it doesn't refer to one job or work, theres so much workers and so much jobs. Lawyer, factory worker, construction worker, etc.

Skillwise – they're pretty unrelated, so now this is kind of an abstract labour. We either think of these jobs as a totality, or individually under this heading of 'labour” - the categories have different meanings in different societies

a really good quote here by marx again is when he says “This example of labour shows strikingly how even the most abstract categories, despite their validity – precisely because of their abstractness – for all epochs, are nevertheless, in the specific character of this abstraction, themselves likewise a product of historic relations, and possess their full validity only for and within these relations.”

Now, Marx turns to the final part of this section. How do we set out these categories? In what order? He says we can't do it historically, we can't order them historically, rather, we have to order them by how they are ordered in modern bourgeois society, which he says “is precisely the opposite of that which seems to be their natural order”... and he concludes with

1) the general, abstract determinants which obtain
Show More

Related Documents: Presentation: Means of Production and Labour Essay

Management Accounting Answers Essay

is because this is a sheet for marking, not specifically a revision aid. The answers to written parts of questions are not laid out as model answers, just indications of what is expected. If you make an error early on in a question it does not mean that you won’t get any marks from then on. There are always marks for method. Jonathan Rooks Management Accounting Systems Main Answers January 2012 11/12 Question One. A. You are to calculate the actual profits under both Marginal Costing…

Words 1532 - Pages 7

202 227 Essay

and size of our logo on the documents is important because if we were to give out documents with stretched out, poorly formatted images then the presentation of our documents wouldn’t look very good. d. Presentation- Presentation of our documents should always be to a high standard because if people were to receive our documents with poor presentation then their interest might fade. Having documents that are presented in an appropriate way makes the company look professional and legitimate. 1…

Words 866 - Pages 4

Impact of Cost Accounting Essay

business unit must strive hard to obtain maximum output with the available input. In order to ensure the optimum utilisation of scarce resources, the value of input is measured against the value of output. This implies matching cost per unit of production…

Words 3133 - Pages 13

Essay on Economics and Political Economy

Assess the contribution of Adam Smith and David Ricardo to the tradition of classical political economy. Political economy is a term coined to explain the manner in which production, consumption and distribution of goods that are desired can be exchanged, are regulated. [Macvickar, J. 1825 p7-8] Adam Smith and David Ricardo are both highly notable classical political economists, promoting the idea of liberal economic theories which lay the groundwork for many of the contemporary economic thought…

Words 2028 - Pages 9

Management Accounting Essay example

associates Control the opening Found procedure changes Board upcoming presentation Interconnect Regulate penalty area Tool By charitable the general presentation fraction that equivalent to one, formerly on a score of one to five, I liken myself with my contestant, general I wasn’t the preeminent but I am control to be the paramount in the business. Demand Forecasting In direct to be my approximate budgeted production estimation of 21250 unit I have used quantitative and formal methods…

Words 1579 - Pages 7

Palm Oil and Body Shop Essay

examine its application to the conduct of individuals in organisations and to the conduct of the organisation as a whole. The tasks that you complete will involve you doing many different things, such as researching information, creating reports, presentations and letters. The learning outcomes of the unit are for you to: 1. Understand the meaning and importance of ethics in the business world 2. Understand the implications of businesses operating ethically 3. Know the social implications…

Words 2475 - Pages 10

Management: Business Ethics and Dr Ross Spence Essay

Tax and Emission Trading Schemes | | 9 – 16/09 | Theories regarding business ethics | Tutorial Exercises | 10 – 23/09 | Ethical issues for the global company | Group Presentations | 11 – 30/09 | The development of Corporate Governance | Group Presentations | 12 – 07/10 | Labour Day Holiday | | 13 – 10/06 | Class Presentations on Uranium Power Project | Research ReportReflective Journal | There will not be a final exam in this subject. 2.3 Teaching methods/strategies Briefly describe below…

Words 1235 - Pages 5

Essay Resource Planning Assignment

Steve Jobs after his tragic death. Apple sells 70% of all those devices via retail shops of which there are 284 locations in 10 different countries. Land | Labour | Capital | * Head-office in California * Offices * Parking area * Warehouses * Restrooms * Reception * Toilets * Garden Area * Design Center * Presentation halls | * CEO * Head Managers * Managers * Designers * Promotional Team * Testers * Sociologists * Cleaners | * Documents * Computers…

Words 555 - Pages 3

Walt Disney Essay

Disney is one of the most recognised icons of modern society, this is of course directly linked to the fact that it is one of the biggest TNC’s on the earth, with is having a whole array of subdivisions, including; marketing, movie production, theme park operation, production of merchandise & many more. However as with every major TNC there are areas of its operations that it is happy for the public to see & those which it is not. One of the main areas of Disney that the public gets to experience…

Words 1184 - Pages 5

Be Able To Produce Information In Appropriate Formats For Decision Making In An Organization

research; government and other published data; by-product data Storage: security of information; data protection issues; ethical issues 2 Understand a range of techniques to analyse data effectively for business purposes Representative values: mean, median, mode; calculation from raw data and frequency distributions using appropriate software; using the results to draw valid conclusions Measures of dispersion: standard deviation for small and large samples; typical uses…

Words 4226 - Pages 17